- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies whether spatial context should use the same protein-specific genes as the center spot. TSNR combines selected center genes with a PCA representation of neighborhood-wide gene expression and fits a Huber regressor for each protein. It also decomposes the transferred objective difference between broad and restricted context into target-side value and transfer mismatch. Experiments include a six-section Spatial-CITE-seq benchmark, context and estimator ablations, and retrospective analyses on two external cohorts.
Critical strengths
- TSNR is a simple and inexpensive method with a useful result on the primary benchmark: mean macro Spearman is 0.4391, compared with 0.4164 for DGAT. The reported CPU runtime also makes the method attractive as a practical baseline.
- The context ablations are informative. Broad context improves over both center-only and target-restricted inputs, while shuffled correspondence and random-gene controls do not recover the gain (Table 2). Most of the benefit remains after excluding the selected center genes from context.
Critical weaknesses
-
My main concern is how much the value–mismatch analysis adds to the empirical result. Eq. (3) is an exact rearrangement, and Eq. (4) follows directly from first-order convexity. In Eq. (8), substituting the definitions of value and mismatch causes all terms involving the target-reference fits to cancel. The resulting balance is simply the target Huber objective of the source-trained restricted-context model minus that of the source-trained broad-context model. Its association with Spearman gains therefore shows agreement between two measures of predictive performance. I appreciate the separate component analysis and the spatially disjoint validation in Appendix C.2. The latter addresses reuse of the same evaluation spots. However, I still do not see what additional conclusion about transfer is established by the decomposition. The bounds also do not establish that Huber reduces mismatch relative to other estimators. This leaves the theoretical contribution, and its role in motivating the method, limited.
-
The evidence for the method's advantage across environments is incomplete. Comparisons with DGAT, SPINE and SR2P are confined to the six-section primary benchmark. On the external cohorts, broad context improves over restricted context by on GSE289326 but loses on CytAssist (Sec. 4.4). The authors acknowledge this reversal, but explaining it retrospectively does not tell us when the fixed broad-context design should be used. External comparisons against the main baselines would help establish whether TSNR remains competitive. There is also limited evidence that bounded residual scores explain the primary-benchmark gain: with the same PCA64 context, Elastic Net and HistGradientBoosting obtain and , respectively, versus for Huber (Table 8). These small differences do not establish that either alternative is better.
-
The baseline comparison is too thin for the state-of-the-art claim. Table 1 has only three baselines. Established methods cited in Sec. 2.1 (e.g., cTP-net, sciPENN, scLinear) and simple linear baselines are missing. Since the paper's own center-only linear variant (0.4148) already matches DGAT (0.4164), the gain in Table 1 is hard to interpret.
Questions for authors
-
Why are the comparisons with DGAT, SPINE and SR2P limited to Spatial-CITE-seq? How do these methods compare with TSNR on GSE289326 and CytAssist under the same biological holdout splits?
-
Table 8 shows that Elastic Net and HistGradientBoosting perform similarly to Huber on the primary benchmark. How do these estimators compare on the two external cohorts when using the same TSNR representation?
Response to Reviewer qdc3: Clarifications and Additional Experimental Evidence
We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback. The revision adds external comparisons, broader baselines, and controlled analyses.
SR2P correction
We identified an inconsistency between SR2P's original training-response preprocessing and the common evaluation targets. We corrected this mismatch and re-evaluated SR2P with source-only feature selection and out-of-fold stacking under the same biological holdout protocol. Its primary-benchmark mean increases from 0.2464 to 0.4040; TSNR remains highest at 0.4390 (revised Table 1; Appendix B.5).
Q1. External spatial baselines
Direct comparisons with DGAT, SPINE, and SR2P now cover two external cohorts under matched biological holdout protocols (revised Table 2):
TSNR leads 10/11 biological holdouts. Under the same zero-shot protocol as DGAT on 15 external records (revised Table 3), TSNR achieves the highest mean among the four spatial predictors (0.2089 vs. DGAT 0.1804, SR2P 0.1685, and SPINE 0.1189), outperforming DGAT on 14/15 records.
Q2. External estimator comparison
With the TSNR representation fixed, Huber leads both refitted cohorts (revised Table 4): 0.2847/0.3236, versus ElasticNet 0.2489/0.2830 and HistGradientBoosting 0.2171/0.2512 (GSE289326/CytAssist).
Huber outperforms both in all 11 holdouts, with mean paired gains of +0.0380/+0.0698, respectively. It also exceeds penalty-matched and source-tuned Ridge in 17/17 biological holdouts (Table 5). These results support Huber as a robust empirical choice across independently refitted environments (Appendices C.4–C.5).
W3. Baseline coverage and spatial contribution
The primary comparison now includes 11 baselines, including the requested cTP-net, sciPENN, and scLinear, plus RNA2000 OLS/Ridge (Table 1). TSNR leads in mean macro Spearman (0.4390 vs. DGAT 0.4176 and RNA2000 Ridge 0.3774). It requires 126.8 s per holdout on CPU, compared with 229.3 s for DGAT on an A100 GPU, under their respective hardware configurations (Table 8).
Dimension-matched controls (Table 4) show zero-shot gains from spatial neighborhoods over broad own-spot features at 320 dimensions (+0.0233), and over extra center features (+0.0214) or shuffled neighborhoods (+0.0218) at 384 dimensions, each on 15/15 records.
These results provide direct evidence that spatial neighborhoods contribute predictive information beyond increased feature dimensionality or broader center features, particularly under zero-shot transfer.
W1. Theoretical contribution and contextual transfer
The exact value–mismatch decomposition separates target-side contextual value from transfer mismatch. The score-shift bound provides sufficient conditions for favorable transfer, while the squared-risk specialization characterizes mismatch through target feature covariance (Section 3.3; Appendix A).
Using the Huber objective, the complete balance achieves a mean Spearman association of 0.577 with protein-level contextual gains across 17 biological holdouts, versus 0.108 for value alone and 0.467 for negative mismatch. Associations are positive in 17/17 holdouts and 33/34 spatially disjoint evaluations (Tables 6–7).
Although the balance algebraically equals a difference in target Huber objectives, its association with protein-level Spearman improvements is not implied by this identity. The spatially disjoint evaluation further examines this relationship using separate target regions for diagnostic fitting and evaluation.
In CytAssist, positive contextual value (+0.037) is outweighed by increased mismatch (+0.052), consistent with the observed negative contextual gain. These results support an empirically grounded characterization of contextual transfer. The diagnostic uses target protein measurements retrospectively and does not affect TSNR predictions.