- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposed the stock recommendation framework DISCO (integrating dynamic risk modeling and casual discovery) to rank stocks by predicted returns. DISCO learns a distribution over lagged, directed stock graphs by training the probability of edge existence jointly with the prediction model using a sparse graph prior and a variation objective. Then a functional causal model then aggregates information only from the selected parent stocks, weights it by learned relationship strengths, and produces a market-driven return estimate for each stock. DISCO adds a stock-specific noise term drawn from a skew-normal distribution to model the remaining return uncertainties. An optional inference procedure averages predictions from multiple graph and noise samples. On NASDAQ, NYSE, and TSE datasets, DISCO is reported higher Sharpe ratios and investment returns and than the compared baselines.
Critical strengths
-
DISCO first implies graph casual discovery and functional casual model on a stock recommendation ranking question.
-
DISCO reveals a significant improvement compared to the baseline methods, including newly proposed ones.
Critical weaknesses
The main concern is that the central architecture of DISCO closely resembles the work CausalStock [1], including formulae in the over lagged graphs casual discovery and in the FCM portions. See 4.3, 4.4 in [1]. Predicting continuous returns and optimizing stock rankings instead of classifying price movements is a meaningful adaptation, and some technical skills are adopted in this paper to modify the methods in [1], such as directly training the edge-probability parameters in graph casual discovery and selecting a skew-normal distribution instead of normal Gaussian distribution to model the noise. However, how much the reported improvement depend on these and how much comes from the inherited causal architecture in [1] is not clear. In particular, replacing the learned graph with a fully connected graph in ablation cannot answer that question. A more informative comparison would adapt [1] to the same price inputs, return target, and ranking objective, then separately test the effects of the skew-normal noise model and multi-situation inference. Without these controls, the necessity of DISCO’s added components remains unclear.
[1] Li, S., Sun, Y., Lin, Y., Gao, X., Shang, S., & Yan, R. (2024). CausalStock: Deep end-to-end causal discovery for news-driven multi-stock movement prediction. Advances in neural information processing systems, 37, 47432-47454.
Questions for authors
-
See the weakness. The similarity between DISCO and [1] makes it difficult to assess the independent contribution of this paper. Could the authors explain precisely how DISCO differs from [1] and clarify how much each new component contributes to the reported gains?
-
At inference, DISCO ranks stocks by the average return obtained from graph and risk samples. Could the ranking also reflect a investor’s risk preference, for example, by penalizing volatility or downside risk measured by the Value-at-Risk or conditional Value-at-Risk of the returns? Despite this may reduce the performance on indexes such as IRR.