acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Beyond Fingertips: From Palm Priors to Tactile Refinement for Generalizable Dexterous Grasping

Abstract

Learning-based dexterous grasp synthesis has shown strong performance on training distributions, but often generalizes poorly to novel objects even when the generated hand poses satisfy kinematic and force-closure constraints. We argue that pose validity alone is insufficient for reliable grasp execution because it does not explicitly account for palm placement or the contact state established after execution. To address this limitation, we formulate dexterous grasping using three complementary components: pose generation, palm-anchor prediction, and tactile refinement. Our method first predicts a dense palm-anchor quality field over the object surface and uses the selected anchor to condition a hierarchical diffusion model for full-hand grasp generation. The resulting grasp is refined by an actor–critic policy using whole-hand tactile observations organized by the hand's kinematic graph. Our tactile infrastructure and refinement policy share this morphology-parameterized graph interface, allowing the same policy architecture to be instantiated and trained separately for hands with different link counts, degrees of freedom, and sensor layouts without redesigning the tactile representation. Experiments on two hand morphologies, using independently trained policies and hand-specific data budgets, validate this architectural portability. On in-distribution and unseen object categories, our method achieves 79.30% grasp success on unseen objects, outperforming the strongest baseline by 8.0 percentage points. Without real-world grasp training, the method further attains zero-shot aggregate success rates of 43.3% on the Wuji Hand and 31.7% on LinkerHand O6, evaluated on separate household-object sets.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Dexterous manipulation, Tactile perception, Sim to real

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_Y94ROpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a palm-anchored, tactile-refined framework for dexterous grasping. It combines a palm-anchor quality predictor (Where2Grasp), hierarchical diffusion-based grasp generation, and graph-based tactile refinement using an actor–critic policy. The authors also develop a whole-hand tactile simulation infrastructure supporting five robotic hands. Experiments on DexGraspNet report 79.47% and 79.30% success on seen and unseen object categories, respectively. Additional evaluations demonstrate architectural portability across two hands and zero-shot sim-to-real execution.

Critical strengths
  1. Well-motivated framework. The combination of explicit palm placement and whole-hand tactile feedback addresses limitations of geometry-only grasp synthesis.

  2. Strong simulation results. The method consistently outperforms the evaluated baselines, with component ablations supporting the complementary benefits of palm anchoring and tactile refinement.

  3. Useful simulation infrastructure. The whole-hand tactile simulator and morphology-aware graph representation are valuable engineering contributions.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited methodological novelty. The framework mainly integrates established components, including affordance prediction, hierarchical diffusion, graph encoding, and actor–critic refinement. The paper does not sufficiently distinguish its algorithmic contributions from existing grasp generation and tactile refinement approaches.

  2. Incomplete comparisons with tactile-aware methods. Most evaluated baselines focus on grasp generation rather than tactile closed-loop refinement. Comparisons with recent tactile-aware grasping approaches under comparable feedback and execution settings are needed to establish the proposed method's advantage.

  3. Missing hierarchical diffusion ablation. The paper does not compare its two-stage diffusion generator with single-stage diffusion or simpler anchor-conditioned generation alternatives, leaving the necessity of the hierarchical design unclear.

  4. Limited real-world validation. Real-world experiments involve only six objects and 60 trials per hand, achieving success rates of 43.3% and 31.7%. These results provide limited evidence of robust sim-to-real generalization. Furthermore, no real-world ablation isolates the contribution of tactile refinement.

  5. Insufficient analysis of tactile representation learning. The tactile encoder is pretrained using masked autoencoding, SimSiam, and force alignment, but the individual contributions of these objectives and the necessity of freezing the encoder are not evaluated.

  6. Limited evidence of cross-embodiment robustness. Although the simulator supports five hand morphologies, the learned refinement framework is evaluated on only two, using independently trained policies. This demonstrates architectural reuse but provides limited evidence of robustness across diverse embodiments.

  7. Incomplete analysis of refinement reliability. The critic-based acceptance mechanism and no-op option are not quantitatively evaluated. The frequency of rejected refinements and disagreement between critic predictions and actual grasp outcomes remain unclear.

Questions for authors
  1. What fundamentally distinguishes the proposed tactile refinement mechanism from existing tactile-aware grasping approaches? Can the authors provide more directly comparable baselines?

  2. How does hierarchical diffusion compare with a single-stage diffusion generator under identical settings?

  3. Can the authors provide a real-world ablation comparing grasp success with and without tactile refinement?

  4. How do the individual tactile-encoder pretraining objectives affect performance? Is freezing the encoder necessary?

  5. How frequently does the critic reject proposed refinements, and how well do its predictions agree with actual grasp outcomes?

  6. How are real-world tactile signals calibrated and aligned with simulated observations?

3 comments

Thank you for your thoughtful review. We have added experiments and clarified the evaluation protocol. These revisions are highlighted in blue.

W1, W2 / Q1: Tactile refinement and matched-budget baselines

We train the critic on simulated palm-guided diffusion grasps, pairing pose, whole-hand touch at closure, and outcome. A separate variant pairs initial touch with the corrected pose and its outcome (Table 10).

MAT uses successive readings to adjust grasps. Nakahara and Calandra (2025) score regrasps from vision and fingertip touch. Our actor proposes bounded corrections from the pose and touch on the hand’s kinematic graph. The critic keeps the pose or selects one correction before lifting.

Table 9 tests what touch adds over pose alone and compares actor proposals with CEM search (set 0, one scored grasp per candidate).

MethodSuccess (%)
Direct execution75.5
Pose-only refiner (same training data)76.1
Tactile refiner (ours)76.8
CEM, critic score alone73.0
CEM, score minus pose-deviation penalty77.1

CEM shares our touch, critic and bounds (~1,000 evaluations/grasp). Our refiner raised success on set 1 (76.6% to 79.2%) and selected GraspQP grasps (44.3% to 47.1%).

W3 / Q2: Two-stage diffusion and anchor-conditioned alternatives

Table 8 uses the same refiner on 125 held-out objects. Learned-anchor variants share the anchor field and sampler.

GeneratorAnchorsBefore refinement (%)After refinement (%)
Single-stageNone69.675.1
Two-stageUniform72.878.9
Single-stageLearned75.779.7
Analytic palm placement + stage 2Learned75.280.2
Two-stage (ours)Learned76.181.8

With learned anchors fixed, two-stage generation gained 0.4 percentage points before refinement and 2.1 afterward over the single-stage model. The unanchored comparison also changes the guidance.

W4, W6 / Q3: Hardware ablation and evaluation across hands

Table 3 compares both conditions on the same ten objects per hand, with ten direct and twenty refinement trials per object. Success required a lift of at least 5 cm and a two-second hold.

HandDirect executionWith tactile refinement
Wuji Hand36/100 (36.0%)84/200 (42.0%)
LinkerHand O626/100 (26.0%)63/200 (31.5%)

Gains were 6.0 and 5.5 percentage points in separate trials. The simulator supports five hand morphologies. Wuji and O6 used the same architecture, with separate training and object sets. Future work could test whether a policy trained on one hand transfers to another.

W5 / Q4: Tactile pretraining objectives and encoder freezing

Table 12 uses fixed candidates and one refiner without paired action–outcome data. We add an unfrozen run below.

Encoder settingRefinement gain (pp)Failure-detection AUROC
All three objectives, frozen+0.20.74
All three objectives, unfrozen+0.40.77
Without masked reconstruction+0.40.72
Without SimSiam+1.10.72
Without force alignment+0.50.74
Random initialization+0.70.73
Pose only (no tactile input)+0.50.59

Full pretraining showed no consistent advantage among frozen encoders. The additional run suggests freezing is optional in this setting.

W7 / Q5: Correction rejection and critic reliability

In Table 10, all corrections were declined for 43.8% of candidates with paired training and 42.4% without it. A candidate can have several proposals. With paired training, AUROC was 0.70 and expected calibration error was 0.19 on executed simulated grasps. Of corrected initial failures, 33.2% succeeded. Of corrected initial successes, 4.2% failed. The net gain was 208 successes across 4,000 candidates.

Table 11 tests the acceptance rule. The last column covers changed grasps that initially succeeded.

Acceptance ruleSuccess (%)Became failures (%)
Full rule76.24.2
Always accept the actor output76.16.0
Remove the keep-original option76.27.2
Independently seeded acceptance critic76.28.8

W4 / Q6: Sim-to-real tactile calibration and alignment

The Wuji Hand uses the Wuji Robot Glove, and LinkerHand O6 uses its built-in tactile array. For both, we map normalized taxel intensities to the corresponding simulated link grids. For Wuji, contact-free hand motions calibrate a pose-dependent filter for resting offsets, drift, and glove deformation. We orient and resample its 24 × 32 pressure array over 16 link regions. Normalized intensity fills the depth and normal channels, and both shear channels are set to zero (Appendix D, Fig. 7). This aligns contact location and relative strength. In a replay of 431 simulated failures with contact, retaining measured glove offsets changed 54.1% of keep-or-correct decisions (Fig. 9).

Thank you again for your time and helpful feedback. As the discussion period nears its end, we wanted to follow up to see whether our response and revisions have addressed your concerns.

Reviewer_Y94ROpenReview ↗

Maintaining My Rating

Thank you for the response. I will keep my current score, which I believe is fair and positive.

Reviewer_CpXbOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents a dexterous grasping framework combining palm-guided grasp generation with tactile refinement. A pointwise predictor estimates palm-anchor quality from object geometry, using empirical grasp success frequencies in simulation as supervision. The selected anchor guides a factorized generative model that predicts palm position, followed by hand orientation and finger configuration. A graph-based tactile representation and a learned success critic are then used to refine the grasp. The paper reports simulation comparisons, component ablations, and real-world experiments on two robotic hands.

Critical strengths
  1. The framework addresses a practically relevant problem. Combining geometry-based grasp generation with tactile refinement is a reasonable approach to handling contact uncertainty. The paper implements a complete pipeline and evaluates it in both simulation and real-world settings.

  2. The ablations provide evidence that the components help within the proposed system. Removing palm guidance or tactile refinement reduces performance, and the graph-based tactile representation improves over the tested MLP alternative. These results support the practical utility of the design choices in the evaluated setting.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited novelty of palm-anchor guidance and insufficient validation of its supervision. The formulation closely resembles existing spatial guidance mechanisms[1][2][3][4], such as pointwise graspness, affordance-, part-, and saliency-conditioned generation. Its simulation-derived success labels depend on the grasp sampling, finger configurations, and execution policy, not anchor location alone. The paper neither establishes a clear advantage over existing guidance mechanisms nor verifies that these labels remain predictive after tactile refinement.

  2. Unclear validity of the tactile-conditioned refinement objective. The critic evaluates a modified pose while retaining tactile features measured at the original pose. It is unclear whether training includes action-outcome data that supports this prediction, or whether tactile observations are refreshed after executed updates. Since both the actor and the acceptance rule rely on the same critic score, a predicted improvement does not necessarily imply better physical grasping.

  3. Insufficiently controlled comparisons and coverage of relevant baselines. The evaluation does not adequately separate the benefits of the proposed design from additional simulation supervision, tactile observations, and refinement opportunities. Comparisons using the same refinement module or matched sensing and execution budgets would strengthen the conclusions. Relevant robust execution methods, such as RobustDexGrasp[5], also warrant discussion and comparison where applicable.

[1] Jialiang Zhang et al. “DexGraspNet 2.0: Learning Generative Dexterous Grasping in Large-scale Synthetic Cluttered Scenes.” CoRL 2024.

[2] Shiyao Wang et al. “Physics-Aware Iterative Learning and Prediction of Saliency Map for Bimanual Grasp Planning.” CAGD, 2024.

[3] Yi-Lin Wei et al. “AffordDexGrasp: Open-set Language-guided Dexterous Grasp with Generalizable-Instructive Affordance.” ICCV, 2025.

[4] Juntao Jian et al. “G-DexGrasp: Generalizable Dexterous Grasping Synthesis Via Part-Aware Prior Retrieval and Prior-Assisted Generation.” ICCV 2025

[5] Hui Zhang et al. "RobustDexGrasp: Robust Dexterous Grasping of General Objects." CoRL 2025.

Questions for authors
  1. What specific advantage does palm-anchor guidance provide over existing graspness-, affordance-, or saliency-based guidance when using the same downstream generator and comparable training resources?

  2. How are anchor labels constructed, including pose sampling, execution policy, and the number of trials per anchor? How well do these labels predict success after the final tactile refinement procedure?

  3. Is the critic trained on paired examples of current tactile observations, candidate corrections, and their execution outcomes? Are tactile observations updated after each executed correction? Among accepted corrections, what fractions turn failures into successes and successes into failures?

  4. Does the advantage persist when existing generators use the same tactile refinement module, or when competing methods receive comparable sensing and execution budgets?

2 comments

Thank you for your careful reading. The revised manuscript highlights the new experiments and protocol clarifications in blue.

W1 / Q1: Palm-anchor guidance and alternative spatial priors

Palm placement gives all fingers a common spatial reference. A region frequently touched by a fingertip can indicate where contact is useful while leaving open where to place the palm. Our score estimates grasp success when the palm is placed near a given surface anchor. The generator then samples hand orientation and finger configuration relative to that placement.

Table 7 changes only the guidance field. The generator, refiner, sampler, backbone, and training schedule are fixed.

Guidance fieldSupervisionGain vs. uniform after refinement (pp)
Geometric saliencyNone0.0
Analytic graspnessGraspQP grasps−2.4
Contact-map affordanceSame 102,400 rollouts−1.9
Physics contact saliencySame 102,400 rollouts−0.7
Palm-anchor score (ours)Same 102,400 rollouts+3.2

Table 1 uses objects from DexGraspNet. Its successor, DexGraspNet 2.0, inspired the graspness control in Table 7.

W1 / Q2: Anchor labels and their predictive value after refinement

For each of 400 training objects, we selected 32 surface anchors by farthest-point sampling. At each anchor, we placed the palm 31 mm along the outward normal and sampled eight orientation/joint configurations from stage 2. Each grasp closed with gravity off and was held for two seconds with gravity on. The label was the fraction of the eight unrefined trials in which the object stayed above its initial height (102,400 trials in total, Appendices C and E). It estimates success under this generator and execution protocol.

On held-out objects, success rose from the lowest to the highest within-object score quintile, from 70.6% to 75.9% before refinement and from 76.6% to 82.0% afterward (Fig. 6b). With the generator and refiner fixed, learned-anchor sampling raised post-refinement success from 78.9% under uniform sampling to 81.8% (+2.9 pp, Table 6).

W2 / Q3: Critic supervision, tactile updates, and correction outcomes

The main-table critic used pose, touch, and outcome from the same grasp. We added a separate variant with 19,954 executed tuples pairing initial touch, a proposed correction, and its executed outcome. Proposals included actor outputs and magnitude-matched random corrections (Appendix G.2).

Figure 2 shows a repeatable loop. For the reported success rates, all internal updates used the initial closure reading, taken before gravity loading in simulation or lifting on hardware. Before the outcome was known, the critic chose the original pose or one correction. The hand reopened to execute an accepted correction. Each candidate contributed one final outcome, with at most one executed correction and no second decision using refreshed touch.

The paired variant changed 56.2% of candidates (Table 10). Among initially failed grasps that received a correction, 33.2% succeeded afterward. Among initially successful grasps that received a correction, 4.2% failed afterward. From a common 74.0% baseline on 4,000 candidates, the net gains were 208 successes with paired data and 80 without, yielding 79.2% and 76.0% final success. In a separate acceptance-rule test (Table 11), the full rule and an independently seeded critic excluded from actor optimization both reached 76.2% execution success.

W3 / Q4: Refiner transfer across generators and matched-budget comparisons

The unchanged refiner improved grasps from GraspQP. On the 32 lowest-energy GraspQP candidates per object, success under our execution protocol rose from 44.3% to 47.1% (+2.8 pp, Table 9).

Table 9 scores one final grasp per candidate. Results on candidate set 0 are shown below.

MethodUses touchSuccess (%)
Generator onlyNo75.5
Same pose, re-closedNo75.4
Magnitude-matched random correctionNo75.2
Pose-only refiner, same dataNo76.1
CEM, critic score aloneYes73.0
CEM, score minus pose-deviation penaltyYes77.1
Tactile refiner (ours)Yes76.8

The observed refinement gains were +1.3 pp on set 0 and +2.6 pp on independently sampled set 1 (76.6% to 79.2%). CEM used the same touch, critic, and correction bounds, with about 1,000 critic evaluations per grasp.

Table 1 includes GraspQP, GenDexGrasp, and DexDiffuser as baselines. Related Work now discusses DexGraspNet 2.0, AffordDexGrasp, G-DexGrasp, and RobustDexGrasp. As future work, we could execute grasps from the first three in simulation, pair whole-hand touch at closure with lift outcomes to predict stability, and use correction outcomes to train the refiner. For RobustDexGrasp, we could test whether adding a tactile keep-or-correct decision improves first-lift success under the same execution budget.

Thank you again for your time and helpful feedback. As the discussion period nears its end, we want to follow up to see whether our response and revisions have addressed your concerns.

Reviewer_t2wrOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper argues that kinematic and force-closure validity alone is insufficient without explicit palm placement and post-execution contact feedback. The authors propose a framework to predict a dense surface palm-anchor quality field to condition a pose generator, followed by an actor-critic policy that applies bounded residual pose corrections using whole hand tactile observasion. Experiments results shows improvement on unseen object categories in simulation, with good zero-shot sim-to-real transfer success rate.

Critical strengths

The critical strength is its decomposition of dexterous grasping to the pre-contact palm-anchor affordances and post-contact whole hand tactile refinement, unified by a morphology parameterized kinematic graph representation.

Critical weaknesses

I think the critical wekness is that the proposed method doesn't fully resolve the open-loop problem in the grasp generation: The paper's central narrative is that open-loop geometry is insufficient. However, look at what the refinement module actually does, we can notice that, optimizing a pose in latent space against a static initial contact snapshot is not true closed-loop tactile control. It is single-step post-contact heuristic adjustment. At the same time, the method does not explicitly model, analyze or discuss real-world tactile sensor noise, which could further weaken the claim of training the closed loop control.

Questions for authors
  1. How are the simulated SDF queries converted into link-local tactile grids, and how are they aligned with the physical tactile sensor readings during zero-shot transfer?
  2. During both simulation evaluation and real-world deployment, how is the transition from initial grasp q to refined grasp q' physically executed once the hand is already in contact with the object?
  3. What is the real-world success rate when executing the initial candidate grasp directly without the tactile refinement stage?
2 comments

We sincerely thank you for your careful reading of our paper and your constructive comments. We have uploaded the revised manuscript, with additions and revisions highlighted in blue. We clarified the tactile input and execution protocol and added experiments on sensitivity to tactile sensor noise.

W1: Scope of tactile feedback in the reported experiments

In the reported experiments, the hand first closes at the generated pose. The policy uses the measured whole-hand contact to decide whether to keep that pose or apply a bounded correction before lifting. All internal pose updates use the same initial reading. We therefore evaluate whether a single contact observation can improve the grasp before the first lift.

Figure 2 shows how the procedure can be repeated across grasp attempts. After a failed lift, the hand can regrasp, acquire a fresh whole-hand tactile reading at closure, and use it to decide whether to keep or correct the new grasp. In principle, this cycle can continue until a lift succeeds or the procedure is stopped. For the success rates reported here, we allowed at most one executed correction before the first lift. A failed lift ended the trial and counted as a failure. This protocol measures first-lift success under a fixed execution budget.

Q1: Mapping simulated contact and physical sensor readings to link-local tactile grids

In simulation, we ray-cast a fixed grid onto each sensor-bearing link and store the valid taxel locations in the link frame (Appendix D, Fig. 7). At each simulation step, a read-only query of the object’s signed distance field gives penetration depth and a surface normal. Normal force scales with penetration depth. Tangential force opposes relative slip and is capped by the friction limit. We express the four channels (depth, normal force, and two shear components) in the taxel frame, apply signed logarithmic scaling, and place the values on the link-local grid. Non-contact taxels are zero and invalid cells are masked.

On hardware, the Wuji Hand uses the Wuji Robot Glove, and the LinkerHand O6 uses its built-in tactile array. For both hands, we map normalized taxel intensities to the corresponding simulated link grids so that the policy receives contact location and relative strength in the same layout as in simulation. For the Wuji glove, we calibrate a pose-conditioned filter on contact-free hand motions to suppress resting offsets, drift, and signals caused by glove deformation. We align and resample its 24 × 32 pressure array over 16 link regions, use normalized intensity for the depth and normal channels, and set the two shear channels to zero. Each hand’s simulation-trained policy was deployed without training or fine-tuning on real-world grasp data.

Appendix I examines the effect of sensor errors. In a replay of 431 simulated grasps that made contact but failed, retaining the resting offsets measured on the Wuji glove changed 54.1% of the keep-or-correct decisions (Fig. 9). This sensitivity motivates the contact-free calibration. In a separate simulation stress test, refinement improved grasp success over direct execution by 0.4–0.6 percentage points under localized sensor loss or a one-cell grid shift, compared with 0.6 points on clean input. When we added Gaussian noise across the entire tactile array, the gain fell to approximately zero (Table 13).

Q2: Physical execution of the transition from the initial grasp to the corrected grasp

The hand closes at the initial pose qq. We record whole-hand touch before gravity loading in simulation or lifting on hardware (Appendix E). Using this fixed reading, each refiner computes three joint-only updates and two bounded full-pose updates internally. Before the grasp outcome is known, the critic selects either qq or a proposed corrected pose q′q'.

If qq is retained, the hand stays closed and proceeds directly to the hold or lift. If q′q' is selected, the hand reopens in both settings. In simulation, we reset the trial and execute the grasp at q′q'. On hardware, the hand moves to q′q', closes again, and then lifts. Only the selected grasp’s outcome is scored.

Q3: Real-world success rate of the initial grasp without tactile refinement

On hardware (Table 3), direct execution succeeded in 36 of 100 trials on the Wuji Hand and 26 of 100 trials on the LinkerHand O6. With tactile refinement, the corresponding results were 84 of 200 and 63 of 200. Each hand used the same ten objects across its two conditions, with ten direct and twenty refined trials per object. Success required lifting the object at least 5 cm and holding it for two seconds. The observed differences were +6.0 percentage points on Wuji and +5.5 percentage points on LinkerHand O6.

Thank you again for your time and helpful feedback. As the discussion period nears its end, we wanted to follow up to see whether our response and revisions have addressed your concerns.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.