- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a method called GRAFT, which trains LoRA to achieve T2V concept erasure by replacing the latent frames containing the target concept with frames from the same generated video that are unrelated to the target concept, and then using the edited results to construct supervised data. For videos where it is difficult to naturally generate certain concepts, the authors propose a “split-prompt generation” method to construct training samples and validate the method’s effectiveness on tasks such as nudity removal, object removal, and character identity erasure.
Critical strengths
The method is explicitly motivated by video structure. Constructing erasure targets using safe donor frames from the same video is a distinctive supervised design; split-prompt generation, in turn, addresses the challenge of obtaining donor frames, and together, forms a relatively comprehensive methodological framework.
The results for Nudity Erasure on CogVideoX are outstanding. Table 1 compares publicly available T2VUnlearning checkpoints under the same evaluation process; GRAFT reduces the nude frame rate on Gen from 55.3% to 0.06%, compared to 13.0% for the baseline method. Results on prompt sets such as I2P and SafeSora also support its generalization capability.
Comprehensive experiments. The paper covers multiple concepts and models, and reports on sampler dependencies, degradation in technical quality, cases of failed identity erasure, and limitations of the metrics. These analyses help clarify the method’s scope of applicability and practical trade-offs.
Critical weaknesses
Lack of a stronger baseline comparison. The paper discusses VideoEraser in the “Related Work” section but does not include it in the experiments, nor does it explain why.
The evaluation of temporal quality is insufficient. I am curious whether GRAFT will cause the generated video to appear blurry or result in reduced dynamic range. Appendix E reports on VBench Subject Consistency and notes that this metric may be misleading due to blurriness. It is recommended to supplement this with metrics such as Motion Smoothness, Temporal Flickering, Dynamic Degree, and Background Consistency, and to combine these with human evaluation to distinguis true motion preservation.
The advantage of GRAFT on HunyuanVideo has diminished, but the reasons for this have not been analyzed. In Table 7, GRAFT’s exposure rates on Gen and Ring-A-Bell are 6.1% and 8.4%, respectively, both higher than T2VUnlearning’s 5.0% and 7.0%. Although GRAFT has better aesthetic quality, its erasure advantage has not been sustained. Whether the cause lies in stream-matching parameterization, architecture, training data, or hyperparameters?
Questions for authors
See weakness.
3 comments
Dear Reviewer,
we are thankful for your insightful feedback. As the end of the discussion period on Nov 18 is getting close, we would like to know if there are any additional points we should address. If there are none, we would be grateful if you could let us know whether you would consider raising your score.
Sincerely,
Authors
Thank you for the detailed response and additional experiments which substantially address the main concerns in my original review. Although reduced motion and the unverified applicability of the revised objective to HunyuanVideo remain limitations, the additional evidence strengthens the paper.
Thank you for your helpful feedback. Every change to the paper is in blue; black text is unchanged from the submission.
The main change. Reviewer yurr pointed to the loss in technical quality, and 4Cje and you asked whether grafting degrades the video. We traced the lower measured quality to the training objective and fixed it (Section 3.5). The nudity row of Table 1 now comes from the revised objective, which the paper calls GRAFT; the submitted objective stays beside it as GRAFT-PF, so the trade can be read directly.
This brought a significant improvement in quality and motion, although both stay below the base model's (Appendix E.1). The revised objective covers nudity and the five identities on CogVideoX-5B, where it erases at least as well as the submitted target, and the ten object classes on CogVideoX-2B, where it erases about as well (restricted ESR-1 56.3 against 54.2, 1,000-way 94.3 against 96.2) and preserves more (restricted PSR-1 86.4 against 84.2, now above T2VUnlearning's 86.1). On identities it lowers the target's ID-Similarity by 99% on average (75% under the submitted target), changes the other identities' by 1% and raises their DOVER-t from 0.082 to 0.100 (base 0.105; Table 3). Fire and HunyuanVideo remain under the per-frame target, and the final version will report them under the revised objective.
VideoEraser. It was left out without explanation, which was our mistake. We ran the authors' released pipeline unchanged. On nudity (CogVideoX-5B) it does not lower the per-frame nudity rate: 59.4% on Gen and 58.3% on Ring-A-Bell, against 55.3% and 54.6% for the original model, in line with its authors' statement that it is more effective on concrete concepts. On chain saw (CogVideoX-2B) it erases: restricted ESR-1 60.7 against 68.3 for GRAFT and 11.5 for the original model, with similar preservation (restricted PSR-1 87.8 against 87.2). The results are in Appendix P.
Temporal quality. Appendix E.1 now reports the official VBench Motion Smoothness, Dynamic Degree, Background Consistency and Temporal Flickering (Table 7). GRAFT's Dynamic Degree on Gen falls from 45% to 10%, so its videos move less; its high smoothness, background consistency and flicker scores partly reflect that stillness. Where nothing is erased the loss is much smaller: on 40 held-out prompts of people with visible skin, Dynamic Degree is 58% against 78% at base and mean optical flow 1.87 against 2.32, 81% of the base model's (Appendix E). T2VUnlearning moves more (Dynamic Degree 64%) but scores below the base model on smoothness, background consistency and flicker, which points to unstable motion. The loss is concept-dependent: on identities GRAFT keeps motion, with optical flow on the erased identity's prompts within 15% of the original model's for four of five identities (Table 18), against -57% for GRAFT-PF.
As you suggest, we pair these metrics with a blind human evaluation (Appendix O). Raters who did not know which method produced a clip score GRAFT's motion as natural as T2VUnlearning's (2.53 and 2.38 on a 1–4 scale; the 95% interval rules out GRAFT being worse by more than 0.09). GRAFT's videos therefore move less without looking less natural. The clips of every method, including the base model, are on the anonymous page: https://graft-anonymous.github.io/graft/.
Why is HunyuanVideo weaker? Appendix F.1 now goes through the causes you list. Hyperparameters are not the cause: a factorial over the LoRA scope, learning rate, η and timestep sampling shows a similar trade between erasure and damage in every run, and a rank-128 adapter on the same 40 blocks as T2VUnlearning's eraser behaves like our rank-8 one. We did not vary the training data, so it remains a possible cause; it does differ from the CogVideoX set, most notably in that a quarter of its rows ask for an edit of frames where the detector finds no nudity (Table 10). On parameterization and architecture, a fit probe shows the adapter making a large clip-wide change. We tested the structural difference between the parameterizations (an edit of size ησ under rectified flow against ησ2 under v-prediction): over the noise levels each model is trained on the two coefficients are nearly equal (0.89 and 0.90), so it does not explain the gap, and the averaged target of Eq. 5 scales the same way. We cannot separate the two further: no released video model shares HunyuanVideo's architecture under another parameterization. We had no GPU large enough to train HunyuanVideo during the rebuttal, so the revised objective has not been run on it.