- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a process-level credit allocation strategy named "Cliff", aiming to improve the verifiable reward reinforcement learning of large language models. The core insight of this method is that once the reasoning process makes an initial error, the information provided by subsequent reasoning evaluations is extremely limited. Based on this, Cliff uses the readily available teacher model to identify the first erroneous step in the student's reasoning trajectory, clearly dividing the trajectory into the correct prefix and the erroneous suffix, and then allocating word-level advantage values accordingly.
Critical strengths
-
The paper ingeniously draws on the concept of substantive implication in formal logic, pointing out that deriving under incorrect premises lacks practical significance. Thus, it simplifies the complex process of reward modeling into finding the first erroneous step, significantly reducing the costs of manual annotation and additional modeling.
-
This strategy does not require training an additional process reward model, nor does it mandate that the teacher model and the student model have the same reasoning mode or tokenizer. It only relies on the teacher model to locate the first error, demonstrating excellent cross-model and cross-task transfer capabilities.
Critical weaknesses
-
Although the paper indicates that making judgments is easier than solving problems from scratch, the accuracy of the teacher model still directly determines the quality of the training signals. If the teacher model performs poorly in highly complex reasoning tasks, it is prone to introducing noise and even transmitting incorrect supervision signals.
-
The paper divides the reasoning process by sentences, but the error boundaries in natural language reasoning are often rather vague. Different annotators or models may have differences in determining the first substantive error, and this subjectivity may lead to an imprecise allocation of advantage values.
-
The paper mentions that for extremely long trajectories, they are directly regarded as completely incorrect and assigned negative advantage values. This hard-cutting strategy is effective in preventing length cracking, but it may mistakenly harm those high-quality trajectories whose reasoning directions are correct but were not completed due to length limitations, resulting in a certain degree of waste of effective signals.
Questions for authors
Lack of discussion of other fine-grained RLVR works:
-
Unlocking Token Rewards via Training-Free Reward Attribution
-
Teacher-Guided Token Reward with Adaptive Calibration for Robust Policy Optimization in LLM Reasoning
I will raise my score if my concerns were well-addressed.
Author Response
We're very grateful for your constructive comments, and are glad for your acknowledgement of our paper’s clear motivation and lightweighted design. Below are responses to your suggestions and concerns.
W1: What happens if the teacher model performs poorly on highly complex reasoning tasks?
Cliff requires a teacher with at least some reasoning capability, but it doesn’t need to solve every problem or as strong as GPT-5.6. As shown in Table 2, moderately capable teachers, such as Qwen3-43B and Gemma-3 27B, also yield strong performance.
When the teacher struggles with a problem, the verification filter serves as a safeguard: Cliff applies teacher-provided process signals only to problems for which the teacher produces a verified correct answer. Otherwise, training falls back to the standard GRPO objective for those problems. Thus, a weaker teacher primarily reduces the coverage of Cliff supervision, but it won’t cause the student to learn from unreliable signals, and it won’t be worse than vanilla GRPO.
W2: Error boundaries in natural-language reasoning are often vague and cannot easily be divided by sentence.
We agree that errors in natural-language reasoning do not always align neatly with sentence boundaries. Sentence-level localization is a practical approximation that allows Cliff to translate the teacher's assessment into actionable training signals. Token-level localization would require an excessively fine-grained judgment, whereas paragraph-level localization could group substantial correct reasoning together with an error.
To reduce ambiguity, we design the judging prompt to focus on identifiable factual or logical errors, rather than stylistic preferences or speculative concerns. In particular, the teacher is instructed not to treat an exploratory attempt that is subsequently corrected as the first reasoning error. These criteria aim to make boundary identification more consistent and objective, while acknowledging that some ambiguity is inherent in natural-language reasoning.
W3: Why do the authors treat overlength responses as completely wrong?
This design serves two purposes.
First, it helps prevent uncontrolled growth in response length. A lengthy but inefficient rollout may remain locally correct until it reaches the generation limit, without ever producing a final answer. If its entire observed prefix were credited as correct, it could receive the same advantage as a completed correct rollout, creating an incentive to prolong reasoning without completing the task. Treating such truncated rollouts as unsuccessful avoids this incentive; Appendix D also analyzes the role of this treatment in controlling response length through the mathematical formulation.
Second, it aligns the training objective with successful reasoning under a finite resource budget. At inference time, a model must produce an answer within a bounded generation budget, so locally valid reasoning alone is insufficient if the response does not reach a solution before that budget is exhausted. Accordingly, treating overlength responses as unsuccessful reflects task completion under the available budget, rather than asserting that every intermediate reasoning step is logically incorrect. This treatment is also consistent with the GRPO baseline used in our experiments.
Q1: More related work should be discussed.
Thank you for highlighting these related papers.
[1] derives token-level rewards through gradient-based attribution of an existing reward model's scores, while [2] calibrates teacher–student token log-probability differences using supervision signals at different levels. Cliff differs from these methods in two key respects:
We will add these studies to the related-work section and clarify these distinctions in the revised manuscript.
We value your insightful comments and suggestions, which have significantly contributed to the improvement of our paper. We will update the paper, incorporating revisions and additional results based on the questions you raised. If you find that your concerns have been resolved, we would be very grateful if you could reconsider the review score.