- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
Goal2Skill combines a high-level vision-language planner, a low-level vision-language-action policy, task memory, and a verifier that decides whether to continue, advance, or replan. Experiments on RoboMME and RMBench report strong results on memory-dependent tasks, including 60% success on Blocks Ranking Try.
Critical strengths
- The system uses execution evidence to revise the remaining plan while retaining verified progress.
- Its memory and verification components target concrete challenges in multi-stage manipulation.
Critical weaknesses
- Several figures have a conspicuously AI-generated appearance, with inconsistent or distorted visual details that detract from their clarity and the overall professionalism of the presentation.
- The related-work discussion does not sufficiently position Goal2Skill against closely related dual-system and memory-centric frameworks, including RoboCerebra and RoboMemArena, making it difficult to assess the novelty of the architecture and the incremental contribution of its memory and verification components.
- Evaluation is concentrated on RoboMME and RMBench, without a real-robot study in this paper.
- The verifier depends on task-specific checks and may misjudge progress when observations are ambiguous.
Questions for authors
Please see the weaknesses section.
3 comments
Response to Reviewer YRtf
W3: Real-robot evaluation.
Thanks for your great suggestion. We agree that real-robot validation is important. Our current evaluation uses RoboMME and RMBench to study memory, progress verification, and recovery under systematic and reproducible conditions. These benchmarks support our conclusions about performance on the evaluated simulated tasks, but do not establish effectiveness in physical deployment.
Real-robot experiments are not included due to the limited resources of physical deployment. We will state this limitation explicitly and identify physical-robot validation as future work.
W4: Progress assessment under ambiguous observations.
This is a good point. We agree that task-specific checks can make incorrect judgments when observations are ambiguous. Goal2Skill addresses this through conservative progression decisions and experience-driven refinement of its verification procedures.
As described in Section 3.2.3, when the verifier cannot establish either completion or a failure requiring intervention, it returns ONGOING, retaining the active subtask. It combines current observations with task memory and, where necessary, evidence across multiple checkpoints; ambiguous or history-dependent cases invoke VLM reasoning. These mechanisms reduce reliance on a single observation.
Moreover, verifier self-evolvement addresses failure patterns identified from execution experience, with candidate updates validated through trajectory replay before adoption. For example, the swing-counting case in Section 5.3 initially infers progress from planned subgoal transitions, which can diverge from actual physical execution. The refined procedure instead detects arrivals at the left and right target regions, suppresses duplicate detections, and counts a cycle only after observing the required transition sequence. This grounds progression in execution evidence. To quantify the contribution of this refinement, we compare an initial generic VLM-based verifier, initialized without manually authored task-specific rules, with the self-evolved verifier on 50 episodes per task across six RoboMME tasks.
| Task | Initial verifier | Evolved verifier | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| PickXtimes | 74% | 92% | +18 pp |
| ButtonUnmaskSwap | 8% | 50% | +42 pp |
| VideoRepick | 70% | 60% | −10 pp |
| VideoPlaceOrder | 82% | 90% | +8 pp |
| PickHighlight | 64% | 76% | +12 pp |
| VideoPlaceButton | 22% | 52% | +30 pp |
| Average | 53.30% | 70.00% | +16.7 pp |
The refined verifier improves success on five of the six tasks, increasing average success by 16.7 percentage points. Complementing the verification comparison in W2, this result supports the practical value of experience-driven refinement for end-to-end task execution.
Thanks for your additional experiments, and I would maintain my original rating.
Response to Reviewer YRtf
Thank you for your constructive comments and for recognizing the value of evidence-guided plan revision and our memory and verification mechanisms. We clarify the presentation, methodological distinctions, evaluation scope, and handling of ambiguous observations below.
W1: Figure quality and clarity.
Thank you for pointing out these presentation issues. The figures are created by the authors using Adobe Illustrator and Matplotlib without using AI tools. We will review the figures for inconsistent details, unclear annotations, and formatting issues, and improve their readability and visual consistency. We would also appreciate pointers to particular figures or elements that appear distorted so that we can address them precisely.
W2: Differences from RoboCerebra and RoboMemArena.
Thank you for highlighting these closely related works. We haved added explicit citations and comparisons in the revised manuscript.
The hierarchical framework introduced in RoboCerebra uses its high-level VLM to assess execution progress and update subgoals or refine instructions. PrediMem, introduced with RoboMemArena, predicts subtasks from recent observations and keyframe memory; its asynchronous inference procedure updates the active subtask whenever a new high-level prediction arrives, without describing a separate completion-verification gate.
Goal2Skill shares the use of high-level reasoning and memory with these frameworks. Our contribution lies in how verification and memory govern task progression and recovery. First, verification uses explicit checking procedures that are functionally distinct from subtask generation and are refined through execution feedback and replay validation. Periodic verification links frequent action execution with sparse planning: confirmed completion advances the existing plan, while detected failure or an exhausted subtask budget triggers reflection and targeted correction. Second, memory updates are conditioned on the remaining plan, preserving information needed by future steps alongside verified outcomes and previous recovery attempts. This context supports subsequent planning, verification, and recovery.
To assess the contribution of these design choices within Goal2Skill, we added two controlled comparisons.
1. Verification procedure versus planner-assessed completion. We replace our verification procedure with completion judgments produced by the high-level model that also generates subtasks. These judgments directly control task progression. We evaluate this alternative on 50 episodes per task across all 16 RoboMME tasks.
Full Goal2Skill improves average success by 31.6 percentage points. This supports the contribution of our verification procedure as a whole relative to the tested planner-assessed alternative.
2. Structured memory versus recent execution history. Since both related frameworks already use memory, we examine whether our memory configuration provides benefits beyond access to recent execution records. We replace structured memory with the last eight execution records supplied to the high-level modules, keeping the executor, verifier library, VLM backend, and evaluation settings fixed.
Across these seven RoboMME tasks, full Goal2Skill achieves 63.1% average success, compared with 54.9% for recent execution history, an improvement of 8.2 percentage points. This comparison evaluates our complete memory configuration, including its retention strategy, rather than memory organization alone.
These experiments assess the contributions of verification and memory within our framework. They are not reproductions of RoboCerebra or PrediMem, and we do not claim direct performance superiority over either framework. We have revised our paper to incoporate the additional results.