- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies data augmentation for preoperative-to-intraoperative liver point cloud registration, where paired in vivo data are scarce and ground-truth rigid transformations are generally unavailable. The proposed AID-GenReg framework generates additional intraoperative depth observations from existing clinical pairs. It first reprojects a real intraoperative depth map under a sampled rigid transformation and then completes the missing regions with a diffusion model. The main design is a region-decoupled generation strategy: Geometry Preservation keeps valid reprojected depth unchanged in observable regions, while Anatomy-Guided Completion uses the corresponding preoperative liver model to guide generation in the missing regions through a differentiable geometric energy. The resulting real and synthetic pairs are used for self-supervised registration training. The method is evaluated on the public P2I-LReg in vivo liver dataset using four registration backbones and three training paradigms. AID-GenReg consistently improves downstream registration compared with real-only fine-tuning and with the SIRA-PCR and PointRegGPT data-construction baselines. The paper also includes ablations on reprojection, Geometry Preservation, Anatomy-Guided Completion, synthetic-data ratio, and guidance strength.
Critical strengths
The main strength is that the paper addresses a real limitation of generative data construction for clinical registration rather than treating synthetic target generation as a generic augmentation problem. In this setting, a generated intraoperative surface is only useful if it remains geometrically compatible with the paired patient-specific preoperative model. The separation between preserving measured geometry in observable regions and guiding completion only in missing regions is well motivated for this problem. I also found the downstream evaluation reasonably convincing. The authors do not rely on a single registration architecture: the generated pairs are evaluated with CoFiNet, GeoTransformer, P2P, and Self-P2IR, and the gains are generally consistent across models. The comparisons with SIRA-PCR and PointRegGPT are particularly useful because they test whether the proposed anatomical guidance provides additional value beyond existing simulation- or diffusion-based pair construction. The experiments are further conducted on public in-vivo human liver data rather than only simulation or phantom data.
Critical weaknesses
My main concern is that the central claim of patient-specific anatomical identity preservation is only indirectly validated. The ablation shows that Anatomy-Guided Completion improves downstream registration, but this does not by itself establish that the improvement comes from preserving the identity of the correct patient anatomy. A particularly informative control would be to replace the paired preoperative model with a mismatched model from another patient during guidance. If the proposed mechanism truly captures patient-specific identity rather than providing a generic liver-shape prior, the performance and geometric consistency should deteriorate under mismatched guidance. At present, this distinction is not directly demonstrated. A second concern is that Anatomy-Guided Completion is not fully independent of the downstream registration model. According to the appendix, the anatomical energy uses the Sim-Pretrain version of the downstream registration backbone under evaluation to coarsely align the preoperative model before computing the guidance signal. This means that the synthetic data used to evaluate different registration models may themselves depend on those models. As a result, the cross-backbone experiments do not cleanly establish that a single model-agnostic synthetic dataset improves different registration architectures. Using one fixed coarse aligner to generate the same synthetic pairs for all downstream models would provide a cleaner test.
Questions for authors
Q1: The paper's central claim is patient-specific anatomical identity preservation, but it is supported mainly indirectly through downstream registration performance. Could the authors provide a direct identity-preservation experiment, for example, by comparing guidance from the correctly paired preoperative liver with guidance from a mismatched liver model from another patient? A clear degradation under mismatched guidance would provide much stronger evidence that AGC preserves patient-specific anatomy rather than acting as a generic liver-shape prior.
Q2: Could the authors directly evaluate the geometric quality of the generated synthetic depth maps, rather than only their downstream utility? In particular, it would be helpful to report separate consistency measures for the observable region and the completed missing region, and to compare these quantities with PointRegGPT and SIRA-PCR. This would help verify that the proposed Geometry Preservation and Anatomy-Guided Completion actually improve the intended geometric properties of the generated samples.
Q3: The in vivo test set contains 92 pairs from only five patients. Could the authors report per-patient registration results, together with confidence intervals or a patient-level statistical analysis? This would help determine whether the improvements in Table 1 are consistent across patients or dominated by a small subset of cases.
Q4: Since Anatomy-Guided Completion depends on coarse preoperative-to-intraoperative alignment before computing the anatomical energy, how sensitive is the method to errors in this initial alignment? A controlled experiment with different coarse aligners or deliberately perturbed initial poses would help establish whether AGC remains beneficial when the coarse registration is inaccurate, which seems important for the intended clinical setting.
6 comments
Response to Reviewer oc7w (Part 2)
W2: Decoupling AGC from the Evaluated Registration Backbone
A second concern is that Anatomy-Guided Completion is not fully independent of the downstream registration model. According to the appendix, the anatomical energy uses the Sim-Pretrain version of the downstream registration backbone under evaluation to coarsely align the preoperative model before computing the guidance signal. This means that the synthetic data used to evaluate different registration models may themselves depend on those models. As a result, the cross-backbone experiments do not cleanly establish that a single model-agnostic synthetic dataset improves different registration architectures. Using one fixed coarse aligner to generate the same synthetic pairs for all downstream models would provide a cleaner test.
A: In our default setting, AGC uses the Sim-Pretrain version of the evaluated registration backbone as its coarse aligner. To verify that a single synthetic dataset benefits different registration architectures, we decouple AGC from the evaluated registration backbone by fixing Self-P2IR (Sim-Pretrain) as the coarse aligner and using the same synthetic pairs for all four downstream models. Table A2 reports each registration model’s performance using this same synthetic dataset.
Table A2: Registration performance under Real-FT and RealSyn-FT. Chamfer accuracy is in % and mean Chamfer error in mm.
| Registration Model | Training Paradigm | Acc@8 ↑ | Acc@15 ↑ | Mean Err. ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CoFiNet | Real-FT | 8.70 | 53.26 | 16.07 |
| RealSyn-FT | 8.70 | 64.13 | 14.03 | |
| GeoTransformer | Real-FT | 11.96 | 40.22 | 17.96 |
| RealSyn-FT | 21.74 | 60.87 | 14.83 | |
| P2P | Real-FT | 43.48 | 96.74 | 8.76 |
| RealSyn-FT | 48.91 | 96.74 | 8.55 | |
| Self-P2IR | Real-FT | 45.65 | 96.74 | 8.70 |
| RealSyn-FT | 51.09 | 97.83 | 8.48 |
Compared with Real-FT, all four registration models achieve lower mean error. In particular, CoFiNet and GeoTransformer improve Acc@15 by 10.87 and 20.65 percentage points, respectively. These results demonstrate that a single synthetic dataset generated by AID-GenReg benefits different registration architectures, underscoring its generality as a generative augmentation tool for clinical registration.
Q2: Direct Geometric Evaluation
Could the authors directly evaluate the geometric quality of the generated synthetic depth maps, rather than only their downstream utility? In particular, it would be helpful to report separate consistency measures for the observable region and the completed missing region, and to compare these quantities with PointRegGPT and SIRA-PCR. This would help verify that the proposed Geometry Preservation and Anatomy-Guided Completion actually improve the intended geometric properties of the generated samples.
A: We directly quantify anatomical identity preservation in observable and completed (synthesized) regions using paired preoperative CT surfaces as references. Table A3 compares anatomical consistency in both regions for PointRegGPT, our method and its variant without AGC.
Table A3: Anatomical consistency with paired preoperative CT surfaces under the same coarse alignments, measured by unidirectional Chamfer (UCD) and 95th-percentile unidirectional Hausdorff (UHD95) distances (mm). O/C denote observable/completed (synthesized) regions.
| Method | UCD-O ↓ | UHD95-O ↓ | UCD-C ↓ | UHD95-C ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PointRegGPT | 16.80 | 32.73 | 28.37 | 54.46 |
| Ours w/o AGC | 16.71 | 32.70 | 23.95 | 45.69 |
| Ours | 16.71 | 32.69 | 19.58 | 36.85 |
Observable-region consistency remains comparable. In synthesized regions, our variant without AGC lowers UCD-C/UHD95-C by 4.42/8.77 mm compared with PointRegGPT, and adding AGC yields further reductions of 4.37/8.84 mm. These results demonstrate the effectiveness of GP and AGC in improving anatomical consistency in synthesized regions.
We do not include SIRA-PCR in Table A3 because it adapts CT-rendered point clouds using a GAN and thus has no corresponding division into observable and completed regions. Although its whole-cloud UCD/UHD95 values are low (9.47/18.14 mm), these are obtained using known rendering poses and are not directly comparable to the regional metrics computed under estimated coarse alignments.
Response to Reviewer oc7w (Part 3)
Q3: Patient-Level Registration Results
The in vivo test set contains 92 pairs from only five patients. Could the authors report per-patient registration results, together with confidence intervals or a patient-level statistical analysis? This would help determine whether the improvements in Table 1 are consistent across patients or dominated by a small subset of cases.
A: To examine whether the gains in Table 1 generalize across patients, we report per-patient results for CoFiNet and Self-P2IR, comparing Real-FT with AID-GenReg (Tables A4 and A5). Uncertainty is quantified using 95% confidence intervals (CIs), with two-sided Wilson intervals for Acc@8/Acc@15. For mean error, we use non-parametric percentile bootstrap resampling of each patient's test pairs (2,000 iterations), drawing with replacement and taking the 2.5th and 97.5th percentiles of the resampled means as CI bounds.
Table A4: Per-patient CoFiNet registration results, reported as value [95% CI]. The first row for each patient is the Real-FT baseline. Chamfer accuracy is in % and mean Chamfer error in mm.
| Patient (#Pairs) | Method | Acc@8 ↑ | Acc@15 ↑ | Mean Err. ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 (22) | - | 0.00 [0.00, 14.87] | 31.82 [16.36, 52.68] | 18.69 [16.10, 21.25] |
| Ours | 4.55 [0.81, 21.80] | 68.18 [47.32, 83.64] | 13.92 [12.18, 15.77] | |
| 02 (20) | - | 0.00 [0.00, 16.11] | 35.00 [18.12, 56.71] | 19.57 [16.20, 23.68] |
| Ours | 0.00 [0.00, 16.11] | 45.00 [25.82, 65.79] | 20.32 [15.93, 25.28] | |
| 03 (21) | - | 14.29 [4.98, 34.64] | 57.14 [36.55, 75.53] | 15.73 [12.61, 19.29] |
| Ours | 19.05 [7.67, 40.00] | 85.71 [65.36, 95.02] | 12.46 [10.08, 15.54] | |
| 04 (11) | - | 0.00 [0.00, 25.88] | 63.64 [35.38, 84.83] | 13.45 [10.79, 16.53] |
| Ours | 9.09 [1.62, 37.74] | 54.55 [28.01, 78.73] | 13.04 [10.96, 14.94] | |
| 05 (18) | - | 27.78 [12.50, 50.87] | 88.89 [67.20, 96.90] | 11.01 [9.50, 12.57] |
| Ours | 27.78 [12.50, 50.87] | 100.00 [82.41, 100.00] | 9.79 [8.73, 10.90] |
Table A5: Per-patient Self-P2IR registration results, with notation and units following Table A4.
| Patient (#Pairs) | Method | Acc@8 ↑ | Acc@15 ↑ | Mean Err. ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 (22) | - | 18.18 [7.31, 38.52] | 86.36 [66.67, 95.25] | 10.85 [9.71, 12.07] |
| Ours | 27.27 [13.15, 48.15] | 90.91 [72.19, 97.47] | 10.45 [9.33, 11.60] | |
| 02 (20) | - | 35.00 [18.12, 56.71] | 100.00 [83.89, 100.00] | 9.52 [8.64, 10.53] |
| Ours | 35.00 [18.12, 56.71] | 100.00 [83.89, 100.00] | 9.40 [8.61, 10.26] | |
| 03 (21) | - | 61.90 [40.88, 79.25] | 100.00 [84.54, 100.00] | 7.15 [6.40, 7.96] |
| Ours | 61.90 [40.88, 79.25] | 100.00 [84.54, 100.00] | 7.06 [6.26, 7.83] | |
| 04 (11) | - | 90.91 [62.26, 98.38] | 100.00 [74.12, 100.00] | 6.99 [6.37, 7.72] |
| Ours | 90.91 [62.26, 98.38] | 100.00 [74.12, 100.00] | 6.90 [6.40, 7.47] | |
| 05 (18) | - | 44.44 [24.56, 66.28] | 100.00 [82.41, 100.00] | 7.99 [7.15, 8.84] |
| Ours | 61.11 [38.62, 79.69] | 100.00 [82.41, 100.00] | 7.68 [6.87, 8.58] |
On CoFiNet, AID-GenReg achieves higher Acc@15 and lower mean error in 4/5 patients for each metric, while maintaining or improving Acc@8 in 5/5 patients. On Self-P2IR, it reduces mean error in 5/5 patients and maintains or improves both accuracy metrics for every patient. Together, these findings support generally consistent augmentation benefits across patients with both registration backbones.
Response to Reviewer oc7w (Part 1)
We are grateful for your thorough review and encouraging feedback, and for recognizing our clear presentation, well-motivated region-decoupled design, and convincing downstream evaluation. Below, we address your concerns by directly evaluating patient-specific anatomical identity preservation, demonstrating the generality of our augmentation across registration models, reporting patient-level results, and presenting additional experiments and analyses.
W1 & Q1: About Patient-Specific Anatomical Identity Preservation
A: To directly validate our central claim of patient-specific anatomical identity preservation, we compare AGC guided by correctly paired and mismatched CT models. In the mismatched condition, we align another training patient’s CT to the original intraoperative observation using the same frozen coarse aligner. All other generation and downstream training protocols remain unchanged, and the original patient’s correctly paired CT is retained for both registration pair construction and geometric evaluation.
Table A1: Mismatched versus patient-specific AGC guidance, evaluated by anatomical consistency and CoFiNet registration. Anatomical consistency is measured by unidirectional Chamfer (UCD) and 95th-percentile unidirectional Hausdorff (UHD95) distances from completed (synthesized) regions (C) to the correct CT under the same reference alignments. Accuracy is in % and distances in mm.
As shown in Table A1, mismatched guidance increases UCD-C/UHD95-C by 1.21/2.88 mm compared with patient-specific guidance. It also lowers both Acc@8 and Acc@15 by 7.61 percentage points and raises mean registration error by 0.93 mm. This deterioration in geometric consistency and downstream performance supports the value of correctly paired patient anatomy beyond a generic liver-shape prior.