- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces AnisoCast, which encodes global meteorological fields into latitude-ring tokens and processes them through latent-channel spectral mixing and gated convolutions between neighboring latitudes. These operations are arranged in a weight-shared symmetric composition to directly predict mean fields for weeks 3–4 and weeks 5–6. The reported experiments show improved performance on several variables and lower inference costs among the evaluated models.
Critical strengths
-
The architecture addresses directional differences while maintaining computational efficiency. Latitude-ring representations separate within-ring feature processing from cross-latitude interactions and avoid the quadratic cost of global attention, providing a practical design for direct S2S forecasting.
-
The paper compares several model families and evaluates multiple variables, latitude bands, and pressure levels. Spatial error maps, component ablations, and efficiency measurements provide supporting evidence for the overall approach.
Critical weaknesses
-
AnisoCast uses latitude-ring tokenization similar to CirT, which the authors acknowledge as an inspiration. I think the paper would benefit from a more direct comparison explaining what AnisoCast keeps from CirT, what it changes, and why those changes are needed for the problem studied here. This would make it easier to understand the contribution beyond the shared tokenization scheme. It would also help to connect these differences to the existing ablation results, so I can see which design choices account for the additional performance gains and how much each contributes. The paper already includes relevant experiments, but the link between the motivation for these changes and the evidence supporting them could be clearer.
-
The FFT in the Zonal Operator acts on learned channels with no inherent longitude ordering, so its connection to physical zonal waves is unclear. Likewise, the linear Strang-splitting analysis does not establish that symmetric ordering reduces long-horizon errors in the actual network. Testing a non-palindromic ordering with the same operator counts and shared weights would help assess this specific claim. Without such evidence, these interpretations remain plausible explanations rather than demonstrated mechanisms.
Questions for authors
-
What are the main differences between AnisoCast and CirT beyond the shared latitude-ring tokenization, and which existing ablation results support the need for these changes?
-
What evidence connects the FFT over learned latent channels to physical zonal waves and longitudinal periodicity?
-
Have you compared symmetric ordering with a non-palindromic ordering using the same operator counts and weight-sharing scheme to isolate its effect on long-horizon errors?
Thanks for the response. My concerns have been adequately addressed. After reading the other reviewers's comments, I support its acceptance and will keep my original score.