- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes PatchTransferNet (PTNet), a retail demand forecasting model combining multi-scale patch attention, convex level anchoring, and aggregate-level supervision. It introduces a two-fingerprint decision rule based on zero-mass share and lag-one autocorrelation to guide loss selection. Experiments on three retail datasets and ten classical time-series benchmarks demonstrate competitive forecasting performance and investigate the effectiveness of the proposed inductive bias across different data regimes.
Critical strengths
-
The paper explicitly considers the discrete, sparse, and intermittent characteristics of retail demand, providing a meaningful alternative to conventional continuous-signal forecasting approaches.
-
PTNet achieves competitive performance on retail forecasting benchmarks, particularly on FreshRetailNet-50K, where it outperforms the compared single-stage baselines. The ablation studies and cross-domain experiments further support the proposed design.
Critical weaknesses
-
In the abstract, "Firstly" appears, but "Secondly, Thirdly, Finally" does not appear afterwards, which may appear a bit weak in logic.
-
The organization, layout, and content of the entire paper are a bit rough. The paper is not fully written, for example, there is still half a page left on page nine, but it has not been effectively utilized, and the introduction and contribution sections are written too vaguely.
-
There are multiple 1-2 words occupying a line in the article (such as line 43, 87, 122, 256, 296, 409), which need to be adjusted and modified.
-
The innovation of the paper's methodology is insufficient. The core components of PTNet are all reasonable, but the article needs to clarify what advantages these components can bring.
-
Most baseline models use fixed random seed results, but for PTNet, 5 seed experiments were conducted.
-
The learning rate of PatchTST on M5 is , and the WAPE is 74.90. However, the appendix indicates that the WAPE can reach 70.51 at , which suggests that the baseline results in the main table of the article may not be the optimal results. The author needs to explain why the main table adopts a poor configuration.
-
Section 5.4 claims that four datasets exceeded the set threshold and benefited from anchoring, but in Table 5 of Appendix, only the Traffic, Weather, and Electricity datasets exceeded 0.04. Although Solar is below the threshold, there has been some improvement, and the author needs to explain this.
Questions for authors
Please see Weaknesses.
Dear Reviewers,
I'm writing to gently remind you that the rebuttal discussion phase deadline is approaching. Please take a moment to read the authors' rebuttal, and feel free to respond if any concerns remain that you'd like them to address. Thank you very much for your time and effort.