- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper targets the shadow removal task, especially trying to address the problem of unavailable or imperfect auxiliary inputs at inference. The authors propose a two-stage framework with Post Fusion to achieve auxiliary-free shadow removal. Stage 1 trains a shadow removal model formulated as an inpainting task, while Stage 2 adapts the model to accept an all-one mask, eliminating the need for an externally supplied shadow mask. Both stages use the shadow image as conditioning. Post Fusion estimates a pseudo shadow mask, and the final result is a composite of the prediction and the original image. The authors evaluate their method on ADSP, ISTD+, and SRD, using masks predicted by BDRAR and FDRNet for the compared mask-based methods.
Critical strengths
-
The authors show a clear auxiliary dependency in current mask-based shadow removal methods, and they propose a straightforward two-stage model to address the problem of imperfect masks. The authors formulate shadow removal as an inpainting task in Stage 1 and remove the dependency on externally supplied masks through a second training stage.
-
The authors further propose to improve their auxiliary-free framework by estimating a pseudo mask followed by compositing. This reduces the errors caused by I2F by constraining where reconstructed pixels are retained and preserving the original image details elsewhere.
Critical weaknesses
-
The comparisons do not sufficiently establish the advantage of the proposed inpainting-based framework for removing mask dependence. Can the authors apply a similar strategy to the compared methods? For example, replace their mask inputs with all-one masks and conduct fine-tuning comparable to Stage 2. The relative drop in performance can help clarify the contributions of the proposed model and the two-stage training strategy.
-
The practical usefulness of the complete two-stage framework across different data conditions needs more evidence. The reconstruction-fidelity advantage on ADSP in the main paper does not consistently extend to ISTD+ and SRD, as shown in supplementary Tables 3 and 5. Furthermore, the authors skip Stage 1 on SRD because reliable annotated masks are unavailable, leaving the benefit of the complete strategy unclear for such datasets. To show the applicability of the framework, can the authors conduct cross-domain evaluation on scenes from WSRD, or qualitative evaluation on more diverse images from SBU? Alternatively, can the authors demonstrate whether a Stage-1 model trained on a source dataset improves Stage-2 adaptation to new data without masks, compared with direct Stage-2 training from scratch? Either would strengthen the justification for using the proposed framework.
-
The use of predicted masks from detection models raises my concern about the consistency of the scope definition. ADSP targets cast-shadow removal while preserving the occluder and its attached shadow. ISTD+/SRD, on the other hand, primarily contain cast shadows. However, some regions predicted by BDRAR/FDRNet may correspond to genuine attached shadows rather than incorrect detections, potentially creating a mismatch between the detection and removal scopes. The suitability of these predictions for a cast-shadow removal task therefore needs to be verified. Can the authors first report the detection models’ checkpoints and training datasets, and then report how much of the predicted-mask error comes from the object region? Can the authors then conduct a controlled evaluation excluding the occluder region from the predicted masks? This could help determine how much the comparison is affected by this mismatch. This may also contribute to the different performance trends between ADSP and ISTD+/SRD, but further analysis is needed to establish that explanation.
Questions for authors
-
Please see my question in Weakness 1.
-
Please see my question in Weakness 2.
-
Please see my question in Weakness 3.
-
Can the authors compare with Stable Shadow Removal (Detail-Preserving Latent Diffusion for Stable Shadow Removal, CVPR 2025)? It is also a diffusion-based, mask-free shadow removal method closely related to the proposed method. Its version without DINOv2 features could serve as a good auxiliary-free baseline.
-
I suggest that the authors clarify the scope of ‘auxiliary-free.’ Their methodology and experiments primarily address shadow mask dependence, while the effects of geometric or semantic auxiliary cues are not examined to the same extent.
-
I suggest adding error maps to Figs. 1, 5, and 7 to make the improvements from I2F to Fused easier to assess. I also suggest standardizing figure and table caption formatting, increasing the spacing, and using consistent panel sizes and column alignment in Fig. 8.