- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes MeshGuard, targeting the intellectual property protection of 3D mesh assets. Text or logos are first encoded into a 128-bit message by BLIP-2 and an MLP, then element-wise modulated on the mid-frequency eigenbasis of the Laplace–Beltrami operator, and vertex offsets computed by a network are applied to the vertices to complete the embedding. On the decoding side, a 3D CNN recovers the bits from potentially attacked meshes. During training, a learnable attack layer and a discriminator are introduced for adversarial training. The authors conduct experiments on multiple datasets and report results superior to existing methods.
Critical strengths
Learned watermarking for meshes has previously been relatively scarce. Using the mid-frequency eigenbasis of the Laplace–Beltrami operator to embed watermarks into meshes is also a reasonable design approach. Combined with various subsequent perturbations, this establishes an overall complete watermark embedding method.
Critical weaknesses
The experimental evidence in the paper is insufficient. The paper does not clearly specify the training and test sets for the messages. On this basis, one can only assume that both are the collection of these 200 logos, which means that for a new watermark, the network can only be retrained, clearly limiting the practicality of the method. Furthermore, can the decoded message be reconstructed back into the original input image, and if so, what is the quality? If not, why introduce the BLIP message encoder instead of directly using random messages?
Questions for authors
Answer the questions raised by the critical weakness.