- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes MambaSEE, a compact event-guided framework for broad-range brightness restoration. The architecture combines fixed-width image-event fusion, MambaIRv2-inspired global state-space blocks, a quantization-aware FIFO ConvGRU for short-term temporal aggregation, and a prompt-conditioned lightweight decoder. The model reports strong results on SDE and SEE-600K with a relatively small parameter/storage footprint. Overall, the paper is technically polished and substantially stronger than a routine architecture submission, but I am not yet convinced that the methodological novelty and the current experimental comparisons are sufficient for acceptance.
Critical strengths
- The empirical results are strong. MambaSEE consistently improves over the reported baselines on both SDE and SEE-600K, including sizeable gains over SEENet, while maintaining a compact model. The evaluation also covers real event-camera datasets rather than relying on synthetic data alone.
- The paper is generally well organized and technically detailed. The authors clearly document the input construction, temporal aggregation, quantization scheme, complexity accounting, and evaluation protocol, and the supplementary material is substantially more complete than what is typical for many architecture papers.
Overall, I appreciate that this submission does not read like a fully automated “auto-research” paper. The figures and overall presentation appear to have received genuine manual attention, which I value given the current trend toward heavily automated submissions. I am still not convinced that the paper reaches the acceptance bar in its current form, but I would be open to raising my score if the rebuttal addresses the main concerns convincingly and the paper remains competitive within my review batch.
Critical weaknesses
-
The technical novelty and task-specific motivation are not yet sufficiently convincing. The dominant spatial component, GSSB, closely follows the Attentive State-Space Module of MambaIRv2, while the remaining ingredients—additive fusion, ConvGRU, quantization-aware training, and depthwise decoding—are individually standard. The paper states that the novelty lies in their task-specific organization, but it does not clearly explain why the MambaIRv2-style semantic routing and state-space formulation are particularly suitable for event-guided brightness restoration, beyond providing generic global context. This is especially important because the largest ablation gain (4.54 dB) comes from replacing Swin with GSSB, whereas the proposed temporal module contributes only about 0.33 dB. The method section therefore reads more as a sequence of architectural design choices than as a mechanism driven by a clear insight into the task.
-
The experimental comparison is generally reasonable as an end-to-end benchmark evaluation, but several issues limit the interpretation of the claimed accuracy-efficiency advantage. First, recent directly relevant methods are missing, including BiEvLight (CVPR 2026) and EIC-LIE (CVPR 2026), both of which evaluate event-guided low-light enhancement on SDE. Second, MambaSEE uses three causal frame–event pairs, whereas some prior methods, such as SEENet, use a single frame–event pair. This is a legitimate architectural choice, but it makes it difficult to determine how much of the gain over prior work comes from the proposed architecture versus the additional temporal evidence. The efficiency comparison is also based on heterogeneous accounting: MambaSEE reports a cached steady-state MAC estimate and mixed-precision FP32-equivalent storage, while baseline FLOPs and parameter counts are quoted under their original FP32 settings, and the MambaSEE MAC estimate excludes routing and selective-scan operations. The accounting is clearly disclosed, but the current results support a promising accuracy-efficiency trade-off more strongly than a fully controlled efficiency superiority claim.
Questions for authors
-
Beyond inserting MambaIRv2-style GSSBs after image-event fusion, what task-specific modification is made to the state-space/routing mechanism itself? Can the authors explain what property of event-guided exposure restoration specifically motivates semantic token routing, rather than simply replacing Swin with a stronger generic restoration block?
-
Could the authors provide a more controlled comparison with MambaIRv2-style or other global restoration backbones under matched width/parameter budget? The current Swin-to-GSSB ablation shows a large gain, but does not clarify how much comes from the proposed task-specific design versus adopting a stronger pretrained/restoration-oriented spatial operator.
-
Why are BiEvLight (CVPR 2026) and EIC-LIE (CVPR 2026) absent from the SDE comparison? Both are recent event-guided LLIE methods evaluated on the same benchmark.
-
Could the authors clarify how much of the gain over SEENet is attributable to the architectural changes versus the additional temporal context? A matched comparison between SEENet and a K=1 MambaSEE variant, followed by K=1 versus K=3 within MambaSEE, would help disentangle these factors.
-
For SDE, how much performance remains if the oracle target-brightness prompt is replaced with a fixed or input-predicted value? Since the current prompt is computed from the ground-truth normal-exposure reference, this seems important when comparing against methods that do not receive equivalent target information.
-
For the “lightweight” claim, could the authors clarify the practical deployment advantage beyond FP32-equivalent storage? The current W8A8 result is based on fake quantization and theoretical bit-width accounting, while the reported MAC estimate excludes some state-space/routing operations. A unified runtime or memory comparison under the same hardware/backend would make this claim substantially stronger.
12 comments
W2 - Recent methods, temporal inputs, and efficiency
Thank you for highlighting these comparison and efficiency concerns. We distinguish broader benchmark coverage from controlled attribution and practical deployment measurements. These three issues now have separate responses:
-
Recent methods. BiEvLight and EIC-LIE have been added to Related Work and the SDE comparison [6,7]. EvLight++ is also included as a published video-method comparison [2]. Q3 provides the added accuracy values and their provenance.
-
Temporal evidence. The single-frame Case 3 and new window/direction controls show that multi-frame input is not required for all of the reported improvement. Q4 separates that observation from the still-unavailable unified SEENet rerun.
-
Efficiency scope. The current evidence supports an accuracy–weight-storage trade-off. It does not establish a common-backend runtime advantage from heterogeneous FLOP/MAC counts or fake quantization. Q6 states that boundary explicitly.
Evidence: Tables 1–4 (pp. 7–10); Appendix A.3 and B.4–B.5.
Q1 - What changes in the state-space or routing mechanism?
Thank you for requesting a more precise description of the task-specific changes. Our task-specific adaptation lies in the input representations and the architectural organization surrounding the inherited state-space operator.
-
What is inherited. The attentive state-space/routing mechanism follows MambaIRv2 [3], including the original-order prompt choice explained by its authors [4].
-
What is task-specific. GSSBs receive fused features from separately adapted RGB and event inputs. Spatial processing operates within each observation, the FIFO module aggregates across observation times, and the decoder incorporates the target-brightness prompt.
-
Why use global context? When local RGB evidence is unreliable, information from spatially separated related regions can be useful. Semantic routing is one way to provide that interaction. This motivates our choice, but it is not evidence that the operator is inherently better for events than every other global backbone.
The scope of novelty is therefore the compact restoration system and its division of roles, not a renamed or newly derived MambaIRv2 operator.
Evidence: Related Work and Method (pp. 3–6); Appendix B.2 (p. 19).
W1 — Technical novelty and task-specific motivation
Thank you for asking us to clarify the task-specific contribution. MambaSEE combines global spatial modeling, bounded temporal evidence, and explicit target-brightness conditioning within a compact restoration framework; its contribution is not limited to the GSSB replacement. We attribute GSSB's underlying state-space/routing mechanism to MambaIRv2 [3], rather than claiming a new operator.
Table K. SDE accuracy, cost, and input settings (selected rows from manuscript Table 2).
The columns and values follow manuscript Table 2; only rows are omitted. Average equally weights Indoor and Outdoor. Temporal denotes multi-frame/recurrent processing, not matched history lengths; MambaSEE uses three causal pairs. Eq. Storage denotes theoretical FP32-equivalent weight storage. †MambaSEE counts one operation per MAC with cached steady-state feature reuse; accuracy uses full-window recomputation. Baseline FLOPs retain their source conventions.
Table 3. Progressive module-level ablation on SEE-600K (reproduced from the manuscript).
Case numbers, configurations, storage values, and per-condition scores follow manuscript Table 3. R1 denotes the original SEENet decoder, DWConv the depthwise-convolutional decoder, and “--” disables temporal aggregation. Cases 4 and 5 use the same architecture with selected GRU layers in FP32 and W8A8, respectively. Bold marks the best score in each metric column.
Why GSSB is important but not the whole explanation. Table 3 shows the largest gain from the spatial replacement (Cases 1–2), while the decoder (Cases 2–3) and temporal module (Cases 3–4) add 0.57 dB and 0.33 dB mean PSNR with GSSB retained. These means equally weight the three lighting conditions. The temporal gain reaches 0.71 dB under low light. Quantization serves a different purpose: reducing theoretical weight storage from 0.73M to 0.48M while retaining comparable reported accuracy.
Simple components with a favorable complete-model trade-off. Table K, excerpted from manuscript Table 2, reports 25.71 dB for MambaSEE, exceeding SEENet and EIC-LIE by 2.14 and 1.93 dB, respectively, with 0.48M FP32-equivalent weight storage—about one quarter of SEENet's 1.90M. The design allocates capacity to global spatial reasoning while keeping fusion, history handling, and reconstruction compact, rather than uniformly shrinking a large fusion backbone. These are end-to-end accuracy–storage results; component attribution comes from the ablations, not the benchmark ranking alone.
Reference: manuscript Section 3 (Problem Formulation and spatial/temporal definitions), Tables 2–3, and Section 4.1.