- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes ScaleCast, a regional weather forecasting framework that improves prediction accuracy through global-regional alignment and learnable positional projections. The framework integrates large-scale atmospheric information from pretrained global weather forecasting models with fine-scale regional dynamics. Its flexible design allows different global forecasting models to serve as drivers, with experiments demonstrating the effectiveness of different global-regional configurations. The authors further evaluate ScaleCast against numerical and data-driven forecasting baselines, as well as station observations from HadISD, demonstrating its competitive performance in regional weather prediction.
Critical strengths
- The key strengths of this paper is its extensive evaluation across different global forecasting models and validation datasets. By demonstrating consistent improvements with multiple global drivers and evaluating predictions against both gridded reference data and station observations, the authors provide evidence of the framework's flexibility and practical applicability.
Critical weaknesses
-
Insufficient analysis of autoregressive forecasting behavior. Although the model supports autoregressive forecasting up to 72 hours, the main quantitative evaluation focuses on forecasts up to 30 hours. Furthermore, the relatively stable error trajectories are not sufficiently explained, particularly regarding the respective contributions of regional autoregressive dynamics and continuously updated global forecast guidance. This makes it difficult to assess whether the reported improvements primarily reflect learned regional dynamics or reliance on the global forecasts.
-
Insufficient differentiation from closely related work. The proposed global-regional alignment framework shares substantial conceptual similarities with recent global-regional coupling approaches, particularly ScaleMixer (Chen et al., 2026). Without a clearer methodological comparison, it is difficult to assess the novelty and distinct contribution of the proposed alignment mechanism.
Questions for authors
-
Autoregressive forecasting and error accumulation Despite its autoregressive design, ScaleCast shows relatively stable errors over increasing lead times. Could the authors clarify whether this stability primarily results from the model architecture or the continuous guidance from global forecasts? Since new global predictions are provided at each step, it is unclear to what extent the model independently learns regional atmospheric dynamics. A quantitative evaluation over the full 72-hour horizon would also strengthen this claim.
-
Evaluation of locally varying weather variables High-resolution regional forecasting is particularly important for variables strongly influenced by local conditions, such as wind and precipitation. However, these variables are not included in the reported evaluation. Is this due to data availability or model limitations? Can ScaleCast effectively predict these variables?
-
Why is Graph-EFM evaluated using a four-member ensemble mean, while StormCast-Reg is evaluated with only a single member, potentially limiting the benefits of its generative approach? Was the diffusion component included in StormCast-Reg?
-
What criteria are used to spatially crop the global forecast fields to the regional domain?
-
Could the authors clarify the methodological differences between ScaleCast and ScaleMixer, particularly regarding their global-regional alignment mechanisms?
5 comments
Response for Reviewer Vm6f (2/2)
Q4. Coarse-Input Coverage and the Larger-Crop Comparison.
We have included comparative experiments regarding this crop in Figure 17 of Appendix C3.2; here, we provide further explanation and additional comparisons.
Table R4a. Coarse-grid geographic coverage.
| Global crop | Latitude (degrees N) | Longitude (degrees E) |
|---|---|---|
| 128 x 128 | 33.50 to 65.25 | -8.00 to 23.75 |
| 128 x 208 | 33.50 to 65.25 | -17.75 to 34.00 |
Coverage uses the inclusive rectangle bounded by coarse-grid centers.
Table R4b. Crop sensitivity experiment, RMSE, +3-72 h.
| Forcing | Variable / unit | 128×208 | 128×128 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pangu | T2m / K | 1.341 | 1.370 |
| Pangu | Z500 / dam | 1.220 | 1.412 |
| Pangu | RH2m / pp | 8.982 | 8.861 |
| ERA5 diagnostic | T2m / K | 1.001 | 1.077 |
| ERA5 diagnostic | Z500 / dam | 0.486 | 0.904 |
| ERA5 diagnostic | RH2m / pp | 7.465 | 7.598 |
In this table, the larger-crop model reduces Pangu-conditioned T2m RMSE from 1.370 to 1.341 K and Z500 from 1.412 to 1.220 dam, while RH2m increases by 0.121 percentage points.
Dear Reviewer Vm6f,
As the discussion period ends tomorrow, we would appreciate it if you could take a look at our additional experiments and analyses. Please let us know whether these additional details and explanations have addressed your questions.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Best regards,
The Authors
Response for Reviewer Vm6f (1/2)
We thank the reviewer for the constructive comments and suggestions. We have extended the evaluation to 72 hours and added wind, ensemble-size, and global-input coverage comparisons. We will incorporate these results into the revised manuscript, clarify the autoregressive forecasting and baseline configurations, and expand the discussion of ScaleMixer.
W1 & Q1. Regional State Evolution under Continued Global Guidance from 3.
Thank you for this helpful suggestion. We have extended the quantitative evaluation to +72 h. The table below reports the mean RMSE across the 14 three-hour leads from +33 to +72 h. Publicly available CERRA forecasts extend to +30 h, so CERRA NWP results are unavailable for this interval.
Table R1. Mean RMSE over +33–72 h. Lower is better.
The model rolls out stably through +72 h with regional autoregressive updates and global forecast guidance from the same initialization cycle.
W2 & Q5. Relationship to ScaleMixer.
ScaleMixer is closely related and will be discussed in the revised paper. It uses internal global-model tokens and bidirectional global–regional interaction, including adaptive key-position sampling and two-stage cross-attention. ScaleCast consumes external forecast fields and updates the regional state, supporting the evaluated neural and numerical forecast products.
Table R2. Interface and coupling comparison with ScaleMixer.
The advantage of our method is that it can be integrated into various models. We will add the related-work discussion.
Q2. Wind and Precipitation Outputs.
Thank you for this suggestion. We have extended wind speed on HRRR under actual GraphCast forecast conditioning.
Table R2. Mean 10-m wind RMSE (m/s) over +3–72 h. Lower is better.
Precipitation is available in CERRA as a forecast accumulation, while the CERRA analysis fields do not include precipitation. So, we are unable to conduct a precipitation evaluation.
Q3. Ensemble Size and the StormCast Diffusion Component.
Thank you for your suggestion. The original StormCast-Reg was used with residual diffusion. We now report both single-member and four-member ensemble-mean results for StormCast and will use the four-member results in Table 1.
StormCast single-member and four-member ensemble-mean RMSE. Lower is better.
The improvements are modest but consistent across all nine variables in both lead ranges. For example, T2m RMSE decreases from 1.004 to 0.989 K over +3–30 h and from 1.472 to 1.449 K over +33–72 h. We will also clarify the StormCast configuration and ensemble protocol.