- Rating
- 2(−1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes AtmosWeave, a graph-based framework for global and regional weather forecasting. The global model introduces Scale-Decoupled Directional Mesh Propagation (SD-DMP) to improve multiscale and directional message passing, and Geography- and State-Aware Grouped Linear Attention (GS-GLA) to capture long-range interactions efficiently. For regional forecasting, the authors further propose CrossWarp, which adaptively transfers features from a frozen global model to a high-resolution regional model.
Experiments on ERA5 demonstrate competitive global forecasting performance and consistent improvements in regional forecasting. Ablation studies also show the effectiveness of the proposed components.
Critical strengths
1.Well-motivated architectural design. The paper identifies meaningful limitations of graph-based weather forecasting, including multiscale message aggregation and long-range information exchange. The proposed SD-DMP and GS-GLA provide reasonable solutions to these challenges.
2.Effective global-to-regional coupling. CrossWarp introduces an interesting approach to transferring global atmospheric information into regional forecasting. The results in Table 3 show clear improvements over both regional-only forecasting and fixed geographic alignment.
3.Competitive forecasting performance. The experiments cover global and regional forecasting across multiple lead times. AtmosWeave achieves competitive global results and consistently strong regional forecasting performance.
Critical weaknesses
- The individual contributions of scale decoupling and directional modeling are not sufficiently validated.
SD-DMP introduces two distinct mechanisms: scale-decoupled message aggregation and directional modeling using graph Laplacian eigenvectors. However, Table 3 only evaluates the removal of the entire module.
Although the results demonstrate the overall effectiveness of SD-DMP, they do not establish whether both mechanisms are necessary. In particular, it remains unclear whether spectral directional features provide advantages over simpler geometric directional encodings.
It could be useful separately ablating scale decoupling and directional modeling, and comparing the proposed spectral representation with conventional geometric direction encodings.
- The necessity of geography- and state-aware grouping remains unclear.
GS-GLA uses both geographic coordinates and atmospheric states to construct source groups and target routing weights. However, the current ablation only compares the full model with a variant without grouping.
According to Table 3, removing the grouping mechanism increases RMSE from 0.2654 to 0.2721, while ACC decreases only slightly from 0.8875 to 0.8868. This suggests that grouping provides some improvement, but the individual contributions of geographic and state information remain unclear.
- CrossWarp lacks sufficient ablations to justify its multi-stage coupling design.
CrossWarp combines adaptive feature warping at the encoder, orthogonal-component coupling in the processor, and feature correction at the decoder. While Table 3 demonstrates that adaptive coupling outperforms fixed geographic alignment, it does not establish the necessity of each coupling stage.
In particular, it is unclear whether orthogonal projection provides advantages over direct residual feature fusion, or whether independently recomputing feature correspondence at the decoder is necessary.
Minor:
1.How is global context generated during autoregressive regional forecasting? Appendix A.2 describes the pairing of regional inputs with global atmospheric context, while Section 4.4 uses features extracted from a frozen global forecasting model.
However, it is not entirely clear how global context is generated and updated during multi-step regional forecasting. Specifically, does the regional model use recursively predicted global states at each forecast step, or global features derived from ERA5 fields at the corresponding future times?
2.The paper could benefit from further language polishing and structural reorganization to improve its clarity and readability. In particular, the two research objectives could be more clearly distinguished. The current presentation makes it somewhat difficult to follow the overall methodological framework and the relationship between its components.
Questions for authors
Please see weaknesses