acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

ReasonOps: Operator Segmentation for LLM Reasoning Traces

10 views

Abstract

Chain-of-thought traces from large reasoning models can span tens of thousands of tokens, yet we lack a vocabulary for describing their internal structure. Previous methods developed to analyze chain-of-thought traces are either too rigid or not expressive enough, failing to capture features across domains and models. To remedy this, we introduce ReasonOps, an unsupervised method that discovers a shared vocabulary of discourse operators for segmenting and annotating chain-of-thought traces. Using ReasonOps, we analyze 44,662 traces from 12 thinking LLMs spanning 6 families across 8 reasoning benchmarks and discover that they share a common compositional structure: 7 recurring reasoning operators—discourse-level moves such as Backtracking, Inferring, and Hypothesizing—that emerge from unsupervised clustering of sentence-initial 3-token pivots. These operators appear across every model family and benchmark domain, confirmed by three independent LLM judges who classify held-out samples at 70–76% accuracy. We analyze the structure of operators on easy vs. hard problems, revealing that the association between reflective operators and correctness changes with problem difficulty. Reasoning traces are highly model-identifying: structural operator features plus anchor-phrase text features recover the source model with macro-AUC , revealing that each model family has a distinctive reasoning fingerprint. Structural operator features predict within-problem answer correctness well above baselines. Classifiers built on these operators reach WP-AUC globally and on AIME. ReasonOps further enables early quality estimation well before the trace completes: we predict at WP-AUC for only 50% of the trace. Comparing OLMo checkpoints with a common base shows distinct operator distributions across post-training recipes, with greater backtracking under math- and code-focused training. The ReasonOps pipeline is unsupervised and annotation-free, enabling deep insights into LLM reasoning traces as well as strong downstream results on model identification and correctness prediction.

Primary area:
interpretability and explainable AI
Keywords:
Automated interpretability, Benchmarking Interpretability, Applications of interpretability

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_iuM1OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents ReasonOps, an unsupervised method for segmenting LLM reasoning traces into discourse operators. The method extracts sentence-initial three-token phrases and clusters them into seven categories, including INFERRING, HYPOTHESIZING, and BACKTRACKING. The authors analyze 44,662 traces from 12 models across eight benchmarks, comparing operator usage across models, tasks, and answer outcomes. They also use these operators for model identification and correctness prediction, achieving a macro-AUC of 0.987 with additional text features and a global WP-AUC of 0.701, respectively. Early correctness prediction and inference-time candidate selection are also examined.

Critical strengths

S1. Large-scale analysis across models and reasoning tasks. The study covers 44,662 reasoning traces from 12 models across six families and eight benchmarks. The authors examine operator usage across different tasks, model families, problem difficulty levels, and answer outcomes. The OLMo checkpoint comparison is a useful addition. It shows clear differences in operator distributions under different post-training recipes, providing evidence that the extracted discourse patterns reflect differences in model behavior beyond the immediate task.

S2. Predictive results supported by extensive experiments. The combined operator and anchor-text features achieve a macro-AUC of 0.987 for model identification. For correctness prediction, the operator-only OST reaches a global WP-AUC of 0.701, outperforming the reported scalar baselines. It also achieves 0.664 WP-AUC when only 50% of a reasoning trace is available. The paper includes human annotation results, alternative clustering methods and sentence encoders, and a detailed hyperparameter sensitivity study. These experiments help characterize both the performance and limitations of the proposed representation.

Critical weaknesses

W1. Limited semantic consistency and coverage of the induced discourse operators. ReasonOps relies on sentence-initial phrases to assign operator labels. Such phrases can indicate discourse functions, but their interpretation may depend on the surrounding context. The human validation results suggest that some of the proposed categories are difficult to distinguish consistently. The two annotators agree with the induced labels on 62.4% and 52.0% of the evaluated spans, respectively, and agree with each other on 58.0%. Appendix N shows particularly low agreement for HYPOTHESIZING and CONSTRAINING. Another concern comes from Appendix Q. Changing the sentence encoder produces substantially different cluster assignments (ARI = 0.350–0.418), while downstream prediction scores remain relatively close. The predictive information appears more stable than the particular semantic categories used to represent it. Coverage is also not fully established. Appendix O reports that 28.0% of spans are unlabeled structural boundaries in a sample of 6,000 Claude traces. The authors acknowledge that this sample is not representative of the full corpus, but the corresponding figures for other models and benchmarks are not provided. Taken together, these results leave the consistency and coverage of the seven-category vocabulary uncertain.

W2. The contribution of grouping the original phrases into seven operators is not clearly isolated. The paper shows that the operator representation is predictive. The model-identification result reaches 0.987 macro-AUC with additional anchor-text features, while Appendix Q reports approximately 0.947 AUC using operator features alone. The operator-only OST also achieves 0.701 WP-AUC for correctness prediction. What remains unclear is whether the clustering step itself contributes to these results. The authors vary the number of operators, clustering algorithms, and sentence encoders, but do not compare the seven-category representation directly with the original three-token phrase features under matched conditions. Without this comparison, it is difficult to separate the benefit of the proposed abstraction from the predictive information already present in the sentence openings. There is also relevant prior work on reasoning-trace structure, including The CoT Encyclopedia and ReasoningFlow. Their representations differ from ReasonOps, but a clearer discussion of what the seven-operator vocabulary reveals that these approaches do not would strengthen the paper's contribution. Finally, Appendix S reports improvements over random candidate selection, but no statistically significant improvement over selection by trace length. The practical benefit of the operator representation in this application therefore remains limited.

Questions for authors

Q1. Semantic consistency of the operators. The two human annotators recover 62.4% and 52.0% of the induced labels, with considerable variation across categories. What accounts for the disagreements? Are certain operator definitions overlapping, or do the errors mainly arise from assigning labels using sentence-initial phrases?

Q2. Contribution of the clustering step. Could the authors compare the seven-operator representation against unclustered three-token phrase features using the same prediction models and data splits? This would help determine whether the clustering step adds value beyond the original lexical information.

Q3. Coverage of unlabeled spans. Appendix O reports that 28.0% of spans are unlabeled in the examined Claude sample. How does this proportion vary across models and benchmarks? Does excluding these spans affect the coverage or predictive performance of the resulting operator sequences?

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Thank you for your review

Thank you sincerely for your thoughtful review. We have not decided to update the paper at this time for this conference based on our feedback from reviewers, but we are genuinely thankful for your time. We will take your comments into account in our future revisions to the paper.

Reviewer_fps3OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This submission proposes "ReasonOps", which segments CoTs and labels their operating roles. Subsequently, "ReasonOps" is shown to be useful for classifying CoTs.

Critical strengths

The manuscript studies an important problem, which is the segmentation of large reasoning models' chain of thoughts.

The proposed dataset could be potentially useful.

Critical weaknesses

The biggest weakness of the manuscript is its high similarity with prior work. "ReasonOps" might be a new naming; however, the similar mechanism has been studied extensively by our community. For example, this paper (https://openreview.net/forum?id=klPszYDIRT) has used an almost identical set of operators the submitted manuscript has used (e.g., execution, transition, and reflection). This work (https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.07364) is similar in using the segmentation and segments’ roles. This paper (https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.22148; especially Figure 3) also presents almost identical operators and discourse cues.

The reasoning segmentations (steps) and the steps' roles/operations have already been extensively studied in these well-cited published works.

A side contribution of the paper is using the "ReasonOps" as a way to identify which model produces the CoT. However, this aspect also lacks novelty. This work (https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.24147) identifies LRM using its CoTs. In fact, the Figure 2 in this publication has already shown CoTs operators this submission defines in a similar way. A more recent study (https://aclanthology.org/2026.naloma-1.4/) also shows the authorship of the CoTs.

Overall, the paper's core contribution has high overlap with these prior studies (many published far ahead of the ICLR submission date). The manuscript struggles to show its scientific value, given its high overlap with prior studies.

Questions for authors

Presentation suggestions: A few tables in the appendices are spreading across two pages (Table 12); consider better formatting.

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Thank you for your review

We appreciate your time and effort in conducting the review for our paper. We were not aware of these previous works, and we appreciate you bringing them to our attention as this will help us guide future iterations of this project. We have decided not to submit rebuttals for this conference as a result of the sentiment of reviewers, but we sincerely thank you for your feedback.

Reviewer_FJgqOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces ReasonOps, an unsupervised framework for analyzing and characterizing Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning traces generated by large language models. The authors analyze 44,662 reasoning traces collected from 12 LLMs across 6 model families and 8 benchmarks, and argue that these traces exhibit a shared structure consisting of seven recurring reasoning operators.

Specifically, the proposed method extracts sentence-initial pivots containing up to three tokens, applies frequency-based filtering, and performs K-means clustering using pretrained text embeddings. The resulting seven clusters are interpreted as Initiating, Qualifying, Grounding, Inferring, Hypothesizing, Backtracking, and Constraining.

The authors report that these operators appear across different models and benchmark domains. They further investigate their utility for model identification and answer correctness prediction. In particular, the proposed Operator Sequence Transformer (OST) achieves a within-problem AUC (WP-AUC) of 0.701 using only operator sequences, suggesting that structural patterns in reasoning traces contain information predictive of answer correctness.

The paper presents an interesting approach to structuring and quantitatively analyzing complex reasoning traces. However, the experimental evidence remains insufficient to establish whether the discovered clusters consistently represent meaningful reasoning functions and whether the resulting operator taxonomy generalizes independently of model family, model scale, training methodology, and task domain.

Critical strengths

S1. An efficient framework for analyzing reasoning traces

Representing lengthy CoT traces as compact sequences of reasoning operators is a useful approach. In particular, the ability to annotate new reasoning traces without additional LLM calls or embedding computations makes the proposed framework computationally attractive for large-scale analysis.

S2. Evaluation across diverse models and benchmarks

The collection of 44,662 reasoning traces from 12 models and 8 benchmarks is a strength of the paper. The analysis covers multiple domains, including mathematics, science, and coding. The comparisons of operator distributions across model families and post-training strategies are also interesting.

S3. Demonstration of potential downstream applications

The results suggest that operator-based representations contain useful information for model identification and answer correctness prediction. In particular, the OST model achieves reasonable predictive performance using only operator sequences, without access to the original reasoning text. The sensitivity analyses in Appendix Q, including comparisons of embedding models, clustering algorithms, and pivot lengths, are also valuable additions.

Critical weaknesses

W1. Insufficient evidence that the discovered clusters correspond to meaningful reasoning functions

My primary concern is that semantic similarity among sentence-initial expressions does not necessarily imply equivalence in their underlying reasoning functions.

In Section 3.1, the authors extract the first three tokens of each sentence and cluster these expressions using pretrained embeddings and K-means. However, the clustering procedure does not directly account for the remaining sentence content, preceding reasoning context, or subsequent changes in the reasoning process.

The same sentence-initial expression may serve different reasoning functions depending on its context. Conversely, the same reasoning function may be expressed using different lexical patterns.

For example, Section 3.2 indicates that expressions beginning with "I need to" and "Okay, so I need to" can be assigned to different operators despite potentially describing similar reasoning actions. Appendix J also presents an example in which a sentence that appears to summarize a conclusion is assigned to Hypothesizing.

I acknowledge that the authors explicitly characterize these operators as discourse-level moves in the generated text rather than as direct representations of internal cognitive operations. Nevertheless, even under this narrower interpretation, it remains necessary to establish whether sentence-initial pivots reliably capture the intended discourse functions.

The semantic validation in Section 4.1 and Appendix N evaluates whether LLM and human annotators can reproduce the labels induced by clustering. However, this does not constitute validation against independently established ground-truth reasoning functions.

Furthermore, human agreement with the induced labels is relatively limited, with accuracies of 62.4% and 52.0% for the two annotators. Some individual operators exhibit particularly low agreement. For example, the second annotator achieves F1 scores of only 0.35 and 0.19 for Hypothesizing and Constraining, respectively.

These results raise concerns about the semantic distinctiveness and reliability of some induced categories.

Therefore, the current evidence supports the existence of interpretable lexical clusters, but does not sufficiently establish that the seven clusters consistently represent distinct reasoning functions.

W2. Insufficient independent validation of operator generalizability across models and datasets

The paper emphasizes that the seven operators are observed across diverse LLMs and benchmark domains. However, the observation of shared operators across multiple datasets should be distinguished from the independent discovery of consistent operator structures across those datasets.

In Section 3.1, reasoning traces from all models and datasets are pooled to construct the pivot vocabulary and perform a single clustering procedure. The resulting operator dictionary is subsequently applied to each model and benchmark to analyze operator distributions.

Consequently, the results in Figure 2 demonstrate that a shared operator dictionary can be applied across the evaluated models and datasets. They do not necessarily establish that the same operator structure would emerge independently from each model family or benchmark domain.

Furthermore, the pivot filtering criterion requires an expression to appear in at least 100 distinct reasoning traces and three datasets, but does not explicitly require balanced occurrence across model families.

Therefore, lexical patterns primarily associated with particular model families may still influence the resulting clustering structure.

To substantiate the claim that the discovered operators represent generalizable reasoning structures, I believe additional experiments are necessary:

  • Leave-One-Model-Family-Out evaluation: Discover operators without using traces from a particular model family, and evaluate their coverage and semantic consistency on the excluded family.

  • Leave-One-Dataset-Out evaluation: Discover operators using a subset of benchmarks and examine whether the resulting taxonomy generalizes to an unseen benchmark domain.

  • Independent operator discovery: Perform clustering independently for different model families or datasets and quantify the agreement between the resulting partitions.

Although the paper includes cross-dataset correctness prediction experiments, this protocol pools multiple datasets during training and uses problem-level cross-validation. It is therefore different from evaluating whether the operator taxonomy itself can be independently recovered or transferred to entirely held-out domains.

Without such experiments, the claim that the seven operators represent a shared and generalizable structure across LLMs and domains remains insufficiently supported.

W3. Insufficient consideration of model scale, architecture, and training methodology

According to Appendix A, the study includes models with substantially different parameter counts, ranging from approximately 30B to 671B among those with disclosed sizes.

However, the paper does not systematically investigate how model scale affects the discovery, distribution, or semantic consistency of reasoning operators.

In addition to parameter count, the evaluated models differ in architecture (Dense vs. MoE), model family, distillation history, and post-training methodology. Since these factors vary simultaneously, it is difficult to determine which factors are responsible for the observed differences in operator distributions.

For instance, the occurrence of Backtracking in both smaller and larger models does not necessarily imply that the underlying reasoning behavior is equivalent. The same lexical expression may correspond to different levels of reasoning complexity or different forms of error correction.

This distinction is particularly important if the authors intend to characterize the discovered operators as common reasoning structures across models of different scales and capabilities.

The OLMo experiments in Section 5.1 provide useful evidence that different post-training recipes can influence operator distributions while sharing a common base model. However, these experiments do not directly address the effects of model scale.

I recognize that analyzing scaling behavior may not be the central objective of this work. Nevertheless, given the paper's emphasis on the generality of the discovered operators across diverse LLMs, a stratified analysis by model size, along with a discussion of potential confounding factors, would strengthen the claims.

W4. Clustering stability and downstream predictive performance do not sufficiently establish semantic validity

The sensitivity analyses in Appendix Q raise additional questions about the stability and uniqueness of the discovered operator taxonomy.

When alternative embedding models are used, the adjusted Rand index (ARI) relative to the reference clustering decreases substantially, reaching 0.418 for MiniLM and 0.350 for BGE. Agglomerative clustering produces an ARI of only 0.191.

Despite these differences in cluster assignments, some alternative configurations achieve similar downstream correctness prediction performance. For example, MiniLM achieves an operator-only WP-AUC of 0.6467, compared with 0.6479 for the reference configuration.

This suggests that the predictive utility of the representation may not depend strongly on the specific semantic partition into seven operators.

Similarly, although K=7 is selected based on agreement with an LLM judge, Appendix Q reports slightly higher operator-only correctness prediction scores for K=8 and K=9.

I acknowledge that the authors select K based on interpretability rather than downstream prediction performance. However, this criterion does not establish that exactly seven distinct reasoning functions exist.

Moreover, the reported macro-AUC of 0.987 for model identification is achieved using both operator-based structural features and TF-IDF features extracted from anchor text. Consequently, this result should not be interpreted as direct evidence of the semantic validity of the operator taxonomy.

A comparison against alternative representations, such as randomly assigned pivot clusters, frequency-based partitions, raw lexical pivot features, or text-only baselines, would help clarify the extent to which semantic clustering itself contributes to downstream performance.

Overall, the current experiments demonstrate that the proposed representation is useful for prediction, but do not fully establish that its effectiveness arises from discovering a meaningful and stable taxonomy of reasoning operators.

Questions for authors

Q1. Semantic validity of the discovered operators

The proposed clustering relies exclusively on sentence-initial three-token pivots. Have the authors quantitatively investigated cases where identical pivots correspond to different reasoning functions depending on context, or where different pivots express the same reasoning function? Could the authors evaluate operator assignments against independently annotated, context-aware ground-truth labels rather than measuring agreement with the labels induced by clustering?

Q2. Independent generalization across model families and benchmark domains

Have the authors performed leave-one-model-family-out or leave-one-dataset-out experiments to examine whether the proposed operators can be discovered without access to the target model family or benchmark domain? More importantly, would independent clustering of reasoning traces from different model families or benchmark domains recover similar operator structures?

Q3. Effects of model scale and training methodology

How do operator frequencies, transition patterns, and semantic consistency change as model size increases? Given the differences in architecture, model family, and post-training methodology, can the authors provide an analysis that separates the effects of model scale from these potentially confounding factors?

Q4. Necessity and uniqueness of the semantic clustering

Appendix Q shows that changing the embedding model or clustering algorithm can substantially alter cluster assignments, while downstream performance sometimes remains similar. Could the authors clarify whether the predictive improvements arise specifically from the proposed semantically meaningful operators or from a more general partitioning of recurring lexical patterns? A direct comparison against random, frequency-based, or raw lexical representations would be particularly informative.

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Thank you for your detailed comments

Your review is very thoughtful and detailed, and this feedback is very useful for future iterations of our work. However, we have decided not to submit rebuttals at this time. We sincerely thank you for your time and effort to respond to our paper, and we will use these comments to improve on our future work.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.