- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes synthesizing 3D pelvic fracture CTs by combining template-based geometric fracture simulation with mask-conditioned latent diffusion. It constructs displaced bone fragments from healthy anatomy, generates their CT appearance, and blends them into the original scan. Augmenting training with these synthetic samples substantially improves rare-fragment segmentation
Critical strengths
- Using generative model to augment fraction segmentation is well-motivated given the scarily of the fraction data.
- The use of template to generate fracture is interesting and can provide realistic-like images.
Critical weaknesses
- The rigid-transform operation is described, but numerical rotation/translation ranges and severity-dependent sampling distributions are not reported. Their effects on anatomical plausibility and downstream performance remain unclear.
- The appendices provide qualitative examples, but systematic analysis of template diversity, anatomical alignment, fragment overlap, and volume preservation is missing.
- Whole-volume image metrics and downstream segmentation provide useful evidence, but expert assessment and localized evaluation of fracture interfaces are needed to substantiate realism claims.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors specify the rotation/translation ranges and severity-dependent sampling distributions, and assess how these choices affect anatomical plausibility and downstream segmentation?
- Could the authors quantify template diversity and evaluate anatomical alignment, fragment overlap, and volume preservation across the generated samples?
- Could the authors provide expert assessment of fracture realism and fracture-region-specific evaluation?
2 comments
Dear Reviewer r8mn,
As the discussion deadline is approaching, we would like to kindly follow up. We have responded to all of your questions, including the exact rotation/translation ranges, volume preservation and fragment-overlap statistics, template diversity, and anatomical alignment. We would appreciate your feedback on whether our response addresses your concerns, and we would be happy to answer any further questions.
Thank you for your time and constructive review.
We thank the reviewer for the focused and precise technical questions. We address each in full.
Weakness 1 / Question 1: Rotation/translation ranges and severity-dependent sampling distributions are not reported.
We report the exact sampling ranges used by GFSM's rigid cut-and-displace step: rotation angles (α, β, γ) are drawn uniformly from ±10° per axis, and translation (t) uniformly from ±10 voxels per axis (realized ranges across all generated samples: rotation ≈ [−9.7°, 9.8°], translation ≈ [−15.0 mm, 14.1 mm]). Anatomical plausibility is enforced via rejection sampling: candidates are discarded if the displaced fragment touches the volume boundary, if volume retention falls below 98% (realized: 99.5–100.2%), or if fragment overlap exceeds 1% (all accepted samples satisfy this constraint, i.e., no inter-fragment collision was observed).
We also clarify an error in Section 3.4: the original text states that "sampling distributions for (α, β, γ, t) are constrained by injury severity," which is inaccurate. In the current implementation, these parameters are sampled from a single fixed range independent of severity; severity currently determines only which anatomical template is retrieved in Stage 2, not the transform magnitude in Stage 3. We have corrected Section 3.4 and added a limitation statement in Section 5. Extending severity-conditioned sampling to comminuted multi-fragment fractures is left for future work, contingent on annotated comminuted-fracture data.
Weakness 2 / Question 2: Template diversity and anatomical alignment are not quantified.
Regarding template diversity: by construction, GFSM's Fracture Surface Atlas (Stage 1) mines exactly one surface template per real training case; template diversity per category is therefore bounded by the real training-sample counts already reported (Pubic: 33, Denis I: 16, Denis II: 11, Acetabular: 5, Iliac: 5, Denis III: 2). We now state explicitly that every Denis III synthetic sample is generated from only 2 distinct real templates — a direct consequence of the data scarcity that motivates this work, and we list this as a limitation in Section 5.
Regarding anatomical alignment: Stage 2 retrieval selects templates by exact match on anatomical site and fracture type, so the zone label of every generated fracture is inherited from a real case already confirmed to be in that zone. Stage 3's rigid transform displaces the fragment locally (realized translation ≤15 mm), which is small relative to zone extents and insufficient to relocate a fracture into a different anatomical region. We consider zone correctness preserved by construction, supported by the volume retention (99.5–100.2%) and zero inter-fragment collision results above.
Weakness 3 / Question 3: Expert assessment and localized evaluation of fracture interfaces are needed.
We do not currently have access to a clinical collaborator to conduct a blinded expert evaluation within the rebuttal window. As partial substitutes, we provide: (1) the quantitative geometric validity checks reported above (volume retention, fragment overlap); (2) the staged pipeline ablation demonstrating that each compositing step contributes measurably to downstream task performance; and (3) the existing qualitative multi-planar visualizations in Appendix D/F. We agree that a clinician-rated realism study would strengthen the realism claim and will pursue this with a radiology collaborator as follow-up work, which we have added to the limitations section.