- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper fined tuned three open LLMs to perform three tasks in optimisation modeling: 1) constructing mathematical formulations and solver code from natural language description; 2) extending existing math models in the form of LP files with business rules; and 3) performing variables pruning. They also perform experiments to show the effectiveness of their fine-tuned models.
Critical strengths
- The problem they tackle may be important in industry;
Critical weaknesses
-
Limitations on presentation and organisation:
- The presentation is poor. Even after reading the abstract and introduction, I did NOT know too much about this paper (What are existing things? What are the research gaps? what are their new contributions? Why should we do this rather than that? things like this are not clear...the authors seem not familiar with writing a ML paper for a top venue like ICLR).
- The motivation of this paper is not clear: why must we inject constraints or perform variable pruning using these fine-tuned models? How about using a capable LLM such as GPT-6.1 to do it? (What are the gains/benefits of fine-tuned models compared to direct prompt LLMs?) Besides, the authors spent so little room on explaining why we need to do constraint injection or variable pruning (rather than building a model from the scratch)? What if the efforts/costs of injecting constraints and/or pruning variables are greater than building from the scratch?
- The categories in Table 2 contains both mathematical-programming classes and application families. This is very poorly organised.
- Figure 2 and Figure 3 are of low resolution, which is unprofessional.
-
Limitations on methodology:
- Their method can only tackle MILP problems (at least from the description, I feel so) while other types of optimisation problems are not discussed;
-
Limitations on experiments:
- It is very confusing why the authors selected to use openPangu-Embedded-7B-V1.1 (few people use this in their research, even researchers from Huawei...) as the base model? (Why not more capable open LLMs such as Qwen-3, Qwen3.5?)
- They did not have any baselines (except the untuned Pangu-Embedded-7B-V1.1). This is not what a scientific paper should do.
I have the feeling that this is a student project or an unfinished intern project in a company.
Questions for authors
Please check the weak points.