- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a palm-anchored, tactile-refined framework for dexterous grasping. It combines a palm-anchor quality predictor (Where2Grasp), hierarchical diffusion-based grasp generation, and graph-based tactile refinement using an actor–critic policy. The authors also develop a whole-hand tactile simulation infrastructure supporting five robotic hands. Experiments on DexGraspNet report 79.47% and 79.30% success on seen and unseen object categories, respectively. Additional evaluations demonstrate architectural portability across two hands and zero-shot sim-to-real execution.
Critical strengths
-
Well-motivated framework. The combination of explicit palm placement and whole-hand tactile feedback addresses limitations of geometry-only grasp synthesis.
-
Strong simulation results. The method consistently outperforms the evaluated baselines, with component ablations supporting the complementary benefits of palm anchoring and tactile refinement.
-
Useful simulation infrastructure. The whole-hand tactile simulator and morphology-aware graph representation are valuable engineering contributions.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited methodological novelty. The framework mainly integrates established components, including affordance prediction, hierarchical diffusion, graph encoding, and actor–critic refinement. The paper does not sufficiently distinguish its algorithmic contributions from existing grasp generation and tactile refinement approaches.
-
Incomplete comparisons with tactile-aware methods. Most evaluated baselines focus on grasp generation rather than tactile closed-loop refinement. Comparisons with recent tactile-aware grasping approaches under comparable feedback and execution settings are needed to establish the proposed method's advantage.
-
Missing hierarchical diffusion ablation. The paper does not compare its two-stage diffusion generator with single-stage diffusion or simpler anchor-conditioned generation alternatives, leaving the necessity of the hierarchical design unclear.
-
Limited real-world validation. Real-world experiments involve only six objects and 60 trials per hand, achieving success rates of 43.3% and 31.7%. These results provide limited evidence of robust sim-to-real generalization. Furthermore, no real-world ablation isolates the contribution of tactile refinement.
-
Insufficient analysis of tactile representation learning. The tactile encoder is pretrained using masked autoencoding, SimSiam, and force alignment, but the individual contributions of these objectives and the necessity of freezing the encoder are not evaluated.
-
Limited evidence of cross-embodiment robustness. Although the simulator supports five hand morphologies, the learned refinement framework is evaluated on only two, using independently trained policies. This demonstrates architectural reuse but provides limited evidence of robustness across diverse embodiments.
-
Incomplete analysis of refinement reliability. The critic-based acceptance mechanism and no-op option are not quantitatively evaluated. The frequency of rejected refinements and disagreement between critic predictions and actual grasp outcomes remain unclear.
Questions for authors
-
What fundamentally distinguishes the proposed tactile refinement mechanism from existing tactile-aware grasping approaches? Can the authors provide more directly comparable baselines?
-
How does hierarchical diffusion compare with a single-stage diffusion generator under identical settings?
-
Can the authors provide a real-world ablation comparing grasp success with and without tactile refinement?
-
How do the individual tactile-encoder pretraining objectives affect performance? Is freezing the encoder necessary?
-
How frequently does the critic reject proposed refinements, and how well do its predictions agree with actual grasp outcomes?
-
How are real-world tactile signals calibrated and aligned with simulated observations?
3 comments
Thank you again for your time and helpful feedback. As the discussion period nears its end, we wanted to follow up to see whether our response and revisions have addressed your concerns.
Maintaining My Rating
Thank you for the response. I will keep my current score, which I believe is fair and positive.
Thank you for your thoughtful review. We have added experiments and clarified the evaluation protocol. These revisions are highlighted in blue.
W1, W2 / Q1: Tactile refinement and matched-budget baselines
We train the critic on simulated palm-guided diffusion grasps, pairing pose, whole-hand touch at closure, and outcome. A separate variant pairs initial touch with the corrected pose and its outcome (Table 10).
MAT uses successive readings to adjust grasps. Nakahara and Calandra (2025) score regrasps from vision and fingertip touch. Our actor proposes bounded corrections from the pose and touch on the hand’s kinematic graph. The critic keeps the pose or selects one correction before lifting.
Table 9 tests what touch adds over pose alone and compares actor proposals with CEM search (set 0, one scored grasp per candidate).
CEM shares our touch, critic and bounds (~1,000 evaluations/grasp). Our refiner raised success on set 1 (76.6% to 79.2%) and selected GraspQP grasps (44.3% to 47.1%).
W3 / Q2: Two-stage diffusion and anchor-conditioned alternatives
Table 8 uses the same refiner on 125 held-out objects. Learned-anchor variants share the anchor field and sampler.
With learned anchors fixed, two-stage generation gained 0.4 percentage points before refinement and 2.1 afterward over the single-stage model. The unanchored comparison also changes the guidance.
W4, W6 / Q3: Hardware ablation and evaluation across hands
Table 3 compares both conditions on the same ten objects per hand, with ten direct and twenty refinement trials per object. Success required a lift of at least 5 cm and a two-second hold.
Gains were 6.0 and 5.5 percentage points in separate trials. The simulator supports five hand morphologies. Wuji and O6 used the same architecture, with separate training and object sets. Future work could test whether a policy trained on one hand transfers to another.
W5 / Q4: Tactile pretraining objectives and encoder freezing
Table 12 uses fixed candidates and one refiner without paired action–outcome data. We add an unfrozen run below.
Full pretraining showed no consistent advantage among frozen encoders. The additional run suggests freezing is optional in this setting.
W7 / Q5: Correction rejection and critic reliability
In Table 10, all corrections were declined for 43.8% of candidates with paired training and 42.4% without it. A candidate can have several proposals. With paired training, AUROC was 0.70 and expected calibration error was 0.19 on executed simulated grasps. Of corrected initial failures, 33.2% succeeded. Of corrected initial successes, 4.2% failed. The net gain was 208 successes across 4,000 candidates.
Table 11 tests the acceptance rule. The last column covers changed grasps that initially succeeded.
W4 / Q6: Sim-to-real tactile calibration and alignment
The Wuji Hand uses the Wuji Robot Glove, and LinkerHand O6 uses its built-in tactile array. For both, we map normalized taxel intensities to the corresponding simulated link grids. For Wuji, contact-free hand motions calibrate a pose-dependent filter for resting offsets, drift, and glove deformation. We orient and resample its 24 × 32 pressure array over 16 link regions. Normalized intensity fills the depth and normal channels, and both shear channels are set to zero (Appendix D, Fig. 7). This aligns contact location and relative strength. In a replay of 431 simulated failures with contact, retaining measured glove offsets changed 54.1% of keep-or-correct decisions (Fig. 9).