acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

LADDER: A Long-horizon Robot Manipulation Benchmark

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

General-purpose robot manipulation policies learn short-horizon skills effectively, but degrade rapidly on long-horizon tasks. Existing benchmarks cannot isolate failures because task horizon is either too short or entangled with scene and object variations. We propose LADDER, a long-horizon robot manipulation benchmark scaling from 1 to 10 subgoals within the same environment over three suites (SimplerEnv-Long, RobotArena-∞-Long, and RoboLab-Long), 145 tasks, eight categories, two embodiments, and 2,024 simulated episodes per system. We evaluate two orchestration paradigms: text subgoals for learned low-level policies (VoLo) and tool selection orchestration (CaP-X, GPT-Policy, PSP-Agent, TiPToP). Given the full instruction directly, low-level policies achieve 85.4% on single-subgoal tasks, but drop to near zero on extended tasks. While orchestration remedies this, it remains bounded by physical execution errors of the low-level policy rather than high-level planning and achieves only ∼25%. Tool selection orchestration with GPT-Policy on GPT-6 Astra significantly outperforms learned-policy methods, but incurs significant time and cost budget and succeeds only ∼62%. Real-world experiments across two embodiments confirm the collapse of the low-level policy and the gain from orchestration. Project website: long-horizon-benchmark.github.io

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
long-horizon manipulation, robot manipulation benchmarks, policy orchestration, hierarchical manipulation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_znfrOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces LADDER, a long-horizon robot manipulation benchmark built on SimplerEnv, RobotArena-∞, and RoboLab. It covers two single-arm robot embodiments with parallel-jaw grippers, eight task categories, and horizons ranging from one to ten pick-and-place subgoals. The authors evaluate frozen low-level policies conditioned on complete task instructions, VLM-based systems that decompose tasks and orchestrate low-level policies, and systems that execute through motion primitives or task-and-motion planning. The reported results show that the evaluated low-level policies degrade rapidly as task horizon increases under zero-shot composition. High-level orchestration mitigates this degradation, although performance remains constrained by execution errors. The strongest tool-based systems achieve higher success rates. Real-world experiments on WidowX and Franka robots support the simulation results.

Critical strengths
  1. The authors have implemented multiple evaluation systems and conducted evaluations of a reasonable scale. They report their findings in detail. This provides a relatively reliable comparison of similar systems on long-horizon tasks. The results also corroborate some intuitive conclusions.
  2. Long-horizon tasks are worth investigating, particularly for understanding the compositional generalization capabilities of VLAs. This work contributes to research in this area.
Critical weaknesses
  1. I believe there is a logical flaw in the experimental design of this paper. The benchmark aims to evaluate zero-shot skill composition, yet the models evaluated on SimplerEnv and RobotArena are trained on BridgeData, which contains very little long-horizon manipulation data. Unsurprisingly, these models perform poorly. In contrast, the π₀.₅ model trained on DROID, which contains some long-horizon demonstrations, shows substantially better relative performance as a standalone policy on RoboLab. How these models would perform after sufficient training on relevant long-horizon, multitask data remains to be seen. Overall, I find the evaluation and comparison of low-level policies on this benchmark to be of limited significance. They merely confirm an unsurprising result and offer little meaningful insight.
  2. Much of the effort in this work is devoted to evaluating three categories of control systems. However, the benchmark itself offers limited originality and innovation in its tasks and data.
Questions for authors

How would the performance of the low-level policy and its corresponding VoLo system change after retraining the policy with a substantial amount of relevant long-horizon training data?

1 comment

As the discussion deadline approaches, the authors kindly encourage the reviewer to review the responses. We have carefully considered and addressed the comments and would greatly appreciate any further feedback!

Reviewer_mXMrOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

LADDER evaluates zero-shot composition of short-horizon manipulation skills across tasks, simulation suites, and robot embodiments. Each task contain one to ten pick-and-place subgoals with different spatial and logical constraints. The paper compares learned-policy orchestration and tool-based systems with failure analysis and real-robot experiments.

Critical strengths
  1. The benchmark addresses a useful problem: whether policies can achieve zero-shot performance across extended horizon. Increasing number of subtasks and task families, separating task-success and subgoal-progress metrics provide a useful evaluation.

  2. The study provides sound diagnostic evidence to help distinguish planning, monitoring, and execution limitations.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The benchmark’s distinct contribution and additional insight are insufficiently established. RoboLab already analyzes performance versus task horizon, and VoLo studies orchestration and planning, monitoring, and execution failures. LADDER offers broader horizon coverage, but its main findings largely reinforce these observations. The author claims the main distinction is controlled horizon scaling without the effects from scene clutter and instruction phrasing. Still long-horizon tasks would naturally introduce additional objects and more complex instruction that could potentially affect the performance. It therefore remains unclear what new horizon-specific failure mechanism or design insight this benchmark reveals.

  2. The real-world comparison was not conducted in a fair setting. Table 10 gives PSP-Agent 1,700 steps on the Franka task versus 950 for the learned-policy systems, and every successful PSP-Agent episode places its fourth object only after step 1,200. According to the caption, an earlier PSP-Agent run with 0/12 successes was excluded, with no recorded reason for the repetition. These differences limit the strength of the comparison in Section 5.3.

  3. Real-to-simu transfer may confound the diagnosis of long-horizon failures. The learned policies are trained on BridgeData v2 or DROID but evaluated in simulation. Strong single-subgoal results do not establish how much transfer error contributes to the execution bottleneck as horizon grows.

  4. Success-label validation remains incomplete. Appendix H reports only 73.0% agreement between the success predicates and an alternative geometric check over 504 sampled subgoals. Human video adjudication and threshold sensitivity analysis are needed to assess the reliability of placement labels and the benchmark conclusions.

Questions for authors
  1. Under fixed object inventory and initial layout, what new failure mechanism or orchestration trade-off does increasing horizon reveal beyond existing benchmarks?

  2. Can you report the Franka comparison at a common execution budget, include both PSP-Agent runs or justify the exclusion, and reassess the ranking claim?

  3. Can you examine the 504 subgoals and test whether placement thresholds affect success rates, system rankings, and the “slightly off target” diagnosis?

1 comment

As the discussion deadline approaches, the authors kindly encourage the reviewer to review the responses. We have carefully considered and addressed the comments and would greatly appreciate any further feedback!

Reviewer_z618OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

LADDER introduces a benchmark for evaluating long-horizon robot manipulation with frozen low-level policies and high-level orchestration. It contains three simulation suites, 145 tasks across eight categories, and 2,024 evaluation episodes per system, with instructions requiring one to ten subgoals. The evaluation measures full-task success, subgoal progress, and failure causes. It compares direct policy execution, orchestration through text subgoals with verification and recovery, and systems that select manipulation tools. The experiments show substantial degradation as tasks become longer and gains from orchestration, while leaving considerable room for improvement. Additional analyses examine planning, state tracking, verification, and cost, with real-robot experiments on two embodiments.

Critical strengths
  1. The benchmark addresses a meaningful evaluation need. Its task ladders and eight categories provide a systematic way to study how robots follow longer instructions, including ordering, revisitation, exclusions, and duplicate objects. Reporting subgoal progress alongside complete-task success makes partial execution failures visible. I find this benchmark design useful for studying the gap between individual manipulation skills and reliable completion of longer tasks.
  2. The empirical study is broad and informative. The paper evaluates ten systems across three suites and supplements the main results with alternative-policy experiments, offline planning and verification tests, failure analyses, cost reporting, and confidence intervals over tasks. The real-robot experiments add practical context, although their comparison protocol needs clarification as discussed below. Together, these analyses provide useful evidence about where current systems fail.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The real-robot comparison uses unequal execution budgets and an unexplained run-selection procedure. This is my main concern. Table 10 (p. 22) states that, for the five-subgoal Franka single-destination task, the low-level policy and Proprioceptive verifier receive 950 control steps, whereas PSP-Agent receives 1,700. Every successful PSP-Agent trajectory places its fourth object after step 1,200, so these recorded trajectories would not complete all five subgoals within the other systems’ budget. The caption also states that PSP-Agent ran this task twice, that no reason for the repeat was recorded, and that the first run with 0/12 successes was excluded. These disclosures limit the comparability of the reported 25% success rate and weaken the evidence for transferring system rankings from simulation to real robots. A common-budget comparison and a clear rule for including runs are needed to support that claim.
  2. Some benchmark interpretations need qualification. These are secondary concerns. Scene construction adds objects and enlarges containers for longer tasks (p. 4), so the aggregate horizon trend may also reflect changes in scene complexity and placement conditions. Scripted feasibility checks establish reachability, but do not establish equal per-subgoal difficulty. Separately, Appendix H (p. 29) reports only 73.0% agreement between two geometric placement checks on 504 sampled subgoals. This does not establish that 27% of labels are wrong, but it leaves uncertainty about placement-related failure attribution and possibly success measurements. Clarifying the scope of these effects would strengthen the benchmark’s interpretation.
Questions for authors
  1. Main concern: For the Franka task in Table 10, why were the control-step budgets different, and why was the first PSP-Agent run excluded? Please provide both runs, the rule used to include or exclude trials, and a comparison at a common step budget. Does the claimed agreement between simulation and real-robot rankings hold under these conditions?
  2. Horizon interpretation: Which existing task ladders keep the object set, layout, and container geometry fixed while changing the required number of subgoals? Results for such a subset would help establish how much of the observed trend can be attributed to task length. Otherwise, please qualify the horizon-isolation claim.
  3. Measurement reliability: What explains the disagreement between the geometric checks in Appendix H? Can a focused manual audit of the disputed cases establish whether the success rates and the main placement-related failure conclusions are sensitive to the choice of predicate?
1 comment

As the discussion deadline approaches, the authors kindly encourage the reviewer to review the responses. We have carefully considered and addressed the comments and would greatly appreciate any further feedback!

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.