- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes three modules, VIBE, COEX, and COMPASS, for event-guided image deblurring and deraining. VIBE augments event features with several hand-crafted temporal statistics, COEX replaces conventional fusion gates with a projected 2 x 2 mixing matrix, and COMPASS uses event-conditioned weights over five fixed spatial shifts. The resulting model reports strong numbers on GoPro, HighREV, and NTURain.
Critical strengths
- The paper does evaluate on both synthetic and real-event settings, and the reported numerical performance is strong if the comparisons are correct. In particular, the method reports improvements on GoPro, HighREV, and NTURain rather than relying on a single benchmark.
- The authors at least attempt controlled component studies rather than reporting only a full-model result. The retrained GoPro baseline and several replacement experiments are useful in principle, although I do not think the current ablations are sufficient to support the stronger mechanism-level claims.
Critical weaknesses
Before the technical issues, I have concerns about the overall level of care. Figure 1 does not clearly communicate where VIBE, COEX, and COMPASS operate or what their defining computations are, and the later figures are similarly cramped and difficult to inspect. The Related Work section also mixes equations and dataset statistics into the literature discussion, while notation such as G_\sigma remains undefined even when reused in Sec. 3.1. Given the authors’ disclosed use of generative AI for manuscript drafting, analysis and plotting scripts, literature surveying, and discussion of the ablation matrix, I would have expected substantially more careful human verification and editing.
- The motivation appears somewhat reverse-engineered around the three proposed modules. The paper summarizes existing event-guided restoration through three “heuristic design choices”: image-like event processing, gating-based fusion, and direction-agnostic decoding. This characterization overlooks recent methods that already use motion-aware event representations, asymmetric cross-modal interaction, and explicit edge or motion modeling [a–d]. The proposed modules themselves also feel rather ad hoc. VIBE uses four hand-selected statistics, COEX imposes an insufficiently justified conservation constraint on learned latent features, and COMPASS is essentially an event-conditioned five-tap dynamic filter. The additional complexity of COEX is particularly unclear given that a 2x2 doubly stochastic mixer can be parameterized much more simply.
- I have more serious concerns about the experimental comparison. Table 1 reports MAENet at 34.50 dB / 0.9534 on GoPro, whereas [a] reports 36.07 dB. AHDINet is similarly reported as 36.98 / 0.9642, compared with 37.09 / 0.9820 in [b]. These discrepancies are too large to dismiss as rounding, and the provenance of the baseline numbers is not sufficiently clear. The comparison also omits highly relevant recent methods [c,d]. In addition, the ablations are conducted only on synthetic-event GoPro and are mostly cumulative, so they do not establish that VIBE explains the real-event improvement on HighREV or that COMPASS provides the claimed directional benefit on NTURain. The modified EGVD evaluation is also difficult to interpret because its recurrent state is reset for every input after the standard setting reportedly “collapses.”
- References
- [a] Motion Aware Event Representation-driven Image Deblurring, ECCV 2024.
- [b] Asymmetric Hierarchical Difference-aware Interaction Network for Event-guided Motion Deblurring, AAAI 2025.
- [c] Separation for Better Integration: Disentangling Edge and Motion in Event-based Deblurring, ICCV 2025.
- [d] Event-Based Motion Deblurring Using Task-Oriented 3D Gaussian Event Representations, CVPR 2026.
Questions for authors
- Please clarify the provenance of the baseline results in Tables 1–3. Which numbers are taken from the original papers, which are obtained by reevaluating official checkpoints, and which are produced by the authors’ own retraining? In particular, the reported MAENet and AHDINet results on GoPro appear inconsistent with their published numbers. These discrepancies need to be clarified before the claimed SOTA improvements can be properly assessed.
- The paper organizes the motivation around three supposedly common limitations of existing event-guided restoration methods. How broadly do these three limitations actually apply to recent methods? In particular, how are the proposed ideas positioned against “Motion Aware Event Representation-driven Image Deblurring” (ECCV 2024), “Separation for Better Integration: Disentangling Edge and Motion in Event-based Deblurring” (ICCV 2025), and “Event-Based Motion Deblurring Using Task-Oriented 3D Gaussian Event Representations” (CVPR 2026)? The latter recent works also seem highly relevant to the claimed event-specific representation and motion-aware modeling.
- The component analysis is conducted only on GoPro. Can the authors provide at least a basic ablation on HighREV and NTURain? Since the paper motivates VIBE partly through event reliability and COMPASS through directional degradation, it would be important to verify that these components remain useful on real events and on deraining rather than only on synthetic-event GoPro.
- Why is EGVD evaluated with its recurrent state reset for every input? Since temporal recurrence is part of the original method, this modification appears to change its inference behavior. What happens under the original sequential inference protocol, and why does that setting “collapse” in the authors’ reproduction?
- The real-event deblurring evaluation is currently limited to HighREV. Why are other commonly used real-event benchmarks, such as REBlur, not included? Given the paper’s relatively broad claims about event-guided deblurring, additional real-event evaluation would make the empirical conclusions substantially more convincing.