- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Mat2GS is a feedforward framework that jointly predicts geometry and PBR materials from posed images to construct relightable 2D Gaussian assets without per-scene refinement. Its renderer combines metallic–roughness shading, environment lighting, and ray tracing for visibility and single-bounce indirect illumination. Experiments show improved context- and novel-view relighting over evaluated baselines, strong material recovery, and competitive normal accuracy.
Critical strengths
1.Strong relighting performance and cross-view consistency. Mat2GS achieves better relighting quality than the evaluated open-source baselines while preserving geometric and material consistency across viewpoints.
Critical weaknesses
- Unclear motivation for the relighting dataset. The authors present the Objaverse-based relighting dataset as a core contribution, yet training relies on direct supervision of material attributes without a relighting loss. The additional benefit of the relighting-specific dataset construction to model training is therefore not clearly demonstrated. 2.Limited methodological novelty. The proposed method primarily combines modules adapted from existing frameworks, without clearly demonstrating substantive innovations in either the individual components or their integration. Its methodological contribution therefore appears largely incremental.
Questions for authors
1.Dataset contribution. Given that training relies on direct material supervision without a relighting loss, what additional benefit does the multi-illumination dataset provide? Could the authors quantify this benefit through a controlled ablation comparing single- and multi-illumination training with matched objects, views, and training budgets?
2.Methodological novelty. What are the key technical innovations beyond combining modules from existing frameworks? Could the authors identify these novel design choices and provide controlled ablations that isolate their contributions while keeping the training data, supervision, and backbone fixed?