- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces a flow matching model called LiMemFlow which incorporates memory pathway components of point-wise and pair-wise histories. It tackles the problem of long-horizon lithium-ion transport and outperforms previous approaches across several temperature ranges, especially at 300 K. This 300 K dataset is also a contribution of this work.
Critical strengths
- The results on the long-horizon rollout are encouraging, especially in the newly introduced 300 K temperature range.
- The ablation of the memory results (Table 2) is thorough, providing a better understanding of the memory components of LiMemFlow.
- The computational times for LiMemFlow are also very competitive with other models.
Critical weaknesses
- The writing and presentation style could be improved. As this paper tackles a very specific problem in lithium-ion trajectory prediction, many details will need to be learned by researchers outside this field. This also makes me question the exact suitability of this paper for ICLR. As a note, the previous approaches presented in this paper for comparison are from journals that also allow longer formats.
- A new benchmark for 300 K temperature is also presented for comparison against previous models, which makes the contributions of the paper in the intersection of new model proposition and new dataset. I am wondering if this paper would also be a better fit for a specific benchmark track at a different venue, in my opinion.
Questions for authors
- Based on the Appendix, different settings were used for the 300 K and the 600-1200 K models. Can the authors explain the reasoning behind these differences?
- In Table 2, what does the w/o Memory mean? Does it refer to both the point-wise and pair-wise memory pathways being removed? In the text, it only says "Effect on ranking metrics." on L440, which makes it ambiguous to understand.
- Can the authors elaborate on the time differences of LiMemFlow compared to LiFlow? Both are very efficient, but it would be helpful to understand which part of the model increases the cost in LiMemFlow.