- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2(+1)
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The work proposes ProxyStaff, a way to learn hourly staffing requirements from historical business and schedule records. Since schedules record assigned rather than required staffing, the authors fit an operational proxy that estimates how much revenue and how many transactions each staffing level per role has supported and invert it to obtain the minimum staffing for each past hour. Forecasting models are then trained to predict these labels one or seven days ahead. On two datasets collected from a restaurant chain and a milk-tea chain, with six backbones, ProxyStaff is compared with learning the managers’ schedules and with forecasting business and converting it through the same proxy, using support and labor metrics defined by the proxy. The datasets and code are not available for review; the authors plan to release them upon acceptance, subject to licensing.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses a practical obstacle to learning staffing from data. Historical schedules record what managers assigned, not what was needed, so a model trained to imitate them also learns their overstaffing. ProxyStaff instead derives requirement labels from records that businesses already keep (hourly revenue, transactions, and schedules), so it needs no new data collection or optimal labels, and the labels can be used with any forecasting model.
-
The comparison is controlled: three supervision schemes are compared within each of six backbones, with the same inputs, training budget, and calibration, on two real datasets at two planning horizons, with seed-level results. Because Business+ proxy uses the same proxy, it isolates the effect of changing the prediction target.
Critical weaknesses
-
The results cannot be checked or reproduced during review. The code link is a placeholder, and the datasets, listed as a contribution, will be released only upon acceptance and subject to licensing. Because this is a method-and-experiment paper rather than a theoretical one, checking that the code is consistent with the paper is an important part of my assessment. The code involves no commercial data and could be shared anonymously now. If confidentiality is the concern, the data could be shared in a protected form, for example with stores anonymized and revenue and transactions rescaled by a secret constant, which leaves the labels and metrics unchanged.
-
The claimed win-win is not supported. The paper frames the work as a win-win for businesses and workers, but neither side is checked against an observed outcome. The workers’ side, such as workload or income from fewer paid hours, is not measured. For the business side, the proxy takes the business recorded in past hours with a given staffing level (its 95th percentile) as the business that this staffing can handle. The records show that this business occurred, not that it was served well; customers may have waited or left, and staff may have been overloaded. Both the training labels and the evaluation rest on this assumption, so if it overstates what a smaller staff can handle, the reported savings would hide real understaffing. Checking the proxy against an outcome it does not use, such as service times or lost sales, would address this.
Questions for authors
- Address the weaknesses above, respectively.
- How general is ProxyStaff? The study covers two food-service chains whose assumptions, such as complementary roles and comparable productivity across stores, may not hold elsewhere. Please state the conditions the framework requires and which other settings, in staffing or in other applications, meet them, ideally with one example beyond food service. This would strengthen the case for the paper’s significance.
Follow-up on our response
Dear Reviewer,
We would appreciate your feedback on our responses. Do these address your main concerns? We would be happy to clarify any remaining questions during the discussion period.
Thank you again for your time and consideration.