- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies whether language models can decide which conclusions continue to participate in subsequent reasoning based on whether intermediate conclusions remain valid after a local reasoning phase ends. The authors propose Reasoning with Scope (RWS): reasoning phases form a hierarchy, and after leaving a phase, a conclusion remains valid only if there exists at least one derivation that depends solely on premises still available in outer scopes. Selective continuation requires the model to stop using conclusions that have lost support while retaining those that still hold.
The paper tests this behavior with controlled rule-based problems, interventions on real reasoning traces, and representation comparisons. Controlled experiments show that after a temporary assumption exits scope, answers derived from it are still preferred over controls; explicitly stating that the assumption has been set aside only weakens this effect. Models react more strongly to whether a conclusion appears inside a phase that has ended than to whether its support has actually disappeared. Curly braces barely change outcomes, whereas writing the same dependencies in C or JavaScript makes models noticeably more sensitive to remaining support. The authors suggest training models with dependency tracking and verifiable representations but do not implement or evaluate such methods.
Critical strengths
Controlled items with known support relations compare different treatments after a local phase ends. The paper separately examines temporary assumptions being explicitly negated, assumptions becoming unavailable after scope exit, the position at which conclusions appear, and whether remaining support persists. Results show that after scope exit, conclusions that have lost support still influence later preferences, and that models react more strongly to where a conclusion appears than to whether its remaining support is intact.
Critical weaknesses
-
Natural-reasoning evidence does not operationalize the paper’s own scope definition. Direction-change statistics on AIME, GPQA, SuperGPQA, and LiveCodeBench measure route switching. Returning to a line of thought after leaving it does not change whether that line or its conclusions are correct; appendix AIME examples also show that returning to a suspected route can still yield the right answer. The local reasoning inserted in Section 3.3 is itself incorrect, so accuracy drops of 4–59 percentage points cannot be attributed solely to “continuing to use conclusions whose support has ended.” The paper discusses long-horizon reasoning and agent memory on this basis, but experiments use short contexts kept in full and do not test whether context compression or memory eviction retains conclusions according to remaining support.
-
Reporting of core results is incomplete, and proposed remedies are not validated. The paper reports only the increase in preference for invalidated conclusions relative to controls, without absolute probabilities or final-answer accuracy, so it is unclear whether this effect changes the model’s final choice. Moreover, improvement directions such as process supervision, dependency tracking, and memory management are not experimentally evaluated.
Questions for authors
-
Can you provide full prompt instances for , , , and , and explain how “derived outside the phase but depending on an in-phase assumption” is realized in text? If the wording of this condition itself suggests the conclusion belongs to an ended phase, position effects will be overestimated.
-
In the direction-change and KV-cache deletion experiments, how many departed lines of thought were still valid at the time of leaving? Can you repeat Tables 2 and 4 on long reasoning with known support relations, rather than only counting route switches?
-
In long-context compression or KV-cache eviction, does deciding which conclusions to retain based on remaining support outperform compression by position, recency, or salience? The current code-representation results cannot answer this question.
3 comments
Response to Reviewer rZkD (2/2) (Absolute outcomes, complete prompts, and support-aware retention (W2, Q1, Q3))
Thank you for requesting the absolute outcomes and full prompt instances. They make the diagnostic directly auditable. The revision reports both levels behind every signed effect, adds all four Table 4 prompts, and validates one concrete implication—support-aware retention—in the controlled setting. We continue to present training-based remedies as future work.
The effects change actual choices, not only probabilities (W2). Table 2 now reports normalized preference for the competing answer:
| Model | Control | Implicit return | Explicit exit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Qwen2.5-14B | 17.5 | 97.9 | 72.3 |
| Qwen2.5-32B | 11.9 | 92.9 | 48.2 |
| R1-Qwen-32B | 36.1 | 98.0 | 66.0 |
| R1-Llama-70B | 39.0 | 88.9 | 59.5 |
| QwQ-32B | 41.0 | 89.1 | 63.0 |
After implicit return, the competing answer is the two-choice argmax on at least 95% of the 600 instances per model. After explicit exit, this remains true on most instances for four of five models. Appendix Table 12 now reports all eight absolute cells underlying Table 4, with no-exit controls, sample counts, and CIs. For a still-supported conclusion, Qwen2.5-32B assigns 99.7% SUPPORTED when recorded outside the stage but only 10.6% when recorded inside; R1-Llama-70B assigns 97.6% and 15.3%.
How the four Table 4 conditions are constructed (Q1). Appendix B now gives complete instances of , , , and . They differ at only two controlled locations:
- Support: rule R8 begins either from base fact
zopi() or temporary assumptionskasa(). - Recorded position:
[Exploration under H1 begins.]appears either before () or after () the queried record L2.
The L2 record is otherwise identical: “by rules R8, R12, R14, hvuni holds.” In , L2 is recorded before the marker, but R8 depends on H1. The record never mentions H1, the assumption, or an ended scope; and have the same record text and position. History records are explicitly defined as past derivations, not new base facts. At the final query H1 is inactive, so the checker labels hvuni unsupported in and supported in . Parsing the prompt text yields zero truth-label disagreements over 1,024 prompts per model.
Most importantly, the paper's 92/83-pp position effect uses only and . Both conclusions remain fact-supported and differ only in marker placement. Therefore wording in cannot create the central position effect. The inside-only support contrasts in submitted Tables 4 and 7 (revised Tables 4 and 5) also avoid and lead to the same conclusion.
Does support-aware retention outperform position, recency, or salience (Q3)? We now test this directly on 660 checked worlds with Qwen2.5-32B:
| Retention policy | Invalid influence left (pp) | Collateral change to supported conclusions (pp; closer to 0 is better) |
|---|---|---|
| No deletion | 47.9 | 0.0 |
| Support-aware | 15.4 | −7.6 |
| Delete entire scope | 13.3 | +27.9 |
| Recency / StreamingLLM | 40.9 | +4.7 |
| Salience / SnapKV | 42.8 | +4.7 |
| Salience / H2O | 29.4 | +17.5 |
Support-aware deletion removes about two thirds of the invalid influence. Whole-scope deletion removes slightly more, but severely damages supported conclusions. Recency and salience preserve more valid content but leave most invalid influence in place. Thus remaining support gives the best selective-retention tradeoff in this controlled setting.
This experiment uses oracle dependencies from the generator and one model. It validates the retention principle, not a learned dependency tracker or a complete compression system. Process supervision and learned tracking remain future work.
Revision. Table 2 now shows absolute preference levels, sample counts, and uncertainty, and the text reports how often those shifts change the selected answer. Appendix Table 12 reports all eight absolute cells underlying Table 4; Appendix B.1 gives the four prompts and checker details. Section 5.2 summarizes the controlled retention result, with full results in Appendix Table 17; the Limitations section narrows training/compression claims to this evidence. Changes are marked rZkD-W2/Q1/Q3.
Follow-up on the revised manuscript
Thank you again for the careful review. As the rebuttal period is approaching its end, we wanted to briefly follow up on the main concerns you raised. We have revised the paper and added new evidence, in addition to clarification:
- Natural traces versus loss of support. We now state clearly that route changes show how often reasoning branches are left and revisited; the causal claim comes from checker-verified experiments where support is known. We also audited 37 natural retractions: 14 retracted propositions were still true. This directly illustrates why retaining conclusions by position alone is insufficient.
- Absolute outcomes and full prompts. Table 2 now shows the underlying probabilities and final choices, not only relative changes. Even after an explicit exit, the competing answer remains the majority choice for four of five models. We also provide complete prompts for all four support/position conditions and verify their labels with an independent checker.
- Longer reasoning and memory retention. We added known-support tests with delayed readout, nested assumptions, and backtracking. We also directly compare support-aware retention with whole-scope deletion, recency, and salience baselines. Support-aware retention removes about two thirds of the invalid influence while avoiding the large damage to valid conclusions caused by deleting the entire scope.
We believe these additions directly address W1–W2 and Q1–Q3, while keeping the broader claims within what the experiments establish. If any concern remains, we would genuinely like to hear it and will do our best to resolve it. If these changes have addressed your concerns, we would appreciate your reconsideration of the paper in light of the revision.
Response to Reviewer rZkD (1/2) (What the natural and long-horizon experiments establish (W1, Q2))
Thank you for separating route changes from changes in logical support. We agree that leaving and later returning to a line of thought does not by itself show that the line became invalid. Our controlled experiments establish the support-based failure; the natural-trace analyses establish that the relevant transitions are common and that completed branches can have directional downstream effects. We revise the paper to make these roles explicit.
Direction changes are prevalence evidence, not the causal test. Appendix A.1 counts how often natural traces leave and revisit reasoning directions. It does not assume that every departed direction is invalid. In a separate annotation of 37 explicit retractions from 944 AIME traces, 22 retracted propositions were false, 14 were true, and one was undetermined. Thus about 38% of what the model set aside was still valid. This is precisely why scope exit must be selective: position alone cannot determine what should be retained.
The causal support/position distinction comes from submitted Tables 2, 4, and 5, where dependencies are fixed by construction and verified by an independent closure checker. This is the evidence for the paper's central claim.
The natural intervention has a directional effect, not a generic error effect. In the submitted Table 3 experiment, the misleading passage is a complete plausible branch leading to a specific wrong conclusion. Across GPQA, SuperGPQA, and LiveCodeBench, the matched control never causes the continuation to adopt that branch's conclusion; after the misleading branch, direct adoption rises to 3–50%. Continuations moving in the branch's direction also increase sharply, while unrelated errors change little. The accuracy drop is therefore carried by the inserted branch rather than by general confusion.
We also added the stricter scope-exit follow-up requested by this concern. Across 43 natural trace points and 16 continuations per condition, we compare matched control, the misleading branch followed by an explicit set-aside sentence, and the same branch without set-aside. The branch conclusion reappears in the consistent order control < explicit exit < no exit. For example, the rates are 9.8/21.0/25.0% for R1-Distill-Qwen-32B on AIME and 34.7/53.5/68.8% for the 14B model on GPQA. Explicit exit helps, but does not remove the branch's influence, matching Table 2.
This leakage can affect the final answer when reasoning time is limited. With a 1,024-token budget on AIME, the final answer equals the completed branch's wrong value in 0.9% after control versus 31.2% after explicit exit for the 32B model, and 1.3% versus 37.1% for the 14B model. We do not claim an unrestricted-accuracy drop for this follow-up.
Known-support tests after longer and more complex reasoning (Q2). We did not retrospectively label the support status of every departed direction in the natural KV analysis; the 37-event audit above is the support-labeled natural subset. The controlled KV intervention is different: it uses Table 2 worlds, where the target conclusion has no valid derivation after exit in all 600 checked worlds. Deleting the completed scope immediately reduces residual influence from 41–84 pp to 0.7–2.8 pp; deleting an equal amount of random cache leaves 34–59 pp. After 32 further tokens, source-only deletion still leaves 26–70 pp, showing that the unsupported conclusion's influence has propagated into later state.
We also extend Table 4 to two assumptions arranged as nested scopes and as sequential branches with backtracking. The same position-over-support failure remains: after backtracking, fact-supported conclusions recorded in the other branch receive only 0.7/11.5%
SUPPORTED, while conclusions supported by the re-entered assumption receive 99.7/95.0%. These experiments cover longer continuations, nesting, and backtracking under known support relations. We do not present them as a full interactive-agent evaluation.Revision. Section 3 and Appendix A now distinguish prevalence, directional natural-trace evidence, and checked causal evidence. We add the explicit-exit natural follow-up, identify the support status of the controlled KV targets, and report the delayed, nested, and backtracking tests. Claims about full agents and unrestricted long-context memory are moved to limitations. Changes are marked
rZkD-W1/Q2.