- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces an inference-time sampling strategy for pre-trained Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models (DDPMs) that extracts a canonical population template, termed the intrinsic atlas, from a generator trained solely for individual synthesis. Motivated by Grenander's pattern theory, the authors posit that while injected noise during the reverse diffusion process drives individual variation, the learned denoiser isolates the shared population structure. Thus, replacing each stochastic reverse transition with its conditional expectation () causes arbitrary random Gaussian initializations to contract onto a single sharp consensus image (cross-seed ), a phenomenon termed canonical convergence. The authors validate this approach across diverse 3D and 2D medical and non-medical domains (brain MRI, chest X-ray, retinal images, faces, and 3D shapes), demonstrating that the intrinsic atlas achieves top-tier registration accuracy and superior geometric centrality under standardized ANTs registration protocols, naturally extends to covariate-conditioned atlas families (reproducing healthy aging CSF expansion on brain MRI), and diagnoses multi-modal or unaligned populations.
Critical strengths
-
The paper presents a simple, reproducible, and interesting finding. Dropping injected noise from the DDPM reverse transition collapses arbitrary initializations onto a single sharp image (cross-seed SSIM ≥ 0.99, correlation 0.9999) across 3D brain MRI, chest X-ray, faces, and 3D shapes, with no atlas-specific objective. The effect is easy to verify, and the mechanism (Tweedie / posterior-mean iteration) is sound as far as it is stated.
-
The presented atlas is useful and biologically coherent. Under a fixed ANTs protocol it is best or second on Dice and the most central and regular template on three held-out brain cohorts. The age-conditioned family reproduces the accelerating CSF-expansion trend of healthy aging, and a distant-age control shows conditioning carries
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper has some missing baselines that would isolate what is new. There are no same-generator controls (DDIM/PF-ODE from x_T = 0, or the mean of N stochastic samples), no conditional deformable-template baselines (Dalca 2019, Atlas-GAN, AtlasMorph) against the age-conditioned family, and no 2D congealing baselines (GANgealing, Neural Congealing) on CelebA despite Section 2.1 positioning against them. Table 1 reports no variance, and several decisive margins are 0.001–0.004. Without these, it is unclear how much credit belongs to the sampler versus the underlying generator.
-
The 2D Gaussian example does not explain why multi-step iteration yields a sharp mode rather than the blurry voxel mean, and no contraction conditions are given beyond the linear case. The pattern-theory analogy obscures that the method requires pre-aligned, background-normalized populations (the FFHQ "remedy" masks already landmark-aligned faces). Ambiguity about IXI/OASIS-1 train/test overlap (899 fine-tuning scans vs. 123 evaluation subjects; OASIS-TRT-20 inside Mindboggle101) must be resolved.
Questions for authors
- Were the 78 IXI and 45 OASIS-1 evaluation subjects, and the OASIS-TRT-20 subjects in Mindboggle101, strictly excluded from the 899 fine-tuning scans?
- What varies across the "at least 3 repeated runs" in Table 1, and what are the standard deviations?
- What does "per-seed r = +0.88" correlate, and how do the 1–4 pp error bars in Figure 7a reconcile with the "<0.2 pp spread" in the text and the s.e.m./s.d. mismatch?
- For the Khader et al. 3D model, is the iteration run in VQ-GAN latent space? What representation is used for ModelNet shapes, and how is 3D SSIM computed?
- Which statistical test produced the p-values in Section 5?
W1. Missing baselines and variance.
We added all requested baselines except AtlasMorph, which has no public code or models.
The new results give additional support to the previous conclusions in the paper, as our method is still the best or second-best on every dataset when considering these additional experiments. The controlled DDIM experiment shows similar performance on Brain MRI datasets but worse on other datasets.
W2. Why does the method converge?
Sharp template vs. voxel mean, and contraction conditions. The revised Sec. 3 answers both through the deformable-template model. Each image is the template under a random deformation, I(x)=Itemp(x−u(x)), expanded in Eq. 3. When the higher-order terms of Eq. 3 are negligible, the population is Gaussian with center Itemp, and the iteration contracts every initialization to this center. This is the contraction condition: the population shares one template and the higher-order terms of Eq. 3 are negligible.
Pre-alignment. We agree these are conditions of the method, and the revised Sec. 3 now states them through pattern theory rather than leaving them implicit. The deformable-template model (Eq. 3) assumes that every member is a deformation of one shared template. Pre-alignment keeps the deformations within the regime where the iteration provably converges to the template, and background normalization removes content that no deformation of the template can produce. The FFHQ remedy illustrates the second condition, not the first: the faces are already landmark-aligned, and cropping to the face oval removes the unshared background, hair and clothing, so the population satisfies Eq. 3 and our method outputs a sharp template (Sec. 6).
Overlap. All evaluation subjects in the revision are excluded from training: Table 1's cohorts are disjoint from the fine-tuning scans (Mindboggle101 excludes OASIS-TRT-20), and Sec. 5 uses models trained without its evaluation subjects.
Questions.
Q1. Yes. For the age-utility experiment, we excluded the 126 evaluation subjects before fine-tuning and trained on the remaining 773 of 899 scans. Mindboggle101 is evaluated without its OASIS-TRT-20 subjects. We have updated the paper accordingly.
Q2. The repeated runs differ in ANTs' stochastic sampling during registration, with the template and subjects fixed.
Q3. We thank the reviewer for the careful reading. We have updated the paper accordingly. r is the Pearson correlation between atlas age and CSF fraction, computed per seed and averaged over 5 seeds. The "0.2 pp" in the text was an error from an earlier model; the seed s.d. of the model in Fig. 7a is 1.2–6.9 pp. The band is ±1 s.e.m., which the caption now states, and the red bars are the ±1 s.d. of the reference cohort.
Q4. The pretrained 3D model is 3D MedDiffusion (Wang et al., 2024); we corrected the citation. Yes, the iteration runs in the 8-channel latent space of the 4× VQ autoencoder, and the endpoint is decoded through the frozen decoder. ModelNet shapes are 323 soft occupancy grids built from 8,192 surface points, modeled by a voxel-space DDPM. 3D SSIM is computed with the scikit-image implementation (73 window) on the decoded volumes within the bounding box of the foreground. We included these computation details in Section B.2.
Q5. We use Wilcoxon signed-rank tests on per-subject values, pairing each subject's registrations to the two atlases compared. Sec. 5 now names the test.