acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Beyond Latent Similarity: Credit Assignment with State Transitions for LLM Agents

Abstract

In agentic RL, feedback based on final episode outcomes does not directly distinguish the contributions of individual steps. Recent methods derive local credit from explicit interaction records or policy hidden states. For methods that share returns within latent neighborhoods formed by hidden-state similarity, pooling records by action can assign identical credit to steps with different observed transitions. To address this limitation, we introduce CAST, a method for step-level credit assignment motivated by state abstraction theory. CAST forms candidate neighborhoods using policy hidden-state similarity and selects references that match the target step in both action and observed transition, while retaining records of other actions for local comparison. It estimates step-level credit from the retained records without additional environment interaction or a learned value model. Experiments with Qwen3.5-4B and Qwen3.5-9B across four interactive environments show that CAST outperforms GiGPO and BiPACE in all eight settings, with success rate gains of up to 8.9 and 22.0 percentage points, respectively. Additional experiments extend these gains to Llama in two environments. Evaluations on 11 general capability benchmarks further show that both Qwen models retain overall performance after training.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Large language models, Reinforcement Learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_Vx8oOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Credit Assignment with State Transitions (CAST ), a step-level credit assignment method for LLM agents. The authors identify a limitation of existing hidden-state-based approaches, where similar hidden states and identical actions may lead to different state transitions but receive the same credit. CAST addresses this issue by introducing transition-aware reference selection within latent neighborhoods, filtering same-action records with inconsistent transitions while retaining other-action records for local comparison. The resulting step-level advantages are combined with episode-level advantages for policy optimization. Experiments across four interactive environments and multiple model families demonstrate consistent improvements over GiGPO and BiPACE, with limited additional computational overhead.

Critical strengths
  • Clear motivation and well-designed method. The paper addresses a meaningful limitation of hidden-state-based credit assignment, where similar hidden states and identical actions may lead to different state transitions. The authors provide statistical evidence supporting this problem. CAST introduces a simple transition-aware reference selection strategy that naturally aligns with the motivation.
  • Practical design with low computational overhead. CAST builds upon the existing latent neighborhood credit estimation framework without requiring additional environment rollouts or a learned value model. The transition filtering mechanism is straightforward and introduces limited computational overhead.
  • Consistent experimental improvements. CAST consistently outperforms GiGPO and BiPACE across four interactive environments and different model scales. Additional experiments with Llama further demonstrate its effectiveness across model families.
Critical weaknesses
  • Limited methodological novelty. CAST mainly introduces transition-aware reference filtering into the existing latent neighborhood credit estimation framework, making the methodological contribution relatively incremental.
  • Reliance on exact string matching. CAST relies on exact string matching for successor-observation consistency, which may incorrectly distinguish semantically equivalent transitions. This partially reintroduces the limitations of explicit state matching that hidden-state-based approaches aim to address.
  • Insufficient analysis of reference reduction. In Table 5, count-matched random selection already improves performance over BiPACE by 19.0 percentage points, while CAST provides only an additional 3.0-point gain. This suggests that reference reduction itself may account for a substantial portion of CAST's improvements, weakening the attributed contribution of transition-aware selection.
  • Potential limitations of observation-only state representations. The authors extract hidden states using only current observations without incorporating interaction history. However, identical observations may correspond to different underlying environment states due to different histories. It remains unclear whether CAST would provide similar improvements when using full-context hidden states.
Questions for authors
  • Local baseline computation. Why are same-action records with different transitions excluded from both the local action-value estimation and the local baseline? While excluding them from the action-value estimation is understandable, retaining them in the baseline seems reasonable. Could the authors provide an ablation comparing Q-only filtering with the current strategy?
  • Necessity of successor-observation consistency. In Table 6, removing successor-observation consistency reduces performance by only 0.4 points on ScienceWorld. Given the limitations of exact string matching, could the authors further justify the necessity of this component?
Reviewer_6rjGOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents CAST, a method for assigning training credit to individual actions taken by language-model agents during interaction with an environment. Learning from an episode requires deciding which actions deserve credit for its outcome. An existing method, BiPACE, compares actions taken in situations that have similar model representations. CAST questions whether those situations are sufficiently comparable: similar-looking observations can be followed by different rewards, episode endings, or next observations. It proposes using what actually happened after an action to decide which examples should inform its training credit. Intuitively, the method changes the examples used for comparison. For a target step, BiPACE groups records whose current observations have similar vector representations from the policy model. Each record has a return: reward from that step onward, with later rewards discounted and a penalty applied to records containing an invalid action. It subtracts the whole group's average return from the average for records taking the target action. That difference supplies local training credit alongside whole-episode feedback. CAST removes other same-action records if their original environment reward, ending flag, or next-observation text differs from the target's. Text matching ignores case and redundant whitespace. It retains the target itself and all different-action records, then recomputes the averages and any normalization. The intended benefit is to avoid averaging together examples whose similar observations hide different outcomes. But this remains a heuristic: agreeing on an observed transition does not establish identical future prospects. Removing records also changes their contribution to the overall average, so better performance need not prove that the method has identified truly equivalent situations.

CAST adds a filter on reference examples using recorded action outcomes, without extra environment interaction or a separately trained value predictor. The local estimator and observation grouping are inherited; the addition is which same-action records contribute and the resulting change to the comparison. Diagnostics examine whether observation similarity misses important differences, and controls test which parts of filtering matter. The equations specify how records are retained and how the averages change. State-equivalence theory motivates looking at rewards and transitions, but the paper does not prove that this practical filter recovers equivalent states or accurate action credit. Those properties would require more than agreement on individual recorded transitions.

CAST is compared with BiPACE and GiGPO, existing episode/action credit methods, on BabyAI grid-world instruction following, ALFWorld text-based household tasks, ScienceWorld simulated science tasks, and WebShop product search and selection. Tests cover Qwen and Llama model families. Final evaluation uses checkpoints at prescribed training limits shared across methods within each setting. CAST outperforms the trained BiPACE and GiGPO baselines in every reported model/environment setting, measured by task success or mean task score for ScienceWorld. Analyses on fixed batches measure transition disagreements, changes in local credit, and surviving reference records. They show what filtering changes, not that the resulting credits accurately measure each action's contribution. In ALFWorld, a random-selection control computes how many same-action peers CAST would retain for each target in its own current batch, then samples that quantity uniformly from the other same-action records in the original group. It retains the target and other-action peers. This recovers most of the improvement over unfiltered BiPACE, with CAST retaining a smaller advantage. In ScienceWorld, dropping next-observation matching while retaining reward/ending matching nearly matches full CAST and outperforms unfiltered BiPACE. Removing reward from the matching rule substantially reduces performance, with validation performance falling late in training in the original and an additional run of that variant; environmental rewards remain unchanged. Timing tests find little added filtering cost, and general benchmarks examine whether language/reasoning performance is retained after agent training. Main agent-training gains lack uncertainty across independent training runs. The evidence therefore supports a cheap, useful training change more firmly than it establishes the necessity of the full matching rule or the accuracy of each resulting credit.

Critical strengths
  1. A simple change using existing transition records improves final success or task scores over the tested BiPACE and GiGPO baselines across all reported model/environment settings. ScienceWorld shows a substantial improvement even over the stronger baseline. The small measured filtering cost makes this a practical estimator modification rather than an improvement requiring extra rollouts or a learned value model.

  2. Useful controls examine the proposed explanation. The random-selection comparison distinguishes choosing which same-action records to keep from deciding how many to retain. The ScienceWorld variants show that reward/ending matching contributes useful filtering, while the added benefit of matching next-observation text is small there. The authors expose these limits rather than treating every element of the full rule as necessary.

Critical weaknesses

The main performance comparisons lack estimates of variability across independent training runs. CAST's consistent advantage over BiPACE and GiGPO across the reported settings supports practical value, but does not establish how repeatable each gain is. This matters especially for its smaller advantages over count-matched random selection and reward/termination-only matching. Repeating the main baseline comparison and these filtering comparisons would help determine whether those advantages persist across training runs.

The component comparisons also leave unclear when CAST's full matching rule is useful. On ALFWorld, random selection recovers most of the improvement over BiPACE, with a smaller additional gain from choosing records by transition agreement. This control still uses CAST's transition test to determine how many same-action records to retain, so it does not show that transition information is unnecessary. On ScienceWorld, reward/termination-only matching nearly matches the full method. Because these controls are evaluated in different environments, the paper does not establish whether the importance of selecting particular records or matching next-observation text changes across tasks. Applying both controls in another evaluated environment would make that distinction clearer.

Questions for authors

Could you extend the count-matched random-selection and reward/termination-only comparisons to another evaluated environment? This would help establish when selecting examples by their full transition matters; the current controls are tested in different environments, leaving unclear whether their conclusions reflect general properties of CAST or particular tasks.

Could you repeat the main CAST–BiPACE comparison and the key filtering comparisons with independent training runs, and report the variation in results? This would help distinguish repeatable gains from training variability, which the current results do not establish—particularly for the smaller advantages over random selection and reward/termination-only matching.

Reviewer_gs4MOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes CAST, a transition-aware reference selection method for step-level credit assignment in multi-turn LLM agent reinforcement learning. Building upon latent-neighborhood-based estimators, CAST retains same-action references only when their observed transition signatures match the target transition, while preserving other-action references for local comparisons. Extensive experiments across multiple environments and LLM backbones demonstrate the effectiveness of CAST. Presentation*

Critical strengths
  1. Clear motivation and practical method. CAST addresses the limitations of sharing returns among steps with similar hidden states but different observed transitions. The method is simple and requires neither additional environment interactions nor a learned value model.
  2. Comprehensive experiments with insightful analyses. Beyond performance comparisons across environments and models, the authors include credit-change analyses, count-matched random selection, transition-signature ablations, and computational overhead measurements, providing useful insights into the proposed method. Critical Weaknesses*
Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited evidence that successor-observation-based credit changes are beneficial. Although successor-observation consistency substantially changes the estimated step-level credits (Section 4.3), removing it only reduces the ScienceWorld score from 62.7 to 62.3 (Table 6). It remains unclear whether these credit changes improve credit assignment rather than merely producing different estimates.
  2. Insufficient evidence of gains over simpler filtering strategies. In Table 5, count-matched random selection already improves ALFWorld success from 64.5% to 83.5%, compared with 86.5% for CAST. Moreover, reward-and-termination-only filtering achieves 62.3 versus 62.7 for full CAST in Table 6, making it difficult to isolate the contributions of reference reduction, reward consistency, and successor-observation matching.
  3. Lack of end-to-end training efficiency comparisons. Figure 6(b) shows that transition filtering increases credit-function runtime from 0.053 to 0.299 seconds per batch (approximately 5.6×). Although its overall computational cost appears small, the paper does not directly compare end-to-end training time between CAST and BiPACE. Questions For Authors*
Questions for authors
  1. Effectiveness of successor-observation consistency. How do the authors establish that the credit changes induced by successor-observation matching lead to more accurate credit assignment or better policy learning, rather than simply different estimates?
  2. Contributions beyond simpler filtering strategies. Can the authors extend the count-matched random selection and reward-and-termination-only filtering comparisons to additional environments and model scales? Can advantage-scale-matched controls further isolate the benefit of transition-aware reference selection?
  3. End-to-end computational overhead. Can the authors provide matched end-to-end training time or GPU-hour comparisons between CAST and BiPACE? Flag For Ethics Review*

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.