acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Concept Envelope Model

Abstract

Pretrained embeddings can be highly predictive while encoding task-relevant concepts in a form that is not readable as a single direction. Yet concept-bottleneck and dictionary-score methods often expose each named concept through a scalar score, which can obscure semantic structure spread across multiple embedding directions. Motivated by the Linear Representation Hypothesis and semantic structure in embedding space, we introduce Concept Envelope, which connects predictive sufficiency with concept-based interpretability and offers a way to retain task-related semantic variation beyond prediction alone. Concept Envelope is a supervised neural method that jointly learns a concept subspace and a nonlinear predictor with soft covariance separation, followed by post-hoc semantic grounding. Across seven visual benchmarks, it maintains competitive predictive accuracy. Two quantitative interpretability metrics show retention of independently defined semantic directions, including those missed by accurate prediction-only subspaces, and transfer of estimated edits to held-out intervention pairs. Controlled language tasks further show that dictionary scores can follow surface wording rather than latent state.

Primary area:
interpretability and explainable AI
Keywords:
interpretable machine learning, concept-based interpretability, subspace learning, envelope models

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_Ex1HOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Concept Envelope, a method for learning low-dimensional representations that aim to preserve semantic information beyond what is required for prediction. The method jointly optimizes a task prediction loss and a covariance-separation penalty to learn a linear subspace, followed by a post-hoc concept grounding procedure to interpret the learned representation. The evaluations are conducted on seven visual benchmarks using predictive accuracy, concept activation vector retention, and edit fit, while further considering constructed day-of-week and month-of-year prediction tasks. While the results demonstrate improvements in retaining certain predefined semantic directions, the methodological novelty and the broader significance of the proposed approach remain insufficiently established.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper considers the distinction between predictive sufficiency and semantic preservation, which is a practical problem to investigate in representation learning.
  2. The proposed objective is relatively straightforward to implement and combines task supervision with a covariance-separation penalty, making the approach easy to understand and evaluate.
  3. The evaluation considers several aspects of representation quality beyond predictive accuracy, including concept direction retention and the transferability of semantic edits.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The proposed method primarily combines supervised subspace learning with a covariance-separation penalty motivated by existing envelope methods, followed by post-hoc concept grounding. The paper does not sufficiently establish what fundamental methodological insight or capability distinguishes this combination from existing approaches.
  2. The optimization objective explicitly penalizes cross-covariance between the retained subspace and its orthogonal complement, but the paper's central claim concerns semantic preservation. The connection between these two objectives remains insufficiently justified, as covariance separation alone does not guarantee that the retained directions correspond to meaningful or comprehensive semantic factors.
  3. The proposed semantic metrics primarily evaluate predefined concept directions and selected paired interventions, while the language experiments rely on constructed tasks. Although the results demonstrate improvements under these specific settings, they provide limited evidence that the method consistently preserves meaningful semantic structure or offers broader practical benefits.
Questions for authors

I expect the authors to address my concerns in the weaknesses section.

2 comments

We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful assessment.


Q1: Is there an insight beyond combining known components?

A1: Yes. The insight is to read a pretrained representation through the envelope of its predictive subspace. Envelopes were introduced in statistics for efficient estimation in regression. We apply them to a different problem: making a compact part of a pretrained representation both predictive and readable as concepts, where a concept may span several directions. Existing approaches each give up one side of this goal. Concept bottlenecks keep interpretability by forcing prediction through scalar scores for predefined concepts, and dimension reduction keeps accuracy by retaining only what the label needs. Concept Envelope learns, from the task label alone, a subspace that is both predictive and readable, and names its directions afterwards. A2 explains why the envelope has this property. Making this work with pretrained representations also requires a new estimator, which learns the subspace jointly with a nonlinear predictor under covariance separation.


Q2: Why does covariance separation preserve semantics?

A2: The connection rests on the linear representation hypothesis, which we use as a working assumption. If semantic factors are approximately linear, the covariance of the representation is organized by concepts, and penalizing cross-covariance discourages the subspace from keeping one direction while dropping another correlated with it. We agree that covariance separation alone does not guarantee semantic recovery, as stated in Section 2. The envelope keeps the concepts used for prediction and those correlated with them, but not every semantic factor. Empirically, the directions it adds are concepts defined independently of the method, such as the Waterbirds background, which a prediction-only subspace barely retains.


Q3: Does the evidence reach beyond controlled settings, and what is the practical use?

A3: We evaluate semantic preservation on datasets whose concept factors are controlled by construction, with interventions whose true change is known, and on tasks with a known state geometry, because these are the settings where preservation can be verified. This is the type of evidence we provide, and it does not cover every task. The practical use is to see, from task labels alone, which concepts a predictive representation carries, including context entangled with the label that a prediction-only representation would drop. On the real-image benchmarks, post hoc grounding of the learned subspace gives such readings (Appendix Table 2). The CelebA blond-hair subspace contrasts light hair with dark hair and facial hair, a male-associated trait, and the CUB species subspace is organized first by habitat, perched woody vegetation versus aquatic or shoreline settings. They come without any concept annotation.


We hope these clarifications address the reviewer's concerns, and we would be grateful for a reconsideration of the assessment.

Thanks for your response. However, after carefully considering the rebuttal, my main concerns regarding the novelty and significance of the work remain insufficiently addressed. Therefore, I will maintain my original score.

Reviewer_NpfcOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces Concept Envelope to address the problem that a representation can be sufficient for prediction while losing important semantic information. The method learns a low-dimensional subspace using task labels and a covariance-separation penalty, then uses concept dictionaries to interpret the learned subspace. Experiments on seven visual datasets show competitive accuracy and better preservation of certain concept directions compared with prediction-only methods. The paper also provides theoretical analysis to support the proposed approach.

Critical strengths

S1. Applying the envelope framework to concept-based interpretability is an interesting idea.

S2. The experiments evaluate both prediction accuracy and semantic preservation, providing useful evidence for the proposed approach.

S3. The paper is clearly written and easy to follow.

Critical weaknesses

W1. On Waterbirds, the background CAV Retention increases from 4.91% to 52.94%, but this only shows that more background information is preserved. It would be interesting to see how the model's predictions change when the bird-related and background-related directions are modified separately. This could help clarify which concepts the classifier actually relies on.

W2. The comparison with PCBM could be more convincing. Appendix A.2 mentions that PCBM uses similarities to generated concept embeddings on several datasets, rather than the task-specific CAVs used in the original method. Since the quality of the concept dictionary can affect PCBM's performance, it would be useful to include a comparison with task-specific CAVs, at least on datasets such as Waterbirds and CelebA.

W3. The covariance penalty does not consistently improve concept preservation across datasets. On FunnyBirds, several CAV Retention scores barely change, and the Foot Edit Fit even drops from 53.85 to 40.64. Why does the penalty help significantly on Waterbirds and COCO-BAM but provide limited improvements on FunnyBirds?

W4. Algorithm 1 mentions an orthogonal rotation for interpretation, but it is unclear how this rotation is chosen. For example, was the rotation in Figure 3 determined automatically or manually?

W5. In the day and month experiments, named and indirect descriptions are trained and tested separately. It would be useful to test whether a model trained on named descriptions can also handle indirect ones. This would better show whether the model captures the underlying state rather than just the wording.

Questions for authors

Please refer to weakness

1 comment

We thank the reviewer for the careful reading and concrete suggestions.


Q1: Does the retained background matter for the classifier's decisions?

A1: Yes, partly. We changed the bird and the background separately and checked whether the prediction changes. Following the construction of Waterbirds, we pasted the 600 test birds onto land and water backgrounds, with each landbird paired with a waterbird on the same two backgrounds. A background change thus keeps the bird, and a bird change keeps the background. Share of predictions that change (%), 300 comparisons per row, five seeds:

Changeλ>0\lambda>0λ=0\lambda=0
Background, landbirds6.47.4
Background, waterbirds24.619.6
Bird, on land70.275.9
Bird, on water86.486.4

The classifier relies mainly on the bird, and partly on the background, as the training set's correlation suggests. Both models show this dependence, slightly more at λ>0\lambda>0. The increase in background retention from 4.91% to 52.94% therefore mainly changes how the background is represented. At λ=0\lambda=0 the background is mixed into the predictive direction, and at λ>0\lambda>0 it becomes a separate, readable direction of the subspace.


Q2: Would PCBM do better with task-specific CAVs?

A2: Task-specific CAVs help PCBM on Waterbirds and CUB, but PCBM remains below Concept Envelope on all three datasets. We added PCBM and PCBM-h with task-specific CAVs, as in the original PCBM. Each CAV is a linear probe fitted on concept annotations: on CUB, 109 annotated attributes; on Waterbirds, the same attributes plus the background label; on CelebA, the 39 attributes other than the task label. Test accuracy (%), five seeds; the generated-dictionary rows are from Table 1:

MethodWaterbirds AvgWaterbirds WGCelebA AvgCelebA WGCUB Avg
PCBM, generated dictionary80.149.994.635.969.6
PCBM, task-specific CAVs84.061.294.930.278.6
PCBM-h, generated dictionary92.681.295.340.882.3
PCBM-h, task-specific CAVs92.780.095.242.083.2
Concept Envelope92.571.295.346.281.9

Q3: Why does covariance separation help on some datasets but not others?

A3: It helps where prediction alone drops a task-related concept, and changes little where prediction already keeps the concepts. This is what the prediction–preservation gap of Proposition 1 predicts. Covariance separation has something to add only when the smallest predictive subspace is smaller than the concept subspace. On Waterbirds and COCO-BAM, the prediction-only model (λ=0\lambda=0) retains little of the background and the scene, and covariance separation recovers them. On FunnyBirds, the classes are defined by combinations of bird parts, so the prediction-only model already retains the part directions. Covariance separation has little to add there, and retention is nearly unchanged. The drop in Foot Edit Fit is not explained by this argument. We report it as an observed limitation.


Q4: How is the interpretation rotation chosen?

A4: Automatically, by a fixed rule. The rotation only chooses a basis inside the learned subspace for display and naming. It is applied after training, so it changes neither the subspace nor the predictions, and every reported metric depends only on the subspace. For Figure 3, the two learned coordinates are rotated to their principal axes on the test set, and the sign of each axis is fixed by the group means so that water backgrounds and waterbirds point in the positive direction. No angle is chosen by hand. In the revision, we will state this rule in Algorithm 1 and in the caption of Figure 3.


Q5: Does a model trained on named descriptions also handle indirect ones?

A5: Not in this embedding. We ran the suggested test, training on named descriptions and testing on indirect ones. No method does well on the indirect descriptions, including the full-embedding MLP. Test accuracy in %, five seeds; chance is 14.3% for days and 8.3% for months:

MethodDaysMonths
Concept Envelope34.750.0
PCBM, state names33.255.8
Full-embedding MLP36.165.4

The reason is in the embedding. The states of named and of indirect descriptions lie in subspaces that overlap little for days, with a largest principal cosine of 0.38, and only partly for months, with 0.81. What is learned from one kind of description applies to the other only as far as these subspaces overlap.


We hope these clarifications and new results address the reviewer's concerns.

Reviewer_Sz9kOpenReview ↗
Rating
2(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes Concept Envelope, a method that learns a low-dimensional linear subspace of a frozen pretrained embedding jointly with a nonlinear predictor. A covariance-separation penalty borrowed from statistical envelope methods is added to the task loss. The paper argues that this penalty makes the subspace retain concept structure beyond what prediction alone requires. A post-hoc grounding stage interprets the concepts in the subspace. Predictive accuracy and concept structure are evaluated on several benchmarks. Some theoretical results are proven.

Critical strengths
  1. Applying statistical envelope methods to concept-level interpretability is a fresh idea. The argument that a predictive subspace may need to be larger than the minimal sufficient one to preserve concept geometry is well-motivated.
Critical weaknesses
  1. It is unclear to me what the benefit of Concept Envelope is, or how it fits with other concept-based techniques. What can it do that existing methods cannot? Task accuracy is comparable to the baselines, so the benefit must lie in the explanations. But in what way are they better? If concepts are not exposed through a scalar score, how are they exposed to the user? The positioning against multi-dimensional concept methods is thin, e.g. Concept Embedding Models, which represent each concept as a high-dimensional supervised vector rather than a scalar. The high-level takeaways from the theory are also unclear. Relatedly, I found the abstract unclear and difficult to follow.

  2. I am unconvinced by the claim that dictionary scores will follow wording instead of state (Section 3.3), and more detail is needed for reproducibility: for example, how was PCBM applied to text? I believe the dictionary learning baselines in this experiment could be stronger: for example, supervised concept probes could be trained, or SAEs could be used. Concept Envelope at λ=0 could be evaluated to isolate the effect of the penalty. One of the prompts in this experiment is ill-posed ("The meeting is scheduled for Monday. What day is tomorrow?" does not fix today's day).

  3. In several places clearer language is needed. For example, what does "response-supervised" mean on line 71? What does "transfer to held-out intervention pairs" mean on line 85? The paper is, at times, hard to follow as a result.

Minor Issues

These minor issues did not affect my rating and do not need to be addressed in the rebuttal (although they could be fixed in a future iteration of the manuscript).

  1. Some claims, like the one on lines 41–42 that scalar scores can obscure concept geometry, could use a citation.
  2. Appendices, such as those describing hyperparameter selection, could be referred to and briefly summarised at relevant points in the paper.
  3. Methods/baselines (e.g., SAVE) used in the main paper should be introduced and cited.
Questions for authors
  1. What is the concrete benefit of Concept Envelope over existing concept-based methods: better accuracy, better explanations, or something else? What problem does it solve that other methods do not?

  2. For the day and month tasks (Section 3.3), could Concept Envelope be compared to more, stronger dictionary score baselines?

  3. Could the abstract and contributions be made clearer and stated in plain language?

3 comments

Response to Reviewer Sz9k (1/2)

We thank the reviewer for the careful questions and for catching the ill-posed prompt.


Q1: What does Concept Envelope offer that existing concept-based methods do not?

A1: The benefit of Concept Envelope lies in the balance between prediction and interpretation. In our comparisons, concept-bottleneck models such as PCBM provide named concept scores but lose accuracy, while the full-embedding MLP and PCBM-h, among the most accurate models in Table 1, rely at least partly on the full embedding, which cannot be read as concepts. Concept Envelope remains competitive in average accuracy while predicting through a small linear subspace whose directions can be grounded in concepts.

How concepts are exposed. In Concept Envelope, a concept is read as one or more directions of the learned subspace and named post hoc with a concept dictionary. We do not use one scalar score per predefined concept, because a concept need not be a single score or a single direction. For example, the day-of-week state in Section 3.3 forms a cycle in a two-dimensional subspace, which Concept Envelope recovers from indirect descriptions but scalar dictionary scores do not.

Relation to Concept Embedding Models. We agree with the view, shared by Concept Embedding Models [1] and by recent work on multi-dimensional features in language models [2], that a single scalar can be insufficient to represent a concept. However, Concept Embedding Models and Concept Envelope address different problems. Concept Embedding Models are supervised concept bottlenecks. Given labels for a predefined set of concepts, they learn an embedding for each concept so that the bottleneck model keeps its task accuracy. Concept Envelope is trained without concept labels. It uses YY to learn which subspace of a frozen embedding to retain, and names its directions afterwards.

Takeaway from the theory. The theory explains when covariance separation matters. If prediction needs fewer directions than the task-related concepts occupy, an accurate subspace can drop some of them (Proposition 1), and covariance separation keeps them (Section 4.2), as for the Waterbirds background in Section 3.2. If every concept direction is needed for prediction, as in the indirect day/month tasks where the label is determined by the state, prediction alone keeps them and λ=0\lambda=0 gives the same result.

Response to Reviewer Sz9k (2/2)

Q2: Does the day/month result hold with stronger baselines and a corrected prompt?

A2: Yes. We now add PCBM with a supervised, task-specific CAV bank, and Concept Envelope at λ=0\lambda=0. PCBM scores each input by cosine similarity to the embeddings of its concept bank and maps the scores to the label with a width-64 MLP head. The CAV bank replaces the state-name embeddings with one class-balanced logistic-regression probe per state, fitted on the named training split, where every probe reaches a validation AUC of 1.00. The day bank is used on both day corpora and the month bank on both month corpora, and the PCBM head is trained on each corpus as before.

We agree that "What day is tomorrow?" does not fix the current day. In the 107 affected named-day templates, we replaced it with "What day comes after that?", and in 40 named-month templates, "What is the next month?" with "What month comes after that?"; labels, splits, and the indirect corpora are unchanged. We reran the named tasks and ran the two new methods on all four tasks. On the unchanged indirect tasks, methods already in Table 13 keep their submitted values. Test accuracy (%):

MethodDay, namedDay, indirectMonth, namedMonth, indirect
Concept Envelope99.7099.40100.0094.44
Concept Envelope, λ=0\lambda=098.5199.4099.5494.44
PCBM, state names (oracle)100.0058.33100.0067.59
PCBM, generated dictionary (agent)100.0076.49100.0082.87
PCBM, task-specific CAVs100.0067.26100.0072.22
PCBM-h (each bank)100.00100.00100.00100.00

Supervised CAVs do not close the gap. They recognize every named state, but PCBM with these CAVs reaches only 67.3% and 72.2% on indirect descriptions, while Concept Envelope reaches 99.4% and 94.4% with two coordinates. Scores defined from named descriptions thus fail to recognize the same state when it is described indirectly. In this sense, such scores follow the wording. A dictionary generated from the indirect training descriptions themselves also stays well below Concept Envelope, at 76.5% and 82.9%. The state itself remains decodable from the embedding, as PCBM-h shows, but not from scores defined on the named descriptions. An SAE-feature bank without names is a different interface from named concept scores and does not test this claim. Engels et al. [2] use SAEs to show that days and months are multi-dimensional, which is consistent with our view.

Concept Envelope at λ=0\lambda=0 gives the same results on both indirect tasks. This is expected because the next state is determined by the current state, so prediction already needs the whole state structure and leaves nothing for covariance separation to add. Section 3.3 thus compares a learned subspace with scalar concept scores, and Section 3.2 shows the role of covariance separation.


Q3: Can the abstract, contributions, and terms be made clearer?

A3: We appreciate this feedback. In the revision, we will simplify the abstract and the contribution list along the lines of A1, describe the PCBM setup for the day/month tasks in Appendix A.5, and add the requested citation, appendix pointers, and introductions of SIR, SAVE, and PLS. "Response-supervised" comes from sufficient dimension reduction, where YY is called the response. Here it means that the subspace is trained with YY only, without concept labels. "Transfer to held-out intervention pairs" means that an edit direction estimated from one set of paired interventions, such as the same scene with a dog replaced by a truck, also describes the change on new pairs of the same type. This is what Edit Fit measures (Section 3.2).


We hope these clarifications and new results address the reviewer's concerns, and we would be grateful for a reconsideration of the assessment.

References.

[1] Espinosa Zarlenga et al. (2022) Concept Embedding Models: Beyond the Accuracy-Explainability Trade-Off

[2] Engels et al. (2025) Not All Language Model Features Are One-Dimensionally Linear

Thank you for your response.

Q1: What does Concept Envelope offer that existing concept-based methods do not?

Thank you for clarifying. I believe I now understand the aims of Concept Envelope more clearly; however, I am still not convinced of the broader practical benefits it offers over other concept-based methods.

Q2: Does the day/month result hold with stronger baselines and a corrected prompt?

I'm afraid that some details needed to reproduce this experiment still aren't clear. For example, will the corpora/templates be released? Will the paper be updated to incorporate these additional details and results?

The title of this section in the paper is "Dictionary Scores Can Follow Wording Instead of State". I believe including SAEs as a baseline would help to strengthen the evidence for this claim, as SAEs are a dictionary learning method. Also, it seems to me that the goal of SAEs, namely decomposing a representation into interpretable concepts, is very close to the goal of Concept Envelope.

Q3: Can the abstract, contributions, and terms be made clearer?

I'm afraid I cannot see a revised version of the paper so am unable to judge whether this concern has been addressed.

As the aim of Concept Envelope is now clearer to me, I will increase my score to 2. My main remaining concern the practical significance of the work.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.