- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes CAST, a reinforcement learning framework that uses classical game solvers as turn-level teachers for LLM agents. CAST converts per-action changes in a solver’s state value (cost-to-go) into a shifted and shaped solver advantage that augments outcome-only RLVR signals, yielding dense, turn-level credit. The authors provide a theoretical interpretation showing that, under a soft-optimality assumption, maximizing solver advantage is equivalent to on-policy distillation from the solver without needing logits, and empirically demonstrate consistent gains across Sokoban, Minesweeper, and Rush Hour, with zero-shot transfer improvements on ALFWorld and WebShop.
Critical strengths
Technical novelty
- The logit-free on-policy distillation interpretation is insightful: it connects solver-derived scalar signals to OPD via soft-optimal policies, bridging classic planning/solving and modern LLM distillation.
Experimental rigor and validation
- Comprehensive in-domain and unseen-difficulty evaluations on three distinct games, with consistent improvements over multiple trained RLVR baselines. Zero-shot transfer results on ALFWorld and WebShop suggest the learned turn-level competencies generalize beyond the training domains.
Clarity of presentation
- The method and signal construction are explained clearly with intuitive grounding in cost-to-go and shortest-path semantics. The theoretical statement (Theorem 2.1) is well-motivated and the assumptions are listed explicitly.
Critical weaknesses
Limited significance of the problem setting
- The central motivation of the paper is long-horizon credit assignment under sparse terminal rewards. However, in the main experimental settings, CAST assumes access to a task-specific solver that can provide a reliable state value or cost-to-go estimate for arbitrary learner-visited states. Once such intermediate values are available, much of the difficult part of credit assignment---namely, determining which intermediate decisions are beneficial or harmful---has already been resolved by the solver. In this sense, CAST seems to primarily address how to integrate an existing value oracle into LLM RLVR, rather than how to solve credit assignment from sparse outcome supervision itself. Many realistic domains lack such oracles, and the paper’s learned-value ablation is limited to a single game that already can be solved by traditional DQN.
Technical limitations or concerns
-
In the practical method, the solver value is defined as where is the shortest-path cost-to-go. Therefore, the solver advantage used by CAST is constructed from a hard shortest-path value. However, in Appendix C.5, the derivation of relies on Assumption C.1, under which i.e., a soft log-sum-exp value. In general, this soft value is not identical to the hard shortest-path value used in the actual implementation. The wording in the main text that CAST is "exactly" or "mathematically equivalent" to on-policy distillation appears too strong.
-
For Minesweeper (partial observability), it is unclear whether the solver uses privileged access to the ground-truth board to compute N(s) or acts on information states only.
Experimental gaps or methodological issues
- The paper motivates CAST partly by arguing that solver-trajectory SFT only covers expert-visited states, whereas CAST can provide supervision on student-visited states. This is a reasonable motivation, but the experiments do not include a solver-trajectory SFT baseline.
Missing related work or comparisons
- The connection to potential-based reward shaping (Ng et al., 1999) is highly relevant: the per-step credit is a canonical potential difference. This connection should be made explicit and contrasted to clarify what is new.
Questions for authors
Scope of the credit-assignment claim.
CAST assumes a solver that provides reliable intermediate-state values. Could the authors clarify what part of credit assignment remains to be solved once such an oracle is available, and what application regime is intended when no reliable value oracle exists?
Hard value versus soft-value theory.
The implementation uses the hard cost-to-go value , while the distillation derivation assumes a soft log-sum-exp value. Is the claimed equivalence to on-policy distillation exact, approximate under the small-signal assumption, or only valid up to a policy-gradient baseline argument?
Minesweeper under partial observability.
Does the Minesweeper teacher value depend only on the observable information state, or also on the fixed latent mine layout? If two latent boards induce the same information state, is the solver cost necessarily identical?
Direct solver-supervision baseline.
Do the authors have results against solver-trajectory SFT or a DAgger/AggreVaTe-style baseline using the same solver information? This would help isolate the benefit of CAST itself from the benefit of access to a strong oracle.
Relation to potential-based reward shaping.
How does CAST differ from using as a standard potential-based shaped reward? A direct comparison using the same solver signal would materially clarify the method's novelty.
6 comments
Rebuttal by Authors (2/2)
W3 / Q4. Solver-trajectory SFT and DAgger-style supervision.
We added solver-trajectory behavior cloning (BC) and learner-state DAgger, both starting from Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507 and using the same Sokoban solver. BC learns from solver trajectories, while DAgger learns solver-labelled actions at learner-visited states. We evaluate action-only and templated-rationale targets, with one training run per method and target style.
The budget counts supervised action targets cumulatively across training, with a common target referenced to CAST's rollout environment-action count. We evaluate final training checkpoints.
BC and DAgger use the same Sokoban test tiers and Avg@4 protocol. DAPO and CAST scores retain the main experiment's run aggregation. On Unseen-Difficulty, the results are:
| Method | Target format | Avg@4 (%) |
|---|---|---|
| BC | Action only | 22.1 |
| BC | Templated rationale + action | 17.3 |
| DAgger | Action only | 19.5 |
| DAgger | Templated rationale + action | 25.3 |
| DAPO | Outcome reward | 31.3 |
| CAST | Outcome + solver advantage | 34.8 |
CAST reaches 34.8% on Unseen-Difficulty, 9.5 percentage points above the strongest BC/DAgger variant. BC and DAgger can achieve higher ID performance than CAST, but this advantage does not extend to harder instances. Directly learning solver action labels yields limited generalization, whereas solver-guided turn-level credit generalizes better to unseen difficulty. The updated comparison is included in Table 10, Appendix E.1, with the budget definition.
Our best AggreVaTe result achieves 49.3% on Sokoban ID and 18.4% on Unseen-Difficulty, below CAST's reported scores on both settings.
W4 / Q5. Comparison with potential-based reward shaping.
On finite-cost transitions, CAST's cost difference is also a standard PBRS potential difference [1]. The distinction is how this signal enters the update.
With , complete rollouts from the same initial state within a prompt group, and zero potential at every terminal state, the accumulated PBRS shaping reward is a shared constant removed by group centering. Thus, aggregating PBRS rewards before GRPO group normalization does not change the trajectory advantages.
CAST instead adds the transformed and normalized immediate solver signal directly to turn-level advantages, allowing actions within the same trajectory to receive different credit.
References
[1] Policy Invariance under Reward Transformations: Theory and Application to Reward Shaping
Thank you for the detailed rebuttal and additional experiments. The responses have improved my assessment of the paper, particularly through the new experimental comparisons.
1. Scope and motivation. The clarification that CAST aims to transfer solver-derived feedback into general-purpose LLM training, rather than solving credit assignment from sparse rewards alone, is helpful. The DQN-based teacher experiment also supports the feasibility of using learned evaluators. However, the method still relies on reliable intermediate-state evaluations, which limits its applicability in domains without such evaluators.
2. Theoretical interpretation. The Gibbs distribution constructed from hard solver advantages provides a reasonable explanation of their implicit action preferences. However, this does not fully establish exact equivalence between the implemented CAST update and standard on-policy distillation, given the nonlinear transformation, batch normalization, and approximation assumptions. The theoretical claims should be qualified accordingly.
3. Minesweeper partial observability. The clarification that the teacher selects actions using observable information is useful. However, its completion cost is evaluated on the fixed latent board, meaning that the supervision can depend on hidden information even when the observable state is identical. This privileged supervision should be explicitly acknowledged as a limitation.
4. Solver imitation baselines. The additional BC and DAgger experiments substantially strengthen the paper. CAST achieves 34.8% on unseen difficulty, outperforming the strongest imitation baseline (25.3%). Although DAgger performs better in-domain, these results provide meaningful evidence that solver-guided turn-level RL generalizes better to unseen difficulty. This addresses one of my major experimental concerns.
5. Potential-based reward shaping. The distinction between trajectory-level reward shaping and directly incorporating solver signals into turn-level advantages is reasonable and clarifies the methodological contribution. Nevertheless, the relationship to potential-based advantage estimation deserves further discussion.
Overall assessment. The rebuttal addresses several important concerns, particularly the missing solver-imitation comparisons. My remaining reservations concern the theoretical equivalence claims and privileged supervision in Minesweeper, which have not been fully resolved.
Given these remaining concerns, I will maintain my original rating of 2 (Weak Reject).
Rebuttal by Authors (1/2)
Our goal is to use solver signals to train a general-purpose LLM for reliable interaction. CAST turns value changes into credit for the learner's own sampled turns while retaining the terminal task objective. Solving credit assignment from sparse outcome supervision alone is not our contribution.
Games provide scalable instances, controllable difficulty, and reliable teacher signals for learning planning and feedback-driven decisions. Prior work also supports game-based transfer [1,2]. Our game-trained policies generalize zero-shot to ALFWorld and WebShop (Tables 2 and 13), where action selection does not require the source-game teacher.
Figure 4 already replaces the exact solver with a DQN value-network teacher, demonstrating that CAST's scalar interface accommodates learned evaluators. In other domains, an LLM teacher could serve as the solver, scoring task progress before and after learner actions. Differences between these scores would provide turn-level credit, enabling distillation without teacher logits. AgentPRM and VinePPO provide related approaches to process evaluation [3,4]. Such applications require an LLM teacher that can reliably assess task progress.
References
[1] LMGame-Bench: How Good are LLMs at Playing Games?
[2] SPIRAL: Self-Play on Zero-Sum Games Incentivizes Reasoning via Multi-Agent Multi-Turn Reinforcement Learning
[3] AgentPRM: Process Reward Models for LLM Agents via Step-Wise Promise and Progress
[4] VinePPO: Refining Credit Assignment in RL Training of LLMs
For finite hard advantages, define qτ(a∣s)=exp(Ahard(s,a)/τ)/Zτ(s). Then
=\tau\log q_\tau(a\mid s)+\tau\log Z_\tau(s).$$ The second term depends only on the state and cancels as a baseline in the population expected policy gradient with fixed scores, state distribution, and a given normalization constant. Therefore, linear hard advantages have a local log-preference equivalence. This preserves the interpretation of conveying action preferences without teacher logits, without requiring hard values to be equated with soft values. > **W2 / Q3. Minesweeper teacher under partial observability.** The Minesweeper teacher selects actions from revealed counts using constraint reasoning and mine probabilities. It derives its own flags rather than treating learner flags as facts. Its completion cost $K(s)$ counts the teacher's reveal actions plus one unflagging action for each unrevealed safe cell flagged by the learner; $K(s)=+\infty$ when the teacher cannot clear the board in its simulated continuation, for example when a probabilistic reveal hits a mine. **$K(s)$ is a teacher-rollout completion cost on the fixed latent board, not an information-state value averaged over compatible hidden layouts; identical observations can therefore yield different costs.** The environment maps infinite-cost boundaries to the finite raw scores below. The trainer then applies asinh compression and batch RMS normalization to these scores: | Transition | Raw solver score | | --- | --- | | Finite $\rightarrow$ finite | $K(s_t)-K(s_{t+1})$ | | Finite $\rightarrow$ infinite | $-K(s_t)$ | | Infinite $\rightarrow$ finite, nonterminal | $+K(s_{t+1})$ | | Infinite $\rightarrow$ infinite | $0$ | | Invalid action | $0$ | An undefined initial cost or an already-terminal state also receives zero. This produces finite scores without evaluating $\infty-\infty$. Finite-to-finite transitions account for over 80%, finite-to-infinite transitions for roughly 5%, infinite-to-finite transitions for less than 1%, and infinite-to-infinite transitions for roughly 10%.