acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Proprioceptive Sketches as Long-Horizon Intent for Generative Action Policies

Abstract

Generative robot policies predict short action chunks but lack explicit long-horizon intent. Recent methods expose longer-horizon structure through language plans, subgoal images, or video forecasts, which are costly to generate and still need to be translated into robot motion. Predicting future robot motions avoids this translation, but a dense, time-indexed trajectory requires numerous parameters to cover the full remaining task, and over a short horizon it largely repeats the action chunk and adds little guidance for action generation. We propose Proprioceptive Action Models (PAM), which jointly generate a compact, timing-free sketch of the robot's remaining joint-space path and a dense executable action chunk within a single transformer denoiser. The sketch parameterizes the path by arc length rather than time, capturing geometric intent invariant to execution timing. Block-causal attention and a staggered denoising schedule maintain directed sketch-to-action dependence, ensuring the action tokens condition on a progressively cleaner sketch throughout sampling. In simulation, PAM improves over its action-only counterparts on Push-T and LIBERO-Long; on four real-world bimanual tasks, it raises success from 47.5% to 75.0%.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Imitation Learning, Generative Policies, Proprioceptive Planning, Long-Horizon Manipulation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_mJYQOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a novel method for generative action policies - instead of predicting immediate next action trunks, or predicting dense and costly long-horizon structures, the method jointly predicts a compact sketch of the trajectory, as well as an executable dense action trunk, using the same denoiser head. The method is evaluated on two simulator-based benchmarks, where it slights outperforms the strongest baseline methods, as well as in real-world experiments, where it demonstrates real and substantial advatnages.

Critical strengths
  • The idea of long-horizon prediction in generative action models has been strongly motivated, and tested in many different ways. PAM-DP takes pushes this idea from B-spline, which directly uses spline coefficients to parameterize executable actions, to the next level of using the spline only for representing the sketch, which is then used to condition a separate action chunk.
  • The strongest result is from the real-world experiment, where PAM-DP shows substantial advantage over Diffusion and B-spline.
  • The ablation study is quite thorough, covering many meaningful alternatives.
Critical weaknesses
  • The main comparisons for the simulations are less convincing, as many of them are taken from other publications rather than reproduced.
  • Missing broader discussion and comparison with alternative forms of future-motion guidance action policies. There are keypoint/waypoint based methods, e.g. ChainedDiffuser, Chain-of-Action, RT-Trajectory; WAM-style models like CoT-VLA. The authors should provide a more in-depth analysis and potentially empirical comparison against PAM-DP.
  • It would be great for the authors to provide some evaluation on the method's performance for the spline sketch prediction for OOD conditions.
Questions for authors

Would equal-budget phase/stage-sampled waypoints provide similar benefits?

2 comments

We thank the reviewer for emphasizing baseline reproducibility and alternative forms of future-motion guidance. We report our reproduced Push-T baselines (W1), new real-world comparisons with ChainedDiffuser and CoT-VLA (W2), evaluation under unseen lighting (W3), and a controlled comparison with equal-budget phase-sampled waypoints (Q1).

W1: Reproduced simulation baselines

We argue that using published scores does not inherently weaken a benchmark comparison. The key requirements are comparable tasks, observation settings, metrics, and evaluation protocols.

Our reproduction of DP-T using its official configuration achieves 0.78 / 0.65 on image-based Push-T, closely matching the published 0.78 / 0.66.

PolicyResult sourceCoverage: max / last ten
DP-TPublished, Table 10.78 / 0.66
DP-TOur reproduction0.78 / 0.65
PAM-DP action-only backboneOur training0.71 / 0.64
PAM-DPOur training0.82 / 0.72

W2: Comparison with alternative future-motion guidance

PAM combines a timing-free remaining-path representation with joint sketch–action generation. The related approaches differ in their intermediate guidance and how it enters action generation:

MethodIntermediate guidanceGeneration mechanism
ChainedDiffuser [1]Predicted end-effector keyposePredict a keypose, then diffuse a trajectory segment to it
Chain-of-Action [2]Keyframe actionGenerate actions autoregressively backward from the predicted keyframe
RT-Trajectory [3]Task-spanning 2-D/2.5-D end-effector traceCondition the policy on an externally supplied trajectory sketch
CoT-VLA [4]Predicted subgoal imageGenerate future image tokens before the action sequence
PAMPhase-indexed sketch of the remaining configuration pathJointly denoise sketch and action tokens with directed sketch-to-action conditioning

We adapted the original ChainedDiffuser and CoT-VLA methods to our dual-arm platform and trained them on the same demonstrations. We evaluated handoff and fold cloth with 20 trials per task under the Table 3 protocol.

MethodHandoffFold cloth
Diffusion Policy (Table 3)9/2010/20
ChainedDiffuser (new)11/2014/20
CoT-VLA (new)10/2013/20
PAM-DP (Table 3)13/2018/20

PAM-DP achieves higher success on both tasks, totaling 31/40, compared with 25/40 for ChainedDiffuser and 23/40 for CoT-VLA.

[1] Xian et al. ChainedDiffuser: Unifying Trajectory Diffusion and Keypose Prediction for Robotic Manipulation.

[2] Zhang et al. Chain-of-Action: Trajectory Autoregressive Modeling for Robotic Manipulation.

[3] Gu et al. Robotic Task Generalization via Hindsight Trajectory Sketches.

[4] Zhao et al. CoT-VLA: Visual Chain-of-Thought Reasoning for Vision-Language-Action Models.

W3: OOD evaluation under unseen lighting

To assess robustness during deployment, we tested handoff and fold cloth under a lighting condition absent from the demonstrations, with 20 trials per method per task.

Lighting conditionMethodHandoff successFold cloth success
StandardDiffusion Policy9/2010/20
StandardPAM-DP13/2018/20
Changed lighting (new)Diffusion Policy5/204/20
Changed lighting (new)PAM-DP7/2012/20

PAM-DP achieves 19/40 successes versus 9/40 for Diffusion Policy under the evaluated lighting shift, supporting better closed-loop task performance.

Q1: Equal-budget phase/stage-sampled waypoints

We replaced the B-spline coefficients with positions sampled uniformly in arc-length phase along the same remaining path. Both representations retain 11 predicted 2-D tokens, relative coordinates, and the terminal displacement as the last token.

RepresentationCoverage: max / last ten
PAM-DP action-only backbone0.71 / 0.64
Phase-sampled waypoints (new)0.73 / 0.65
B-spline sketch (PAM-DP)0.82 / 0.72

B-spline coefficients are jointly fitted to 64 phase samples spanning the remaining path, whereas phase-sampled waypoints directly retain selected positions. We compared target reconstruction RMSE using the metric in App. A.3, with linear interpolation between waypoints.

TaskPredicted tokensPhase-sampled waypoints RMSEB-spline sketch RMSE
Push-T (px)114.123.08
Handoff (deg)110.8030.568
Close lid (deg)130.8280.528
Fold cloth (deg)150.8840.563
Measure (deg)130.9690.596
LIBERO-Long (deg)150.830.56

The B-spline targets reconstruct the path more accurately in all evaluated settings, consistent with the higher coverage in the controlled Push-T comparison.

I thank the authors for the detailed rebutal. All my concerns are address and I will raise my score.

Reviewer_ZF8cOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2(+1)
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

Diffusion-based action generation has been shown to be effective for modeling short-horizon skills, though less effective for long-horizon skills. Related work includes auxiliary information (such as image subgoals) to address this. This work proposes to include sketches—the robot's joint configuration trajectory encoded with splines—as the auxiliary information, which is easier to generate since it's low dimensional, and we already have access to that. Experiments done on simulated and real-world domains report higher success rates, but the standard deviations are missing (or not in the significant range).

Critical strengths

Using sketches---not the actual action outputs---could be good for generalization since it creates an abstraction on the trajectory itself, and is invariant to time shifts and parameterizations. It's also low-dimensional, and could be produced directly from the data, excludes task-irrelevant things (for instance, if we used images, then it's possible the subgoals are overfit some distractor objects in the background). It's generic---sketches could be introduced for every robot. And they are still pretty close to the actual action distribution, which, I guess, would be helpful for steering the output.

Critical weaknesses

Even though the paper overall is well-written, there are parts that are not very obvious at first reading. For instance, I only understood the significance of the work after Section 3. The paper could benefit from changing the narrative in the introduction. Not that this alone would be enough for rejection, but it makes it hard to assess the contribution.

The more important one is the lack of standard deviations/errors in Tables 1 to 3. There's only one std report in Table 2, and it doesn't show a significant (say, p < 0.05) improvement over the other baseline. I must say, not everything is numbers. I think there could be some merit in the motivation of this work, but it's not shown very clearly in the results. Since sketches could potentially be integrated with other approaches (i.e., it's orthogonal), I would have focused on showing, say, why images would not be good, why having end-effector positions, or other types of actions as a replacement for sketches wouldn't give the same performance. Currently, it seems very incremental (even if it may not be), and the increment itself is not statistically shown, and we don't know if it's only for a handful of domains, or a general property which would hold across domains.

Questions for authors

I don't like to ask for new experiments, but is there any way that we can get standard errors for results in Tables 1 to 3?

3 comments

We thank the reviewer for highlighting the need to clarify the contribution and strengthen its empirical support. We revised the Introduction (W1) and provide comparisons with alternative guidance methods and path representations, and standard errors for Tables 1–3 (Q1).

W1: Making the motivation and contribution clear earlier

We will revise the Introduction to explain the distinction between long-horizon guidance and short-horizon execution before reviewing related approaches:

A short action chunk specifies immediate commands but does not explicitly describe the robot’s remaining path to task completion. We introduce Proprioceptive Action Models (PAM), which jointly generate a compact, timing-free sketch of the remaining configuration-space path and an executable action chunk. The sketch provides long-horizon geometric guidance through directed sketch-to-action conditioning; only the action chunk is executed, determining immediate motion, execution timing, and gripper commands.

Make the significance concrete in the Introduction. We illustrated this distinction using the handoff example in Fig. 1: the sketch describes the remaining route toward the transfer region and around the barrier, while the action chunk controls the immediate movement. We also stated the main real-world result and summarized the contributions before the detailed related-work discussion.

W2/Q1: Evidence for the sketch design and standard errors

What the sketch contributes. PAM provides a compact, timing-free representation of the remaining path and jointly generates it with executable actions through directed sketch-to-action conditioning. The sketch captures long-horizon geometry, while the action chunk determines immediate motion, timing, and gripper commands. This separation motivates the following comparisons.

Comparison with alternative guidance methods. We adapted the original CoT-VLA [1] and ChainedDiffuser [2] methods to our dual-arm platform, trained them on the same demonstrations, and evaluated each method over 20 trials per task.

MethodIntermediate guidanceHandoffFold cloth
CoT-VLA (new)Subgoal images10/2013/20
ChainedDiffuser (new)End-effector keyposes11/2014/20
PAM-DPRemaining-path sketch13/2018/20

PAM achieves higher success on both tasks than the adapted visual-subgoal and keypose-guided methods. These method-level comparisons are complemented by the controlled comparison below, which changes the path representation within PAM.

Controlled comparison of path representations. On image-based Push-T, we replaced B-spline coefficients with uniformly phase-sampled waypoints along the same remaining path, retaining the same 11-token budget. Results follow Table 1’s reporting convention over three training seeds:

RepresentationMaximum coverageLast-ten coverage
PAM-DP action-only backbone0.710.64
Phase-sampled waypoints (new)0.730.65
B-spline sketch (PAM-DP)0.820.72

Thus, the proposed encoding provides greater benefits than equally compact waypoint guidance in this controlled comparison. At the same token budget, B-spline targets also reconstruct the remaining paths more accurately across all evaluated datasets, supporting their use as compact geometric guidance.

Standard errors. We clarify the evaluation protocols and uncertainty reporting for Tables 1 and 3.

Table 1: Push-T. Following Diffusion Policy’s reporting convention, we computed maximum coverage and mean coverage over the last ten checkpoints separately for 3 training seeds, using 50 initial conditions per evaluation. The entries below report mean ± SE across the three seed-level values.

MethodState: maxState: last tenImage: maxImage: last ten
B-spline Policy0.92 ± 0.020.74 ± 0.030.76 ± 0.030.63 ± 0.04
PAM-DP0.96 ± 0.010.88 ± 0.010.82 ± 0.040.72 ± 0.06

Table 3: Real-world tasks. Each method is evaluated over 20 trials per task. The table below reports success percentage ± estimated SE, with SE expressed in percentage points. These SEs quantify uncertainty from the evaluation trials, not variation across training runs.

TaskDiffusion PolicyB-spline PolicyPAM-DP
Handoff45.0 ± 11.140.0 ± 11.065.0 ± 10.7
Close lid45.0 ± 11.140.0 ± 11.070.0 ± 10.2
Fold cloth50.0 ± 11.250.0 ± 11.290.0 ± 6.7
Measure50.0 ± 11.245.0 ± 11.175.0 ± 9.7
Overall47.5 ± 5.643.8 ± 5.575.0 ± 4.7

[1] Zhao et al. CoT-VLA: Visual Chain-of-Thought Reasoning for Vision-Language-Action Models.

[2] Xian et al. ChainedDiffuser: Unifying Trajectory Diffusion and Keypose Prediction for Robotic Manipulation.

Thank you for your response.

The standard errors seem to be a bit high (i.e., a rough +-2 SE shows no significance for most entries). Nevertheless, there are some improvements in some of the tasks.

In Table 1, what is the difference between state and image columns?

Thank you for the follow-up.

“State” and “Image” in Table 1 refer to two observation settings for Push-T, following Diffusion Policy:

  • State: The policy receives low-dimensional observations consisting of the T-block’s keypoint coordinates and the pusher’s 2-D position.
  • Image: The policy receives RGB images together with the pusher’s 2-D position.

PAM’s sketch represents the remaining pusher path in both settings. The state-based setting evaluates the policy without the additional challenge of visual perception, while the image-based setting evaluates the full visuomotor policy.

We will add this clarification to the manuscript by explicitly introduce "State" and "Image" based experiments on Push-T.

Reviewer_pieROpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces Proprioceptive Action Models (PAM), which use a compact sketch of the remaining robot joint-space path to guide short-horizon action generation. The authors use B-spline control points and arc-length parameterization to represent future motion without execution timing. They also introduce directed attention and staggered denoising to jointly generate the sketch and action chunks. Experiments on Push-T, LIBERO-Long, and four real-world bimanual tasks show improvements over action-only baselines.

Critical strengths

Geometric information is useful for robot manipulation, especially for long-horizon tasks. This paper provides a compact way to incorporate future motion information into action generation. The proposed sketch can be constructed directly from demonstration data without additional annotations.

The paper includes real-world robot experiments and ablation studies. The improvement across four bimanual tasks supports the effectiveness of the proposed method. The method is also evaluated with both Diffusion Policy and VLA models, showing its compatibility with different policy architectures.

Critical weaknesses

I think the paper does not fully explain why the proposed sketch should be considered long-horizon intent rather than a representation of future robot motion. The sketch mainly represents the geometry of future joint-space trajectories, but it does not explicitly include object states, contact information, or gripper actions. These factors can be important in long-horizon manipulation tasks. The paper could explain more clearly what information the sketch captures and whether it is sufficient to represent long-horizon intent.

Although the paper shows improvements over action-only baselines, it is unclear how much of the improvement comes from sketch conditioning itself. In Table 5, the auxiliary-only variant already improves performance without allowing action tokens to directly attend to the sketch. This suggests that additional supervision may also contribute to the results. While the sketch intervention experiment shows that changing the sketch affects action predictions, it does not fully explain how much this dependence contributes to task success.

The paper includes several ablation studies, but most of them are conducted on Push-T. I wonder whether the same findings would hold for more complex manipulation tasks, especially those involving contact changes and coordination between two arms. The current experiments show that the overall method works on real robots, but they do not fully explain whether the individual design choices contribute in the same way across different tasks.

The generalization ability of the proposed method also needs more discussion. Although PAM is evaluated on different tasks and policy architectures, the models are trained for specific settings. It is unclear how well the method would generalize to unseen objects, environments, or robot embodiments. Evaluating the method on different platforms does not necessarily demonstrate generalization across them.

Although PAM improves over action-only baselines, the paper does not provide direct comparisons with other methods that use future motion or geometric information to guide action generation. Existing approaches also use end-effector trajectories or visual motion representations as intermediate conditions. The paper explains some differences in their designs, but it is unclear what advantages the proposed joint-space sketch provides over these alternatives.

The improvement on LIBERO-Long is relatively small compared with the FLOWER baseline. Although FLOWER already achieves high performance, the result does not clearly show how much PAM improves long-horizon manipulation in this setting. More discussion would help explain the value of the proposed method for pretrained VLA models.

The staggered denoising method also requires additional model evaluations. Since different denoising schedules use different computational budgets, it is difficult to determine whether the improvement comes from the proposed schedule or the additional computation.

Questions for authors
  • I am still confused about why the proposed joint-space sketch is considered long-horizon intent rather than a representation of future robot motion. Could the authors explain this distinction more clearly, especially what task information is preserved or lost?
  • In Table 5, the auxiliary-only variant already improves performance without direct sketch-to-action attention. Could the authors provide more analysis of how much of the improvement comes from sketch conditioning rather than additional supervision?
  • Most component ablations are conducted on Push-T. I wonder whether the same findings would hold for real-world bimanual tasks. Could the authors provide more discussion about the contributions of different components across tasks?
  • Although PAM is evaluated on different tasks and policy architectures, how well does it generalize to unseen objects, environments, or robot embodiments? Could the authors clarify the generalization ability and limitations of the proposed method?
  • I wonder how PAM compares with existing methods that use future motion or geometric representations, such as OASIS or RT-Trajectory. Could the authors explain the main advantages of the proposed joint-space sketch over these approaches?
  • The improvement on LIBERO-Long is relatively small compared with FLOWER. Could the authors explain whether this result mainly demonstrates compatibility with pretrained VLA models or provides meaningful performance benefits?
  • The staggered denoising method requires additional model evaluations. Could the authors clarify whether the improvement would remain under a matched inference budget?
  • How well would the proposed method work on tasks with more complex contact changes or unexpected object movements? What are the main limitations when applying joint-space sketches to more general robot manipulation tasks?
3 comments

We thank the reviewer for the detailed and constructive comments. We respond to each weakness and question below, with new results on sketch conditioning in Push-T and two real-world tasks (W2/W3), unseen lighting (W4), sketch horizon (W5), and sampling under matched inference budgets (W7).

W1/Q1: Meaning and scope of long-horizon intent

We argue that our sketch represents future robot motion and serves as long-horizon geometric intent by describing the remaining path to task completion. It guides short-horizon actions through directed sketch-to-action conditioning.

Why object, contact, and gripper variables are omitted. An intermediate intent representation need not encode every task variable. Prior work likewise adopts different abstractions, including language plans and subtask reasoning (ECoT [1]), subgoal images (CoT-VLA [2]), and motion traces (MolmoAct [3]). PAM uses the sketch to represent compact remaining-path geometry, while visual and proprioceptive observations provide context and the action stream generates timed motion and gripper commands. The sketch provides geometric guidance within this complete policy.

Information preserved and omited:

Content
RetainedCoarse remaining-path geometry, traversal order, terminal configuration, and relative coordination between the two arms
Removed by designExecution timing: speed, pauses, and duration, and geometric detail beyond the spline’s capacity
Not explicitly encodedObject state, contact modes and forces, and gripper state

[1] Zawalski et al. Robotic Control via Embodied Chain-of-Thought Reasoning.

[2] Zhao et al. CoT-VLA: Visual Chain-of-Thought Reasoning for Vision-Language-Action Models.

[3] Lee et al. MolmoAct: Action Reasoning Models that can Reason in Space.

W2/Q2: Contribution of sketch conditioning beyond auxiliary supervision

Conditioning improves performance while retaining sketch supervision. The auxiliary-only variant in Table 5 retains sketch prediction and its loss but masks action access to sketch tokens. Auxiliary supervision increases Push-T coverage from 0.69 to 0.75; enabling conditioning further increases it to 0.79.

Why sketch supervision is retained. At evaluation, PAM conditions actions on generated sketches; ground-truth future trajectories are unavailable. Removing sketch supervision would also change how the conditioning signal is learned. The auxiliary-only ablation isolates action access to the sketch while retaining its supervision.

We evaluated the same trained checkpoints while holding sketch coefficients at Gaussian noise throughout sampling and preserving sketch-to-action attention. Coverage decreases from 0.79 to 0.65, and real-world success decreases from 31/40 to 11/40. This intervention complements the auxiliary-only ablation by testing the policy’s dependence on generated sketch content during execution.

VariantSketch supervisionSketch-to-action conditioningPush-T coverage ↑Handoff successFold cloth success
Action-only baselineNoNone0.69 ± 0.079/2010/20
Auxiliary-onlyYesSketch-to-action attention masked during training and inference0.75 ± 0.04——
PAM-DP, sketch held at noise (new)YesAttention retained; sketch coefficients held at Gaussian noise0.65 ± 0.024/207/20
PAM-DPYesJointly denoised sketch coefficients0.79 ± 0.0213/2018/20

W3/Q3: Component contributions in real-world bimanual tasks

  1. The intervention provides evidence beyond Push-T. With the trained weights fixed, holding the sketch at noise reduces success from 13/20 to 4/20 on handoff and 18/20 to 7/20 on fold cloth. These results support the contribution of generated sketch guidance on both real-world tasks.

  2. These tasks involve contact changes and two-arm coordination. Handoff requires grasp transfer between grippers around a barrier; fold cloth requires coordinated corner grasps and successive folds of a deformable object. The intervention therefore tests sketch guidance in manipulation settings substantially different from planar pushing.

  3. The experiments provide complementary component evidence. Table 5 isolates sketch parameterization, attention structure, and training noise levels on Push-T. The new real-world intervention supports the contribution of generated sketch guidance during execution. This complements Table 3, where the full method improves success on all four real-world tasks, from 38/80 to 60/80 overall.

W4/Q4/Q8: Generalization, contact changes, and disturbances

Performance under unseen lighting. We evaluated handoff and fold cloth under a lighting condition absent from the demonstrations. PAM-DP achieves 19/40 successes versus 9/40 for Diffusion Policy, with a larger improvement on fold cloth than on handoff.

MethodHandoff: changed lightingFold cloth: changed lighting
Diffusion Policy5/204/20
PAM-DP7/2012/20

Applicability across embodiments and policy formulations. We evaluated diffusion policies on Push-T and the real dual-UR3 platform, and a pretrained rectified-flow VLA on LIBERO-Long with a simulated Franka arm. These setting-specific experiments demonstrate the applicability of the shared sketch–action formulation across multiple embodiments and policy architectures.

Our handoff and cloth-folding tasks already involve contact changes; the observation-conditioned action stream generates the executable motion and gripper commands alongside the sketch’s geometric guidance.

Replanning during execution. PAM regenerates both the sketch and action chunk from updated observations after each execution window. This allows subsequent predictions to respond to changes in the observed scene.

Scope and limitations. Future work will evaluate performance on unseen objects and scenes and zero-shot embodiment transfer. As acknowledged in the Conclusion, the sketch does not explicitly model object dynamics or contact.

W5/Q5: Comparison with future-motion guidance methods

AspectOASIS [4]RT-Trajectory [5]PAM
RepresentationCamera-frame SE(3) end-effector posesRendered 2-D/2.5-D end-effector traceConfiguration-space B-spline coefficients
HorizonAction chunk: 8 stepsTask-spanning trajectoryRemaining path to completion
ParameterizationTime-indexedTemporal progress encoded by colorArc-length phase
Generation and conditioningTrajectory predictor supplies pose-supervised hidden states to an action decoderExternally supplied sketch conditions the policySketch and actions are jointly denoised with directed sketch-to-action attention

Why configuration space. Joint coordinates explicitly represent whole-arm posture and the configuration of both arms along the path. Sketch supervision comes directly from recorded robot configurations, without depth targets or camera calibration.

Controlled comparison of horizon. Inspired by OASIS’s action-aligned horizon, we trained a PAM variant whose sketch covers its own 16-step action chunk.

RepresentationHorizonPush-T coverage ↑
PAM-DP action-only backbone—0.69 ± 0.07
Phase-indexed sketch, short horizon (new)16-step action chunk0.70 ± 0.02
Time-indexed sketchRemaining path0.74 ± 0.04
Phase-indexed sketch (PAM-DP)Remaining path0.79 ± 0.02

Guidance beyond the action window provides additional benefit: extending the phase-indexed sketch to the remaining path increases coverage from 0.70 to 0.79 under the same representation budget. Among remaining-path sketches, removing execution timing further improves coverage from 0.74 to 0.79. These comparisons support the horizon and temporal parameterization of PAM’s geometric guidance.

[4] Chen et al. OASIS: Observation-Action Space Alignment via SE(3) Trajectory Prediction for Robotic Manipulation.

[5] Gu et al. Robotic Task Generalization via Hindsight Trajectory Sketches.

W6/Q6: LIBERO-Long performance and pretrained VLA compatibility

Performance with a strong pretrained VLA. FLOWER reports 94.9 ± 1.2% success on LIBERO-Long, leaving limited room for further improvement. PAM-VLA achieves 95.2 ± 0.4% over five training seeds. The principal finding is that PAM extends to a strong pretrained VLA while maintaining competitive performance and obtaining a modest improvement in reported mean success.

We will revise the Abstract and Conclusion to frame LIBERO-Long as evidence of compatibility with a strong pretrained VLA and a modest improvement in mean success.

W7/Q7: Performance under matched inference budgets

The advantage persists under matched NFE. We added synchronous DDIM evaluations at 18 and 32 NFE, matching the staggered schedules. We report mean coverage ± SD across the same three sampler-noise seeds.

NFESynchronous samplingStaggered sampling, 16 base steps
160.779 ± 0.015—
180.776 ± 0.009 (new)0.805 ± 0.011 (η = 1/8)
320.770 ± 0.012 (new)0.809 ± 0.027 (η = 1)

Advancing sketch denoising provides a benefit beyond increasing the evaluation count. Staggered sampling achieves higher mean coverage at both matched budgets, by 0.029 at 18 NFE and 0.039 at 32 NFE. Increasing synchronous sampling to these budgets does not improve its mean coverage over the 16-NFE baseline.

Inference budget. At the 16-step base budget, the default lead increases model evaluations from 16 to 18 (+12.5%), and staggered sampling retains its advantage in the matched-NFE comparisons.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.