- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes an end-to-end learning framework for measurement feedback in dynamic parameterized quantum circuits (DPQCs). The circuit consists of a pre-measurement block , a mid-circuit measurement with outcome , outcome-dependent gates parameterized by , and a post-measurement block . Instead of manually specifying the feedback rule, the authors jointly optimize the feedback parameters and the circuit parameters. To handle the discrete measurement outcome, the paper uses exact branch decomposition, explicitly evaluating all measurement branches and optimizing a balanced branch objective. The paper also derives analytic lower bounds for outcome-independent circuits and evaluates the approach on VQE ground-state preparation and classification tasks, together with studies of different architectures, measurement configurations, readout noise, and feedback latency.
Critical strengths
I do not identify a major strength that compensates for the fundamental problem-formulation issue discussed below. The paper contains substantial theoretical and experimental analysis within its assumed DPQC model, but in my view the significance of these results depends on first establishing that the assumed mid-circuit measurement addresses a meaningful need in the target application.
Critical weaknesses
-
The main problem formulation appears artificial for the targeted VQE application. The paper assumes a VQE architecture containing a mid-circuit measurement and then proposes to learn how to respond to its outcome. However, unlike quantum error correction, fault-tolerant protocols, or measurement-based quantum computation, the VQE problem considered here does not intrinsically generate or require such an intermediate measurement. The paper does not establish that introducing this measurement is necessary or advantageous for solving the underlying ground-state-preparation problem. Consequently, the measurement creates the branch-dependent feedback problem that the proposed method subsequently solves.
-
The theoretical advantage does not establish the usefulness of mid-circuit measurement for VQE. The analytic floor compares outcome-dependent processing against outcome-independent processing after the measurement has already occurred. Once a measurement has generated orthogonal branches, it is natural that allowing different operations on the branches can outperform forcing the same operation on both. However, an ordinary VQE circuit that does not perform the intermediate measurement does not suffer this measurement-induced restriction. Therefore, crossing the proposed floor establishes the usefulness of the measurement record given that the measurement was performed, not the usefulness of performing the measurement itself.
-
The paper lacks the baseline needed to support the VQE motivation. The relevant comparison should include a resource-matched VQE circuit without mid-circuit measurement and, ideally, a coherent conditional circuit that preserves the quantum information rather than measuring it and converting it into a classical branch variable. Without these comparisons, it is difficult to determine whether the proposed architecture provides any benefit over solving the original VQE problem directly.
-
The training objective is not generally the physical expected loss. The paper optimizes \frac{\ell_0+\ell_1}{2}, whereas actual executions encounter the branches with probabilities and , giving p_0\ell_0+p_1\ell_1. The paper explicitly distinguishes these quantities. When branch probabilities are unequal, the two objectives may favor different solutions. This further weakens the connection between the proposed optimization problem and the physical VQE objective.
Questions for authors
My main concern is with the premise of the work rather than the optimization technique itself. Before asking how to learn a feedback rule following a mid-circuit measurement, the paper needs to establish why such a measurement should be present in the target VQE problem. In applications such as quantum error correction, syndrome measurements arise naturally and independently of the feedback algorithm; therefore, learning a response to those outcomes constitutes a meaningful problem. I do not see an analogous motivation established for the VQE task studied here.
The current results show that once a mid-circuit measurement is imposed, using its outcome can outperform ignoring its outcome. This is not sufficient to demonstrate that mid-circuit measurement is beneficial for VQE. Indeed, the measurement itself creates the orthogonal branches responsible for the outcome-independent floor. I therefore encourage the authors to compare against a resource-matched unitary VQE circuit with no intermediate measurement and against an appropriate coherent-control baseline. The central question should be whether introducing measurement and feedback improves the solution of the original ground-state-preparation problem, rather than whether feedback helps after measurement has already been imposed.
Alternatively, I believe the proposed learning framework would be substantially better motivated in an application where intermediate measurement is intrinsically required, such as quantum error correction or a fault-tolerant measurement-based protocol. In such a setting, the problem “given an unavoidable measurement outcome , learn the optimal response ” would have a clear application-level meaning.
In its current form, I view the problem-formulation issue as fundamental. The technical results may be valid within the assumed DPQC model, but the paper has not established that solving this assumed feedback problem advances the target VQE application. For this reason, I would not consider additional optimization results within the same assumed architecture sufficient to address my primary concern; the authors would first need to justify the architecture itself or move to an application in which the measurement has an independent purpose.
2 comments
Part 2 of 2
Part 2 answers the four questions and reports the syndrome experiment.
Q1. Why a measurement at all. The paper does not answer this by asserting that VQE needs one. Where the measurement is not required, it does not claim it should be added. It answers a question well posed in any architecture: given a record, what is it worth, and can the response be learned. The measurement is the family's primitive and the floor is what makes its value decidable before training.
Q2. Is the unitary comparison the central question? Yes, and it belongs in the headline table rather than an appendix. W3 adds both arms, and the revision reports them in the first table of the energy section. On the two reset heads the same question has no coherent counterpart.
Q3. An application where the measurement is intrinsic. The setting you recommend is already two of our three task families: in the phase and XOR heads the measured bit is the only carrier of the label. We also ran the syndrome task, a three-qubit repetition code with one round of bit-flip noise at rate p, two ancillas measured mid-circuit, and a 12-angle recovery table indexed by the observed syndrome. Training uses the exact logical error, which is computable here because every error pattern is a basis state, so there is no surrogate mismatch either. The learned rule matches the Bayes decoder in every setting we ran, largest gap 1e-4, and it finds that decoder from the logical error alone, without being told the code or the noise model.
| p | readout q | no recovery | textbook | Bayes hand | learned |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.05 | 0 | 0.136 | 0.007 | 0.007 | 0.007 |
| 0.10 | 0 | 0.244 | 0.028 | 0.028 | 0.028 |
| 0.20 | 0 | 0.392 | 0.104 | 0.104 | 0.104 |
| 0.05 | 0.10 | 0.136 | 0.178 | 0.102 | 0.102 |
At q=0 the learned table is majority vote. With readout error it does something a textbook rule does not: at p=0.05, q=0.10 it corrects only the syndrome that noise cannot easily fake, so it beats the textbook rule, 0.102 against 0.178, and beats doing nothing, 0.136. The same ordering holds at q=0.20 and p=0.10, where it reaches 0.204 against 0.316 textbook and 0.244 no recovery.
Q4. Would further results within the same head help? No, and the revision is built accordingly. W3 changes the comparison class, Q3 changes the application. Neither is another optimization result inside the assumed head.
The certificate is the piece that outlives any single arm. It is computed from the task rather than from the trained circuit, and it transfers unchanged to the syndrome setting, where the record exists by necessity.
Part 1 of 2
We thank the reviewer for the report. The standard it sets is clear: justify the architecture, or move to a setting where the record has a purpose. We answer on both sides. We start with the contribution, because the disagreement is about whether it survives the formulation.
The paper contributes three things. A certificate computed from the task before training, which says whether the record can change the attainable objective at all, with no analogue in a hand rule or a trained decoder. A rule that lives inside the circuit as four angles, trains without a sampling estimator, and beats a tuned 12-rule hand family by 1.72x at h=2. A measured boundary, where the channel pays when the measured bit carries label information, 0.175 bits on MNIST, and stops paying when it does not, 0.006 bits on CIFAR. The scope is explicit: one to three measured qubits, state-vector simulation, no hardware claim. The abstract will say this in its first sentence, and that framing was ours to make explicit.
W1. The object is the circuit family, not VQE alone. The premise is correct for VQE taken alone, and the paper does not rest on it. The object is the dynamic parameterized circuit family, whose definition includes one mid-circuit measurement and which is provably at least as expressive as unitary circuits of equal depth. VQE is the benchmark we instantiate it on, not an application claim, chosen because its floor has a closed form in the Hamiltonian spectrum. The question is conditional: given a record, when does using it pay, how much, and can the rule be learned.
W2. The floor prices the record, and a unitary circuit has no such price. It separates using the record from ignoring it once the measurement exists, which is the certified quantity. It is not a restatement of the design: it holds over the whole m-independent family, is attained exactly, and moves with the payload spectrum, 0.184, 0.732, 1.507 at one, two and three measured qubits. The measurement does not create a problem for the method to solve; it defines a resource class with a computable ceiling, and the method reaches that ceiling. A coherent circuit has no record, hence no branch class to bound, so the certificate is not defined for it rather than contradicted by it.
W3. The baselines are added, and they do not subsume the reset heads. The stronger claim, that the dynamic circuit solves the ground-state problem better than a unitary VQE at the same budget, is a different claim and we will measure it: a no-measurement arm at matched depth, gate count and restarts on all nine energy cells. The existing outcome-independent arms hold depth and gate count and drop only the dependence on the record, 0.620 and 0.552 against 0.200, but they still project at the mid-point, so they bound the value of the record rather than the cost of the projection. The coherent arm is added on all 27 cells and reported beside it. Neither subsumes the two reset heads, where measure-reset-condition has no unitary counterpart and needs an ancilla.
W4. Two quantities, two jobs, and they coincide on 18 of 27 cells. In the phase head p_m=1/2 exactly for both classes, and in XOR branch m is the sample, so L_bal is the empirical risk rather than a surrogate. The nine energy cells are where they differ, and there the physical cost is in the deployment table.