acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Readable Coordinates, Distributed Concepts: Concept Supervision in DreamerV3

Abstract

Concept supervision gives a world model a vocabulary: named coordinates report facts such as whether an agent has wood or is running low on energy. Understanding what these reports reveal requires connecting the readable interface to the representation behind it. We study this connection in DreamerV3 on Craftax-Classic through a paired comparison of concept supervision, localization regularization, and sparse-representation objectives. Across five starting checkpoints, supervised scalar readouts consistently outperform their raw-coordinate controls, while the same concepts remain highly predictable from the surrounding state. The most revealing differences emerge beneath the aggregate scores: objectives with similar overall readability expose different inventory, spatial, and physiological variables, producing distinct views of the agent’s state alongside different training-return profiles. Two analytical results sharpen this interpretation. Identical decoding measurements can accompany different causal roles, and shared temporal structure can preserve predictability even after labels are reassigned between episodes. Together, these findings characterize concept supervision as a way to construct readable interfaces within distributed representations. They show how the value of a named coordinate depends on which concept it exposes, how reliably it reports that concept, and what the available evidence establishes about its relationship to the wider model.

Primary area:
interpretability and explainable AI
Keywords:
World models, concept-based interpretability, reinforcement learning, concept supervision, representation learning, concept localization

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_vo54OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies concept supervision in the latent representations of DreamerV3, using Craftax-Classic as the experimental environment. The authors assign 14 human-defined concepts to designated latent coordinates and investigate whether these concepts remain predictable from the rest of the representation. They compare direct coordinate supervision, additional localization regularization, an ablation-based objective, sparse autoencoders, and a self-ablation baseline.

Critical strengths

The paper investigates an interpretable representation problem in model-based reinforcement learning. The paired-checkpoint experimental setup and per-concept analyses provide some useful descriptive observations about how different regularization objectives affect concept readability.

Critical weaknesses

The paper revisits well-established questions in supervised disentangled representation learning for a specific world model. The observation that supervising individual latent coordinates improves their predictability of predefined concepts, while the same information remains recoverable from other dimensions, is largely expected given the extensive prior literature on disentanglement and distributed representations.

Similarly, the distinction between concept decodability and causal usage has been studied extensively in interpretability and probing research. The analytical example in Figure 1 is a straightforward construction illustrating this known distinction rather than a substantial new theoretical result

All experiments are conducted on a single environment (Craftax-Classic) and a single model architecture (DreamerV3), using only 14 supervised concepts and five starting checkpoints. The results therefore provide limited evidence about the generality of the observations.

Given the limited novelty and narrow empirical scope, the contribution does not appear sufficient for ICLR.

Questions for authors

N/A

Reviewer_dtb4OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies whether concept supervision creates readable coordinates in a DreamerV3 world model trained on Craftax-Classic, and how those coordinates relate to concept information in the remaining state. Five starting checkpoints are continued under an unpenalized control, three nested concept objectives, a sparse-autoencoder objective, and a self-ablation mask. Supervised scalar readouts achieve median axis AUROC of 0.834–0.853, while concept predictability from the complementary state remains approximately 0.999–1.000. The paper also reports concept-level differences and training-return ratios. Analytical examples illustrate that observational decoding does not establish causal use and that episode-reassigned labels can remain predictable through shared temporal structure.

Critical strengths

None sufficient to support acceptance. The paper states the limits of its measurements carefully, but this clarity does not resolve the concerns about the central comparison or establish a substantial new finding.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The headline readability gain is measured against an unmatched control. The concept-supervised conditions train both the designated coordinates and concept-specific scalar calibrations, whereas the unpenalized, SAE, and mask conditions are scored using raw assigned coordinates. Consequently, the reported gap between supervised axis AUROC and the approximately 0.5 raw-coordinate scores does not isolate an improvement in the underlying representation. A capacity-matched, episode-disjoint scalar readout on each control coordinate is needed to establish the size of that improvement. The raw-axis evaluation also does not test the interpretability of the SAE’s learned features.

  2. The remaining findings do not establish effective localization or a substantial functional contribution. Complement AUROC stays near 1.0 after the residual-regularization and ablation objectives, so these experiments provide no evidence that concept information became less recoverable outside the designated block. The concept profiles are measured on corpora generated by different continued policies, and return ratios are taken from training telemetry rather than independent evaluation rollouts. The two analytical examples clarify familiar limitations of decoding, but are not interventions on the trained agents. As a result, the paper mainly shows that directly supervised readouts can report their training concepts while leaving their distribution and computational role unresolved.

Questions for authors
  1. What are the held-out, per-concept axis AUROCs if an identical one-dimensional logistic calibration is fitted to the assigned coordinates of every condition using training episodes only? What paired supervised-versus-control differences remain after matching readout capacity and orientation¿

  2. Do A-loc and A-full reduce concept predictability from either the nondesignated recurrent coordinates (h_t[K:]) or the stochastic state (z_t), considered separately?

  3. What are the paired returns from independent evaluation rollouts for all six conditions? Do they support the training-return differences reported in Table 2?

Reviewer_8hvyOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the relationship between the concept readability and distributed representations, and provides an empirical analysis of concept supervision as a way to construct readable interfaces within distributed world model representations. The authors use DreamerV3 on Craftax-Classic to study whether explicitly supervising designated latent coordinates to predict human-defined concepts is able to produce interpretable representations. And further, they study if the corresponding concept information is still recoverable. Authors compare three objectives, coordinate supervision, additional residual cross-covariance and readout regularizer. Experiments show that supervised coordinates improve concept readability by a large margin while concept information remains predictable from the complementary latent representation.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper provides a systematic comparison of multiple representation objectives, which help understand how additional constraints impact concept accessibility and agent performance.
  2. The experiments design is well controlled. The authors continue five common starting checkpoints under these different objectives. It provides a more controlled comparison. Additionally, the authors report training-return ratios together with the interpretability metrics, which helps understand potential tradeoffs between readable representation and agent performance. Also the paper provides analysis on the concept level, which help clarify the results further.
  3. The paper provides careful analysis and discussion in terms of the interpretation of the observed measurement. It separates the ability to decode a concept from recovering the concept and the causal role of the coordinate in downstream computation, and provides counterexamples.
Critical weaknesses
  1. My main concern is that the experiments are conducted in a very limited setup. All the results and conclusions are drawn from one architecture and environment. It makes the conclusion harder to generalize and less credible. The 14 supervised concepts are simulator-defined and may have substantial correlations. Moreover, the reported return ratios are computed from training logs rather than independent policy evaluation rollouts. It would be very useful if the authors could provide more experiments under more diverse settings. Additional independent evaluation episodes and paired confidence intervals will also strengthen the conclusions.

  2. A major emphasis of the paper is the distinction between observational decodability and causal use. But the actual experiments evaluate only observational accessibility, while the causal argument relies on a simple synthetic construction. Since the experiments are mainly conducted in the simulator and Dreamer V3’s latent state, which is a highly controlled setting, I suggest the authors add more causal interventions on designed coordinate to test whether changing a concept coordinate will actually influence world model predictions, imagined trajectories, and agent actions as claimed in the paper. The paper recognized the interpretability limitation but rarely the empirical evidence about the actual functional role of the learned interfaces.

  3. The supervised conditions use learned scalar transformations specifically trained to predict each concept, whereas the unpenalized, SAE, and self-ablation conditions are evaluated using raw latent coordinates. The concern I have is the substantial AUROC improvement does not necessarily mean it’s the underlying representation changes that caused it. It could also just be from the advantage of having a concept-specific, trained readout. This problem is especially important given the main finding is the improvement in readability.

Questions for authors

It would be great if the authors could respond to the questions brought up above as "critical weaknesses". I will consider raising the scores if those get properly addressed.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.