- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies causal-role erasure in text-to-video diffusion models: removing an event source and its physical effects while preserving the same object when it appears in a noncausal role. The proposed method, Source-slot Randomized Counterfactual Distillation (SRCD), varies the source identity in training prompts while keeping independently generated source-free target videos fixed. It trains mechanism-specific LoRA adapters through flow matching, teacher distillation, and preservation updates. The paper evaluates seven physical mechanisms. The setting is interesting, particularly because inference requires only a text prompt and the corresponding adapter. However, the evidence for a reliable improvement over the matched control remains limited.
Critical strengths
- The causal-role erasure setting is novel.
- The controlled single-factor design is rigorous (Holm correction, non-inferiority margins).
- Negative results are reported candidly.
Critical weaknesses
-
Each adapter is trained on only 100 erasure pairs. Is this sufficient? Does the model learn the scenes in the training set or the prompt descriptions, or does it truly generalize? Does SRCD’s advantage still hold within the trained mechanisms for unseen object–receiver combinations, substantially different scene layouts, and free-form prompts?
-
What does the learning curve with respect to data size look like? The authors could compare several training-set sizes while controlling the optimization budget and repeating seeds, and check whether erasure, role preservation, and generalization improve with more data.
-
As described in the paper, effect-aware removal methods can handle such effects using an observed video, masks, or region localization. Their limitation is not that they cannot remove these effects; it is that they cannot be used directly through the text-only generator interface defined here. Nevertheless, the paper provides no direct experimental comparison with these methods. Moreover, the training prompts already describe the physical consequences, and the source-free targets are themselves generated by the base model from source-free prompts. Could a carefully designed prompt achieve the same result directly? I suggest adding such a naive baseline.
-
Figure 2 does not clearly show the full computation path: how the target video is encoded and noised, which text the teacher and student each receive, which parameters are updated, and which modules remain at inference.
-
Figure 3 shows clear failures in which the source and its effects are not fully erased. Consider these alongside the complete-absence metrics, the statistical tests, and the human evaluation, the current evidence neither establishes a reliable advantage of SRCD over the matched control nor shows that it can consistently accomplish the defined task.
Questions for authors
-
Please clarify whether the target videos were screened by humans or by an automatic evaluator. Please also report the residual error rate after screening, along with independent human spot-check results. The source-free prompt does not depend on the source, and each mechanism has only 12 receivers and two wording styles. How many distinct scene conditions do the 178 targets per mechanism actually contain? What is the rationale for using only 100 pairs per adapter?
-
When a scene contains multiple mechanisms or multiple active event sources, which adapter should be used? Can the method remove all downstream consequences of a specified source while preserving similar effects produced by other causes? Would this setting require retraining?
-
Compared with flow-matching fine-tuning alone on the same target videos, how much does teacher distillation contribute? Can this gain, and the gain from source replacement, be reproduced across multiple training seeds?
Response to Reviewer wsPZ
Thank you for recognizing the task formulation and controlled comparison. We would like to clarify two points:
The 100 training pairs per adapter are the setting used in this study, not a claim that this amount of data is sufficient. We also do not use the current results to claim generalization to arbitrary scenes or combinations of mechanisms.
The distinction from effect-aware video editing is the input interface: those methods use an existing video, masks, or localization information, whereas we study erasure during generation from text prompts alone. We do not mean that those editing methods cannot remove physical effects.
Your questions about target-video screening and the training pipeline in Figure 2 also highlight details that need clearer explanation. Thank you for reading the paper carefully.