- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents Aqua3R, a feed-forward framework for underwater 3D reconstruction from unposed images. The method predicts camera parameters, an in-water Gaussian scene (W), a restored Gaussian scene (C), and scene-level medium parameters in one forward pass. The two Gaussian branches share camera estimates and pre-fusion depth-derived point support but predict separate Gaussian attributes. A physical image-formation model uses the predicted medium and rendered range to transform C into a water-affected rendering (P), with gradients stopped at C and its rendered depth. The authors also introduce the paired synthetic DL3DV-Water dataset and the real DeepSea-ROV collection. Experiments show improved in-water novel-view synthesis on real footage and synthetic transfer sets, together with improved camera estimation on Real25, relative to the evaluated baselines. The method trails YoNoSplat-D on the in-domain Test32 rendering benchmark. A separate data study investigates the effects of scene count, medium coverage, and training budget.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses a practically important problem by jointly producing observed underwater and restored scene representations from unposed images without per-scene optimization. Predicting W and C under the same cameras is a useful design for obtaining directly comparable reconstructions and avoiding camera inconsistencies between separately trained models.
-
The evaluation covers real underwater footage and two synthetic transfer sets, with ablations of the loss components and training-data design. Under the nominal 24-view protocol, Aqua3R improves in-water PSNR over the stronger adapted YoNoSplat baseline on each set from 18.55 to 19.53 dB on Real25 (Table 1, p. 6) and from 19.56 to 22.31 dB on OOD-Water (Table 8, p. 15). The additional training seed, paired confidence intervals, and scene-medium swap experiments provide useful context for interpreting these gains.
Critical weaknesses
-
The experiments do not fully isolate the specific benefit of maintaining two Gaussian scenes. Section 3.1 (pp. 3-4) motivates the dual-scene design against an alternative that predicts only a restored scene and a medium, but no matched feed-forward comparison tests that alternative. Table 15 (p. 20) provides output-training controls with the physical and medium-label losses disabled. As explained in Appendix D.2 (p. 19), these controls freeze the branch not optimized by that control and mask its RGB loss while retaining both forward paths. They therefore do not directly test the complete dual-scene system against a clean-scene-plus-medium model. The shared-camera outputs offer a useful capability, but the performance benefit of the additional in-water representation remains uncertain without this matched comparison.
-
The benefit of physical re-rendering over medium-label supervision alone remains untested. Table 6 (p. 9) removes the physical and medium-label losses together: Test32 C PSNR changes from 18.25 to 18.23 dB without a resolved difference, while Real25 P PSNR drops from 18.34 to 17.19 dB. Table 16 (p. 20) provides sensitivity results for nonzero physical-loss weights, and Table 17(a) demonstrates synthetic medium recovery. These results support the combined training objectives, but do not establish the incremental benefit of the physical loss over direct coefficient supervision. A control retaining medium-label supervision while disabling the physical loss would clarify the contribution of the physical consistency objective.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors compare Aqua3R with a feed-forward model that predicts only a clean Gaussian scene and a medium, using the same VGGT-Ω initialization, camera/depth supervision, training data, and optimization budget, while reporting model size? This would directly test the alternative discussed in Section 3.1 and clarify the benefit of the additional in-water representation.
-
Could the authors add a control that retains medium-label supervision but sets the physical-loss weight to zero, with all other training settings fixed? Evaluating the resulting models on the same synthetic samples in the shared 4 m gauge, with C and P quality and coefficient errors reported together, would isolate the benefit of physical consistency beyond direct medium supervision.
-
Appendix A.2 (p. 13) distinguishes possible upstream exposure of Test32 sources from the separate contamination concern associated with the original VGGT-Ω checkpoint. Could the authors assess whether the relative gains persist with the recommended retrained checkpoint, keeping the adaptation and evaluation protocol fixed, and distinguish the implications for Test32 from those for the transfer and real-data results?