- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents MagicCore-LM, an interface to represent near-Clifford quantum circuits with algebraic structure instead of raw gate sequences to neural network. It studies the effectiveness of this representation using the measurement expectation prediction task. Experiments show mean absolute error reduction and generalization to unseen settings compared with raw gate inputs.
Critical strengths
The idea of designing a compact algebraic interfaces for neural models instead of directly using gate sequences is valuable, as representation is a core component to model learning and gate sequence might not be ideally learnable.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper is poorly written. (1) It didn't give a clear description of the compact representation it actually uses, how it is represented in tokens and features. A complete coordinate-by-coordinate specification is essential. (2) It didn't present a clear and complete introduction to the model architecture, input/output, data generation, training pipeline, etc. in the main text. A single figure in Figure 2 without detailed explanation prevents the reader from understanding the overall framework clearly.
- For experiments, (1) the paper didn't specify the observables used, how are selected, benchmark distribution, sufficient details of "Position-free compact vanilla, DeepSets, and Set Transformer" baselines, etc. (2) The paper mentions "four active qubits". If that means the model only applies to circuits with four active qubits, or needs to be retrained for each different active qubit number, it would severely limit the practicality of the model. The framework needs to apply to larger qubits to be pratically meaningful. (3) For the baseline comparison, are baselines such as Circuit-image CNN, Circuit-DAG GNN presented in Table 2 evlauated on the same task as in Table 1, or the primary task? Why use different settings (frame-explicit v.s. compact representation) for these baselines? (4) As Table 27 shows, pretrained LLM gives negligible contributions to the prediction. (5) If I understand correctly, according to Table 14, MagicCore has very little OOD improvement over the trivial zero predictor, which diminishes the generalization claim.
Questions for authors
Could you resolve the problems raised above?