- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
As I understand it, the paper proposes a steering approach to guide diffusion/flow policies in Vision-Language-Action (VLA) models. The main argument presented is that VLA policies lack conditioning. The author proposes PROACT, which uses two components: a motion expert that proposes a motion prior and a world-modelling component that refines it; it then uses this to steer the noise source for action generation, thus providing a steering algorithm for VLA. They show the approach works quite well on the benchmarks and outperforms baselines
Critical strengths
- The framing that providing additional conditioning is reasonable and should help a policy smoother and locally continuous in action trajectory. I think their propose-calibrate-refine idea is intuitive indeed.
- PROACT was evaluated on multiple benchmarks, including real-world manipulation tasks. The results seems quite strong against the baselines.
Critical weaknesses
The paper should've been desk-rejected due to the severe lack of care when it comes to scientific communication, such as a lack of writing quality (grasping a high level of understanding of the contribution to begin with). The paper is very hard to follow, as it is filled with jargon. In the abstract, when I first started reading it, I needed to make multiple attempts to keep my focus on it , because every sentence is coming up with a term that is hard to follow. This goes on and on in the full paper. I like to print paper to read, but it's impossible to follow the figures because they are too tiny. The paper doesn't have a standard paper structure one would have started with a related work section after the introduction; neither they have a preliminary introduction to the topic or a background section. The method section is filled again with jargon for 3 long pages. The experiments section doesn't have a proper description of the baselines. The related work, which appears before the Conclusion section, doesn't discuss VLA, so a general reader was never introduced to the domain. I'm reasonably familiar with this area, and when I started reading the paper, the first paper that came to mind was diffusion steering [1]. The author didn't place themselves in relation to prior works (I couldn't find discussion of policy steering that was well studied in prior works). As it stands, an almost complete disregard for basic effort in writing and communication to a reader.
[1] Wagenmaker, Andrew, et al. "Steering your diffusion policy with latent space reinforcement learning." arXiv preprint arXiv:2506.15799 (2025).
Questions for authors
None