- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a method to convert an input mesh into a set of simple primitives. The paper proposes to use sparse anchors mesh component as a an intermediate representation to ease the fitting of primitive while dealing with hidden/intersecting regions.
Critical strengths
- The insight that a form geometry guided segmentation - here performed trough the proposed anchors - helps more robustly fit primitives
- The final result, as seen from figure 9 for instance, seem significantly better than the base line they compare to
Critical weaknesses
- The manuscript is globally more a description of a system than a well grounded research paper. Most of its content are statement rather than proposition stemming from an analysis of the problem
- It remains unclear whether alternative, simpler segments would not lead to surface regions that are good candidate for the fitting stage
- Little to no care is attached to the geometric analysis: for instance, intrinsic (and even extrinsic) symmetries are ignored (as can be seen in a number of examples, where exact copies of geometries structures get decomposed differently
- I cannot assess how one can control the level of detail of the resulting assembly
- The text is hard to read: short, very compressed sentence and out of the blue statement, as too often produced by LLM in a performative ton
- The papers consider only very recent prior art, and does not discuss earlier learning-based approach, nor pure geometric methods e.g., GlobFit
- Most example reported consists in input mesh that were clearly themselves made from some primitive-based modeling process. For the few that do not clearly come from such a process, such as the horse or the bull on figure 14, the dominance of the proposed method against the baselines is less clear.
Questions for authors
- How does the method compare to pure geometric analysis e.g., hough transform like
- Should the scope of the claim be toned down, toward categories of input shape that are essentially made of simple primitives in the first place?
- how does the method perform on incomplete shapes (e.g., scans) ?
- how robust is the method to the initial sampling both in term of density and uniformity?