- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposed to apply regression for a trajectory instead of a scalar. They propose PPI-Net and perform experiments on heart rate estimation. The authors compared with a strong estimator, Belief-PPG, and provide evidence that the proposed method performs similarly with the state-of-the-art technique with small improvements.
Critical strengths
The authors spent a good time to find the state-of-the-art techniques and compared with them. I appreciate for this effort. The idea is motivated well enough while the choosing application fits the motivation. The figures are easy to read and generally clear.
Critical weaknesses
The experiments are extremely shallow. The authors only considered one application, heart rate tracking, with a single dataset Dalia. There are multiple datasets out there including WildPPG (cited by authors). There are also several application where the authors can and should try their methods to provide evidence. Some examples are heart rate variability (HRV), respiration rate (RR), blood pressure and more. All of these tasks are regression based and well-defined for the technique. The current experiments are not enough for ICLR bar.
The presentation is weak and multiple references to Appendix are ?. This also shows the rigor of the work.
I believe the work needs a major revision.
Questions for authors
See above for the experiment point especially.