acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Learning Stabilizer-Type Constraints with Adaptive Product Measurements

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Large quantum devices are most readily queried by choosing one local Pauli basis per qubit and collecting classical bitstrings. Rather than reconstructing a state or estimating preselected properties, we learn unknown stabilizer-type constraints revealed by these data and reuse them as the state of an adaptive learner. A classical compiler removes resolved directions, packs compatible unresolved directions into the next product setting, and randomly completes the remaining axes. This gives a simple exploration–exploitation loop with no graph, code, generator list, or target-family prior; before any relation is verified, it is exactly uniform Random. Across 30–64-qubit chain, graph, and code-derived targets—including independently drawn graph and CSS cohorts and a mixed state with partial constraints—the same rule completes every fixed structured run and improves on Random across all tested physically organized suites. A layered theory explains what kind of gain is possible: rare residual bottlenecks can change completion complexity; when Random is already polynomial, matching and joint capture yield repeated finite-budget gains; under an isotropic completion law, no stable directional advantage is available. Controlled interventions validate these mechanisms, and readout-noise experiments test verified feedback and targeted tail search.

Primary area:
applications to physical sciences (physics, chemistry, biology, etc.)
Keywords:
Quantum machine learning, Adaptive experimental design, Constraint learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_UwqkOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how adaptive product measurements can improve the learning of unknown stabilizer-type constraints in quantum systems, namely exact relations among measurement outcomes. Under fresh-copy product-Pauli readout, each setting chooses an X, Y, or Z axis on every qubit, and different settings expose different relations. Uniform Random does not reuse previously learned structure and may therefore require many uninformative settings. The authors propose a representation-generating feedback loop: the learner initially samples uniformly at random, discovers candidate relations from outcome batches, and independently verifies them on fresh outcomes. The verified span then serves as both the learned representation and the persistent acquisition state. A classical learned-row compiler constructs a physical residual frame, packs compatible unresolved directions into the next product setting, and uniformly fills the remaining axes, combining structure reuse with continued exploration. The central contribution is to compile verified relations into executable measurement settings without a supplied graph, code, generator list, or target-family prior. The theory identifies distinct regimes: rare residual bottlenecks can yield a polynomial–exponential separation in expected settings under explicit structural conditions, while accessible local structure can improve finite-budget progress. Experiments using stim cover 30–64-qubit targets. Across 15 fixed structured instances with 50 runs each, Learned-row completes all 750 runs and is fastest on 11 of the 15 instances. However, the method does not universally outperform other policies: Random-Clifford targets show no decisive advantage, and noisy relation extraction can incur substantial classical cost.

Critical strengths
  1. Effective feedback mechanism for adaptive measurements. The paper proposes a practical approach that uses verified stabilizer relations to guide subsequent measurements without requiring prior knowledge of the target structure. The learned-row compiler constructs a physical residual frame and combines compatible measurement directions. Ablation studies further demonstrate the importance of residual-space representation and measurement packing. 
  2. Solid theoretical analysis and experimental validation. The paper explains when adaptive measurements provide benefits, including polynomial–exponential separations under specific structural conditions, finite-budget improvements, and limitations in isotropic settings. Experiments across diverse quantum structures support these findings. The proposed method completes all 750 runs on 15 fixed structured instances and achieves the best performance on 11 of them.
Critical weaknesses

The paper considers mixed and non-stabilizer states, yet the false-admission bound in Appendix G relies on non-stabilizer candidates having zero expectation under the stated pure-stabilizer readout model. This property does not hold for general quantum states. Candidates with expectation values near ±1 may therefore be incorrectly admitted as exact constraints under finite-sample validation, affecting subsequent acquisition. The paper should clarify the scope of its validation guarantees and either restrict the applicable state class or introduce additional assumptions and guarantees that distinguish exact from approximate constraints.

Questions for authors
  1. How does fresh-data verification distinguish exact stabilizer-type relations from near-deterministic relations in general mixed and non-stabilizer states?
  2. What properties of the physical residual frame explain why RREF/free-column wins all four code/check rows, while Learned-row performs better on most graph targets in Table 2?
Reviewer_rTr2OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3(+1)
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes an adaptive method for learning unknown stabilizer-type constraints using product-Pauli measurements. Its central idea is to reuse verified constraints to guide subsequent measurements and improve the discovery of new relations. The method maintains verified relations, constructs a residual proposal frame through stabilizer-tableau completion, and greedily packs compatible proposals into subsequent measurement settings. The authors analyze conditions under which this adaptive strategy can outperform random measurements and evaluate it on a range of structured quantum states. The experiments show improved recovery efficiency on the tested structured targets, with ablation studies examining the sources of these gains and additional evaluations under readout noise.

Critical strengths

The paper provides a substantial empirical evaluation across diverse structured targets. The ablation studies help identify which components of the method contribute to the observed improvements in measurement efficiency. These results strengthen the empirical case for reusing learned constraints to improve measurement efficiency on structured quantum systems.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited algorithmic originality. The main algorithm is Algorithm 1. Its core steps are stabilizer-tableau completion through Stim (line 8), greedy construction of a maximal compatible set (line 14), and extraction, verification, and updating of the learned relations (lines 17–18). This appears primarily to extend existing Stim-based stabilizer processing with a greedy measurement-selection heuristic. I do not see a substantial original algorithmic contribution beyond this combination.

  2. The theoretical analysis lacks depth. Section 4.1 essentially multiplies the retention probability ρ\rho by the random-matching probability 3−r3^{-r}, which by itself provides little insight into why the proposed algorithm should outperform Random. Section 4.2 considers a highly specialized target structure. The paper does not sufficiently explain how likely the required configurations are to arise during an actual learning process. Moreover, Theorem 1 is not an unconditional polynomial-time guarantee: terms such as 3−r∗3^{-r_*} in the denominator can still produce an exponential bound. Polynomial guarantees are only provided for GHZ and another specially constructed case, rather than for the general setting. Section 4.3 continues to focus on particular examples, including corridors and explicit BB5-30 spans. Proofs restricted to these special cases are insufficient to establish that the proposed algorithm generally performs better than Random.

Questions for authors
  1. What is the substantive algorithmic contribution of Algorithm 1 beyond combining Stim-based tableau completion, greedy compatibility packing, and standard relation updates?

  2. How do the theoretical results establish an advantage over Random beyond the selected examples? In particular, how often do the required very specific structural conditions hold along actual learning trajectories?

Reviewer_JyZ9OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposed a framework to learn unknown stabilizer-type constraints from product-Pauli measurememts of single-copy. The authors try to find Pauli relations and exploit the structure to guide subsequent circuit measurements instead of estimating prediction observables. The authors perform experiments on 30–64-qubit stabilizer systems, including GHZ and graph-state on a simulator. It demonstrate improvements over random acquisition.

Critical strengths

I am not familar with the direction of the paper. Within my knowledge, I can see the following strengths:

1. Clear problem target. The target problem of the paper is clear from my perspective. i.e. between discovering unknown Pauli constraints and predefined observables. Learn a compact representation that can tell later observables is meaningful and potentially useful.

2. Interesting approach. The method connects the commutation structure of stabilizers with Pauli-product measurement constraints. The mechanism is conceptually interesting and does not require instance-specific target information.

3. Theoretical and empirical analysis. The manuscript provides theoretical and empirical results characterizing when adaptive observation can help.

Critical weaknesses

I find it hard to understand the paper and I believe there is a large room to improve the writing to make it easily accessible for the general audience. The logic is not tight and I have to guess what the authors would like to talk about next. This is a critical issue.

Regarding the contents of the manuscript, from what I can see, I gave the following:

  1. (strong) The main separation from the theoretical perspective is established against a weak baseline. The polynomial-versus-exponential separation for GHZ states is interesting. However, it is established against uniformly random, independently selected local Pauli axes. I do not think this establishes a comparable advantage over stronger nonadaptive product-measurement strategies.

  2. Limited evidence beyond idealized simulations. All experiments are performed using classical stabilizer simulation, and the noise analysis is restricted to independent readout flips. The work does not evaluate correlated noise, or noisy measurement rotations. These can impact when the policy relies on exact protocols.

  3. Formatting and presentation. Pages in the main manuscript are not fully used, despite substantial technical details and experimental results being moved to the appendix. This normally suggests that the available page budget could have been used more effectively to present important supporting evidence in the main text. While this does not directly affect the technical quality of the paper, better organization of the space could potentially improve its readability.

Questions for authors

See weakness.

Comments on the paper

2 comments
Area_Chair_8keVOpenReview ↗

Please respond to the authors

Dear reviewers,

Thank you for your service.

The authors have provided their response to your initial reviews. As we approach the end of the author-reviewer discussion period, could you please respond to the authors’ rebuttal (if you haven’t done so already) and communicate the extent to which your concerns have been addressed, and whether you have any further questions and concerns?

Thanks, Your AC

Dear Area Chair,

Thank you for your thoughtful follow-up and for taking such an active and conscientious role in coordinating the discussion. We sincerely appreciate your time, care, and commitment to a thorough review process.

Best regards, The authors

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.