- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This work proposes Dual-scale Adaptive Temporal Encoding (DATE), which jointly models local contact changes and full-sequence dynamics. Specifically, the work focuses on two physical properties with distinct temporal characteristics: hardness, which relies on long-term deformation accumulation during pressing, and roughness, which is reflected by short-term local texture and shear variations during sliding. Building upon a frozen AnyTouch backbone, this work introduces additional temporal modeling modules to capture property-specific temporal evidence, enabling more accurate tactile property classification.
Critical strengths
- The motivation is clear and physically intuitive.
- The method can handle variable-length tactile sequences and maintain cached representations.
Critical weaknesses
The two most significant weaknesses of this work are: (1) inadequate coverage and discussion of related work, and (2) flaws in the experimental evaluation.
Specifically:
-
Insufficient discussion of related video understanding works. The paper lacks a comprehensive discussion of prior video understanding approaches. To my knowledge, jointly modeling global and local spatio-temporal features has already been widely explored in video understanding, e.g., ViViT [1]. Although existing methods differ in their specific designs, the authors do not explain why these video understanding architectures cannot be directly applied to tactile attribute understanding, nor what unique challenges arise in the tactile domain. More importantly, the most relevant work to this paper appears to be GLFormer [2], which was submitted 1 year ago and published 6 months ago, and therefore should not be considered a concurrent work. The proposed architecture is highly similar to GLFormer, with the main difference seemingly being a straightforward domain transfer from visual videos to tactile sequences. The paper does not clearly identify the fundamental technical differences or novel insights beyond this adaptation. In addition, the recent tactile temporal modeling approach VTV [3], which specifically targets tactile attribute understanding, is not discussed at all. Ignoring these closely related works raises significant concerns regarding the novelty and technical soundness of this paper. The claim that “No existing model preserves short patch-level events and full interaction evolution in parallel, or adapts their relative contributions to each property” appears to be overstated. This statement seems to be based only on the fact that such approaches have not been directly adopted in the tactile domain, rather than on a fundamental limitation of existing methods.
-
Serious concerns regarding the cross-dataset evaluation in Table 2. The results reported in Table 2 are highly questionable. First, the performance of the VitaSet → PhysiCLeAR transfer setting is unexpectedly low. For a three-class classification task, a random classifier should achieve approximately 33% accuracy. However, none of the methods in the Hardness column reaches this level, and similar issues can be observed in other reported results. This raises concerns about whether the evaluation protocol, label definitions, or metric calculation are correctly implemented. Second, some results in the PhysiCLeAR → VitaSet setting appear to be multiples of 1/37, and their standard deviations are exactly 0. Does this indicate that the test set contains only 37 samples? If so, the evaluation may not be statistically reliable, and the reported performance could be highly sensitive to individual samples. These issues suggest serious problems with the cross-dataset evaluation protocol. The authors should provide detailed information about the test set size, class distribution, evaluation procedure, and metric computation, and clarify why the reported results are reliable.
-
Insufficient experimental details. The paper does not provide sufficient details on how different baseline encoders are trained and evaluated on the downstream tasks. For example, it is unclear how the downstream task heads are designed for different baseline encoders. In particular, the statement “TVL uses its original evaluation protocol” is unclear. Does this indicate that TVL adopts a different evaluation setting from other methods? In addition, the data splits used for downstream evaluation are not clearly specified. The authors need to provide a detailed explanation and ideally report results under a unified evaluation setting.
-
Insufficient comprehensiveness of comparisons and ablation studies. To validate the superiority of the proposed temporal encoding module, the authors should include comparisons with simpler temporal modeling approaches, such as applying an LSTM or other standard temporal aggregation modules on top of AnyTouch features. The ablation studies are also not sufficiently comprehensive. Several key components of the proposed architecture, including BiGRU, 3D RoPE, and the gating mechanism, should be individually ablated to quantify their respective contributions. Moreover, the paper mentioned AnyTouch 2 but does not report its performance.
-
Lack of analysis on the gating mechanism. The paper lacks a direct analysis and discussion of the gate outputs. For example, the authors should provide visualizations of the gate outputs in different tactile attribute recognition tasks. Such analysis would serve as direct evidence supporting the motivation that different attributes rely on different types of features. A few Grad-CAM visualizations is far from sufficient to validate the proposed motivation.
-
Unfair comparison of inference time and model size in Table 5. The comparison of inference time and model size in Table 5 appears to be unfair. The authors state that “We evaluate DATE’s runtime using small pre-trained encoder and post-encoder modules at test time,” which seems inconsistent with the actual model used in the main experiments, where DATE is built upon the AnyTouch encoder.
-
Unfair comparison on the TVL benchmark. The comparison in Table 6 is not fair because the proposed method adopts a much more advanced and powerful LLM backbone, Qwen3-VL-8B-Instruct, while previous methods are built upon earlier-generation LLMs (e.g., LLaMA). The performance improvement may therefore come from the stronger language model backbone rather than the proposed method itself. To enable a fair comparison, the authors should either adopt the same LLM backbone as previous methods or re-implement existing methods with the same Qwen3-VL-8B-Instruct backbone.
-
No experimental results for robot interaction and object ranking in Appendix D.
-
Figure 4 is visually cluttered and difficult to interpret. The current design makes it challenging for readers to quickly identify the key experimental findings and compare the performance differences among different methods.
Overall, there are serious issues with the related work discussions and experimental evaluations. The main conclusions of this paper are not sufficiently supported by the current presentation and experiments.
[1] Arnab, Anurag, et al. "Vivit: A video vision transformer." 2021 IEEE/CVF international conference on computer vision (ICCV). IEEE, 2021.
[2] Wu, Hanbo, et al. "GLFormer: a hierarchical cross-layer transformer decoding framework with global–local feature collaboration for video action recognition." Complex & Intelligent Systems 12.7 (2026): 171.
[3] Xie, Yifan, et al. "Universal visuo-tactile video understanding for embodied interaction." Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems 38 (2026): 127864-127883.
Questions for authors
For tactile attributes beyond hardness and roughness, such as the important contact force, which category should they belong to?