- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a method for generating crystal structures with fewer sampling steps. Instead of predicting only the instantaneous velocity, the author proposes to learn an additional correction for larger sampling steps using a consistency-based objective. This can help avoid expensive derivative calculations and does not require a pre-trained teacher model. Their experiments supports this. Experiments on four crystal structure prediction benchmarks show improved match rates with only 2–5 sampling steps.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses an important practical problem of reducing the computational cost of crystal generation. The proposed method is relatively efficient and comes with theoretical analysis. The experiment results look quite convincing and encouraging.
Critical weaknesses
Although SRTF achieves higher match rates with fewer steps, the generated structures often have larger reconstruction errors. For example, on MP-20, the 5-step SRTF has an RMSE of 0.141, compared with 0.057 for FlowMM. This raises concerns about the trade-off between generation speed and structural accuracy. Since accurate crystal structures are important for practical applications, the paper could better demonstrate whether the few-step results are sufficiently reliable.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors provide a more detailed comparison of the trade-off between sampling speed, match rate, and structural accuracy, especially in the 2–5 step setting?
- Have the authors evaluated the physical stability or validity of the generated crystals beyond structural matching? Would the performance advantages remain after structural relaxation?
3 comments
Thank you for the detailed response. I appreciate the more comprehensive analysis of the trade-off between sampling efficiency, match rate, and structural precision. The matched-budget comparisons and relaxation experiments substantially address my original concerns. In particular, the results showing that SRTF maintains its advantages after relaxation and achieves competitive precision with 10–20 sampling steps are convincing.
Thank you
Thank you for the follow-up. We are glad that the matched-budget comparisons and the relaxation experiments address your concerns, and that the results on precision at few steps and on the advantage after relaxation are convincing. Your questions led us to add the speed–match-rate–precision analysis and the relaxation study, which strengthened the paper. Thank you again for your careful review.
Response to Reviewer 1M5D
Thank you for the encouraging review and the precise questions. Table and appendix numbers refer to the revised PDF; the code is in the supplementary material. RMSE below is StructureMatcher's normalized RMS displacement.
W1 / Q1. Speed, match rate and precision: the five-step setting first (MP-20, full test split, 3 seeds, same backbone and prior draws; Table 18):
Against a much larger budget. Against flow matching at 50 steps, five-step SRTF is less precise on the structures both match (0.130 vs. 0.058), almost entirely through fractional-coordinate error. Lattice error is already at the 50-step level (1.37% vs. 1.31% in lengths, 0.56° vs. 0.54° in angles), while fractional-coordinate RMSE is 0.065 vs. 0.032 and falls to 0.035 by twenty steps; MPTS-52 shows the same pattern. Three remedies are available:
Operating points:
Amortized generation time on MP-20 is 0.26 / 0.66 / 1.31 / 2.62 ms per structure at 2 / 5 / 10 / 20 steps, against 6.30 ms for flow matching at 50. The published FlowMM RMSE of 0.057 is averaged over a smaller matched set (MR₁ 61.4). Our same-backbone flow-matching model at 50 steps matches 68.1% at RMSE 0.070.
Q2. Geometric validity, and robustness across two MLIP relaxation models.
Protocol. We relaxed all samples with CHGNet (FIRE, positions + cell, fmax 0.05 eV/Å, ≤ 500 steps) on a fixed 2000-structure test subset, scoring against the DFT ground truth. Failed relaxations count as unmatched. MP-20 rows: mean of 3 seeds; MPTS-52: one seed (Table 19).
Geometric validity before relaxation:
These are MLIP surrogates, not DFT, as stated in Appendix G.3.
These results address the precision–speed trade-off and show that the few-step advantage survives surrogate relaxation. We are happy to clarify further.