- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the earsure of unsafe concepts in image-to-video generation, focusing on the issue that both reference images and text prompts may introduce unsafe content. The paper propose the training-free UNITE framework, which consists of two complementary modules: FMB, which relaxes the first-frame constraints on target regions in reference images, and TSP, which identifies text tokens related to the target concept and projects them into a predefined safe subspace. The paper conducts experiments across three scenarios—where unsafe content originates from text, images, or both—and evaluates the effectiveness of erasing nudity and specific character concepts.
Critical strengths
-
Clear practical significance. This paper addresses the issue of continuously injecting unsafe information into the video generation process from both reference images and text conditions. The clear scene segmentation in S1–S3 helps analyze the impact of different condition sources on the erasure effect.
-
FMB and TSP operate on image and text data, respectively, with a clear division of labor. Ablation experiments support the complementary nature of the two modules; in particular, when the reference image contains the target concept, joint processing significantly outperforms using only the text module.
-
The main experiments demonstrated strong erasure performance. UNITE outperformed the compared methods on the nudity detection metrics across all three scenarios, with particularly significant improvements observed in S2 and S3.
Critical weaknesses
-
Lack of robustness evaluation against multimodal adversarial attacks. UNITE was designed to defend against multimodal injection of unsafe information during video generation. Whether it is sufficiently robust against multimodal jailbreaking attacks. Could you evaluate UNITE on the benchmarks like RunawayEvil and MMA.
-
The cross-model generalizability. Most experiments have focused on Wan2.2-TI2V-5B. Although validated TSP on the CogVideoX and Wan T2V settings, these results only support the transferability of the text module and are insufficient to demonstrate that the full UNITE framework is equally effective on other I2V models. Differences in image condition injection methods, text representations, and generation mechanisms across models may affect the performance of the two modules.
Questions for authors
See weakness.
3 comments
Thank you for the detailed response. The clarifications have resolved my questions and I will maintain my current score.
Thank you for your feedback. We are glad that our responses have successfully addressed your questions. If you need any further clarification or have additional questions, please feel free to let us know. We would be happy to provide further details.
Rebuttal by Authors
W1. Evaluation against multimodal adversarial attacks.
A1. We evaluate Base and UNITE on identical attack inputs.
(i) MMA. We transfer all ten final textual attacks from the public example logs to paired safe and unsafe references, without outcome-based filtering.
Table R1. NudeNet detection ratio under transferred MMA textual attacks.
UNITE reduces NudeNet detections under both reference conditions.
(ii) RunawayEvil-based attack transfer. Starting from 20 clothed reference images, we use a RunawayEvil-based pipeline to generate edited images and video prompts. For each policy, all 20 retained image–prompt pairs, including unsuccessful attack attempts, are applied to Base and UNITE under identical generation settings.
Table R2. VLM-flagged video ratio (↓).
UNITE reduces the flagged-video ratio by 20 percentage points under both attack policies.
W2. The cross-model generalizability.
A2. We further evaluate the full UNITE framework, including both FMB and TSP, on CogVideoX1.5-5B-I2V, a different I2V architecture. We adapt FMB to its concatenated image-conditioning channels, with first-frame latent blending at the scheduler's noise level. TSP operates in the model's native text-embedding space during the first 13 denoising steps, together with concept-negative conditioning.
Table R3. Full-framework CogVideoX development evaluation.
As shown in Table R3, UNITE reduces NudeNet detections to 0% in both scenarios, demonstrating that the combined image- and text-side interventions can be extended to another I2V architecture. However, some regenerated-region artifacts remain. These results support cross-model applicability for concept erasure, while further improving generation quality across architectures remains future work.