- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces RoboARCade, a benchmark for Agentic Robot Control (ARC) comprising 22 long-horizon manipulation tasks involving single-arm and bimanual manipulation, assembly, physical puzzles, and laboratory-inspired procedures. The benchmark integrates MuJoCo simulation, high-fidelity Blender rendering, and unified evaluation protocols, supporting both VIA and multi-view RGBD interfaces. The authors evaluate several frontier multimodal agents and investigate their limitations in visual understanding, action planning, precise execution, and task completion verification. Furthermore, the paper studies autonomous improvement through in-context learning and feedback-based prompt optimization without updating model parameters. GPT-6 Astra achieves a 49.2% subtask completion score with VIA, while the autonomous improvement experiments increase the mean rubric score from 54.0% to 72.7%.
Critical strengths
-
A practical and unified benchmark for agentic robot control. RoboARCade integrates 22 diverse manipulation tasks with multiple robot configurations and standardized evaluation interfaces. Beyond conventional short-horizon manipulation benchmarks, it offers a useful setting for evaluating long-horizon planning, closed-loop control, and the use of execution feedback.
-
Insightful and systematic analysis of agent failures. The paper goes beyond aggregate performance by investigating visual understanding, action planning, execution precision, retry-based recovery, and incorrect success claims. These analyses provide valuable empirical evidence about the current limitations of multimodal agents in robotic control.
Critical weaknesses
-
The primary evaluation metric does not fully capture long-horizon task completion. The Success (%) metric in Table 1 measures the proportion of completed rubric subtasks rather than full-episode success. The paper does not provide complete task-level success rates and per-task statistics across all 22 tasks, making the overall performance difficult to interpret. Additionally, the comparison of trajectory lengths across benchmarks is based on simulation steps without sufficiently accounting for differences in control frequency and action granularity, weakening the claim regarding long-horizon complexity.
-
Limited coverage and incomplete cost analysis of autonomous improvement. The main autonomous improvement evaluation focuses on only five tasks selected to have at least one successful rollout, which limits the representativeness of the results. Furthermore, T2 uses multiple rounds of graded rollout feedback, while the reported costs mainly reflect individual evaluation trials rather than the cumulative cost of obtaining demonstrations and optimizing prompts. The lack of cross-task generalization experiments also makes it difficult to establish the broader effectiveness of the proposed autonomous improvement setting.
-
Limited Novelty and Insufficient Experimental Validation. The paper primarily integrates existing robotic manipulation tasks into a unified benchmark, with limited methodological novelty beyond the evaluation framework. Moreover, the experiments focus on a narrow set of proprietary agent models from only two model families, without evaluating open-source alternatives or a broader range of agent architectures. This limited model coverage makes it difficult to establish whether RoboARCade can comprehensively and reliably assess the general capabilities of agentic robot control systems. Additional evaluations across more diverse models and control paradigms would strengthen the benchmark's validity and significance.
Questions for authors
-
Limited Model Coverage. The evaluation only includes proprietary models from two model families. Could the authors extend the experiments to additional open-source and closed-source models to demonstrate that RoboARCade can reliably differentiate the capabilities of diverse agentic robot control systems?
-
Benchmark Novelty and Evaluation Scope. Most tasks are adapted from existing robotic benchmarks. What unique capabilities does RoboARCade evaluate beyond existing benchmarks? In particular, how can the authors demonstrate that it effectively assesses agentic capabilities such as reasoning, planning, and memory, rather than primarily measuring action execution and manipulation precision?
-
Evaluation Metrics. The reported Success (%) mainly reflects subtask completion rather than full-episode success. Could the authors provide complete task success rates and per-task results across all 22 tasks to better demonstrate the benchmark's effectiveness in evaluating long-horizon manipulation?
-
Autonomous Improvement and Generalization. The autonomous improvement experiments are limited to five selected tasks. Could the authors extend these evaluations to more diverse tasks, particularly those without successful demonstrations, and report the total computational and inference costs of the multi-round optimization process?
4 comments
[2/n] Reviewer Er47
Q2: Benchmark Novelty and Evaluation Scope. Most tasks are adapted from existing robotic benchmarks. What unique capabilities does RoboARCade evaluate beyond existing benchmarks? In particular, how can the authors demonstrate that it effectively assesses agentic capabilities such as reasoning, planning, and memory, rather than primarily measuring action execution and manipulation precision?
For all 22 tasks, we had to introduce large task-specific initial-position ranges because these benchmarks were designed for VLA evaluation with narrow randomization distributions. Since we made these ranges large, they had to be tested to ensure the task was feasible with the agents. In addition, we substantially modified the visual and collision meshes and tuned physics parameters to address issues in the existing assets and scenes. The contributions therefore extend beyond asset reuse to task construction, scene configuration, and physics tuning. Below, we breakdown all 22 tasks. The Appendix Table 3 has citations to all named benchmarks included below and below are just some of the differences for all 22 tasks:
- Beam placement, Cooling manifold, Gamepad, Circular stool: The task is original. The assets are from Fabrica. Visual meshes were fine. Collision meshes and friction had to be tuned to all for feasible insertion under sub-mm tolerances.
- Square nut assembly: The task is not original. The assets are from Robomimic. The visual and collision meshes had issues.
- Shell game: Completely original
- Lights Out, 6×7: The task is not original. Expand the original 4×6 board to 6×7 for much more difficult task. The assets are not unique.
- Lock coins in strongbox: Completely original
- Pack tools into toolboxes: Completely original besides tool assets from RoboDojo where visual and collision meshes had to be tuned.
- Organize table and plug in charger: The task is original. The charger and pen assets from RoboDojo. We modified the charger’s visual and collision meshes and tuned friction and restitution for the assets.
- Sort LEGO bricks: The task is original. The assets are from Robodojo.
- Set Up PCR Run: The task is original. The asset is from AutoBio. The plate friction and meshes were tuned.
- Start incubation: The task is original. The asset is from AutoBio but buttons were added. The test tube visual and collision meshes were tuned.
- Vortex sample: The task is original. The asset is from AutoBio but switches were added and it was made articulated. The test tubes visual and collision meshes were tuned.
- Serve warm drinks: The task is original. The assets are from LIBERO but heavily tuned meshes and physics parameters. A button was added to the microwave as part of the task.
- Tidy counter: The task is not original. The assets are from LIBERO but heavily tuned meshes and physics parameters.
- Start making breakfast: The task is original. The assets are from LIBERO but heavily tuned meshes and physics parameters. A toaster asset with bread was added.
- Handover dominos: The task is not original from Pix2Dex.
- Cup pyramid: The task is not original. The assets are from Pix2Dex but heavily tuned. The cup friction had to be tuned and the meshes aligned.
- Jenga tower: The task is not original from Pix2Dex.
- Hang mugs and rack plates: The task is not original. The assets are from Pix2Dex but heavily tuned. Center of mass of mug stand, plate thickness, mug handle friction.
- Bottles in bin: The task is not original. The assets are from Pix2Dex but heavily tuned. The bottles friction and restitution were heavily tuned.
[3/n] Reviewer Er47
Q3: Evaluation Metrics. The reported Success (%) mainly reflects subtask completion rather than full-episode success. Could the authors provide complete task success rates and per-task results across all 22 tasks to better demonstrate the benchmark's effectiveness in evaluating long-horizon manipulation?
Absolutely. We include in Table 1 above the full-episode solve percentage. In Appendix Table 12, we include per-task results across all 22 tasks.
Appendix Table 12: Each cell reports subtask success (%) / full-episode solve (%), with five seeds per task.
| Task | GPT-5.6-Sol (VIA) | Claude Opus 5 (VIA) | Claude Fable 5.1 (VIA) | Claude Fable 5.1 (Multi-view RGBD) | GPT-6-Astra (VIA) | GPT-6-Astra (Multi-view RGBD) | Gemini 4 Argon Medium (VIA) | Gemini 4 Argon High (VIA) | Gemini 4 Argon High (Multi-view RGBD) | DeepSeek V4.1 Flash 1017 Xhigh (Multi-view RGBD) | DeepSeek V4.1 Flash 1017 Xhigh (VIA) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Beam placement | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 60.0 / 60 | 20.0 / 20 | 40.0 / 40 | 80.0 / 80 | 40.0 / 40 | 40.0 / 40 | 60.0 / 60 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Puzzle 6×7 | 100.0 / 100 | 100.0 / 100 | 100.0 / 100 | 100.0 / 100 | 100.0 / 100 | 100.0 / 100 | 100.0 / 100 | 100.0 / 100 | 100.0 / 100 | 100.0 / 100 | 40.0 / 40 |
| Shell game | 93.8 / 80 | 98.5 / 80 | 80.0 / 80 | 86.2 / 80 | 100.0 / 100 | 87.7 / 80 | 81.5 / 80 | 100.0 / 100 | 100.0 / 100 | 26.2 / 20 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Sort LEGO bricks | 46.7 / 0 | 88.9 / 40 | 100.0 / 100 | 95.6 / 80 | 95.6 / 60 | 97.8 / 80 | 100.0 / 100 | 97.8 / 80 | 100.0 / 100 | 13.3 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Tidy counter | 6.7 / 0 | 26.7 / 0 | 100.0 / 100 | 66.7 / 60 | 60.0 / 60 | 20.0 / 0 | 40.0 / 20 | 53.3 / 40 | 73.3 / 60 | 6.7 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Square | 0.0 / 0 | 100.0 / 100 | 60.0 / 60 | 100.0 / 100 | 100.0 / 100 | 100.0 / 100 | 100.0 / 100 | 100.0 / 100 | 100.0 / 100 | 20.0 / 20 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Bottles in Bin | 5.0 / 0 | 75.0 / 60 | 100.0 / 100 | 65.0 / 40 | 95.0 / 80 | 95.0 / 80 | 80.0 / 60 | 95.0 / 80 | 90.0 / 80 | 5.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Handover Dominos | 13.3 / 0 | 30.0 / 0 | 63.3 / 20 | 53.3 / 20 | 70.0 / 20 | 80.0 / 60 | 26.7 / 0 | 56.7 / 20 | 66.7 / 40 | 6.7 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Cup Pyramid | 6.7 / 0 | 26.7 / 0 | 46.7 / 20 | 46.7 / 0 | 46.7 / 40 | 26.7 / 20 | 26.7 / 0 | 40.0 / 20 | 66.7 / 40 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Set Up PCR Run | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 20.0 / 20 | 15.0 / 0 | 55.0 / 40 | 40.0 / 40 | 55.0 / 40 | 15.0 / 0 | 80.0 / 80 | 20.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Jenga Tower | 2.2 / 0 | 6.7 / 0 | 20.0 / 0 | 8.9 / 0 | 24.4 / 0 | 17.8 / 0 | 20.0 / 0 | 8.9 / 0 | 13.3 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Cooling manifold | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 20.0 / 20 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 20.0 / 20 | 20.0 / 20 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Gamepad | 0.0 / 0 | 20.0 / 20 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 20.0 / 20 | 0.0 / 0 | 20.0 / 20 | 40.0 / 40 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Hang mugs / rack plates | 0.0 / 0 | 10.0 / 0 | 25.0 / 0 | 5.0 / 0 | 10.0 / 0 | 10.0 / 0 | 20.0 / 0 | 25.0 / 0 | 25.0 / 0 | 5.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Organize table / charger | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 20.0 / 0 | 23.3 / 0 | 56.7 / 0 | 46.7 / 0 | 6.7 / 0 | 26.7 / 0 | 10.0 / 0 | 3.3 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Pack tools | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 2.5 / 0 | 2.5 / 0 | 5.0 / 0 | 5.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 15.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Start incubation | 4.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 8.0 / 0 | 24.0 / 0 | 16.0 / 0 | 48.0 / 40 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 8.0 / 0 | 8.0 / 0 | 4.0 / 0 |
| Start making breakfast | 30.0 / 0 | 80.0 / 60 | 100.0 / 100 | 65.0 / 60 | 100.0 / 100 | 80.0 / 60 | 40.0 / 0 | 80.0 / 60 | 85.0 / 60 | 75.0 / 40 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Circular stool | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 20.0 / 20 | 40.0 / 40 | 40.0 / 40 | 60.0 / 60 | 80.0 / 80 | 20.0 / 20 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Vortex sample | 0.0 / 0 | 4.0 / 0 | 20.0 / 0 | 12.0 / 0 | 40.0 / 0 | 36.0 / 0 | 24.0 / 0 | 20.0 / 0 | 28.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 8.0 / 0 |
| Serve warm drinks | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 36.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 24.0 / 0 | 32.0 / 20 | 8.0 / 0 | 44.0 / 0 | 24.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Lock coins in strongbox | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 2.5 / 0 | 5.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 | 0.0 / 0 |
| Overall | 14.0 / 8.2 | 30.3 / 20.9 | 43.6 / 34.5 | 36.8 / 26.4 | 49.8 / 36.4 | 48.3 / 37.3 | 37.9 / 27.3 | 46.6 / 34.5 | 51.4 / 40.9 | 13.1 / 8.2 | 2.5 / 1.9 |
[4/n] Reviewer Er47
Q4: Autonomous Improvement and Generalization. The autonomous improvement experiments are limited to five selected tasks. Could the authors extend these evaluations to more diverse tasks, particularly those without successful demonstrations, and report the total computational and inference costs of the multi-round optimization process?
Absolutely. We extend the task-specific autonomous improvement experiments for tasks without successful demonstrations to a set of 5 tasks from just 1. Table 2 has the results and also includes the one-time computational cost of the optimization process. The inference cost of the optimization process for each individual episode is already included in the per-episode cost as the optimization incorporates a prompt that is prepended when the agent starts the task. We see that multiple rounds of optimization provide increased subtask success and full-episode success, keeping with the earlier trends. We see the optimization costs are extremely high compared to the per-episode inference cost, however, that cost is a one-time cost.
Main paper Table 2:
| Method | Subtask (%) | Full-episode solve (%) | Per-episode cost ($) | Optimization cost ($) | Turns/EEF | Calls/EEF |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GPT-6-Astra baseline | 53.5 | 38.0 | 27.60 | — | 2.5 | 3.4 |
| In-context success demo (ICL) | 73.0 | 64.0 | 30.55 | — | 3.1 | 4.2 |
| Text prompt, round 1 (T1) | 62.5 | 52.0 | 30.76 | 57.41 | 3.0 | 3.3 |
| Text prompt, round 2 (T2) | 72.0 | 64.0 | 22.75 | 914.27 | 2.3 | 3.2 |
| No successful baseline episode | ||||||
| GPT-6-Astra baseline | 25.3 | 0.0 | 42.00 | — | 2.4 | 3.1 |
| Text prompt, round 1 (T1) | 40.0 | 16.0 | 36.18 | 539.93 | 1.8 | 3.2 |
| Text prompt, round 2 (T2) | 53.3 | 20.0 | 35.40 | 1,149.60 | 2.1 | 3.1 |
Here we address all of the Critical Weaknesses:
The paper does not provide complete task-level success rates and per-task statistics across all 22 tasks, making the overall performance difficult to interpret.
We included in Table 1 the complete task-level success rates and in Appendix Table 12 the per-task statistics.
Additionally, the comparison of trajectory lengths across benchmarks is based on simulation steps without sufficiently accounting for differences in control frequency and action granularity, weakening the claim regarding long-horizon complexity.
We agree that raw step counts alone do not establish long-horizon. We have therefore revised the main paper to report approximate simulated time durations to incorporate control frequency alongside trajectory lengths, using duration = number of steps / control frequency. Across our 22 tasks, rollouts average 3,311 control steps, corresponding to approximately 166 s at 20 Hz. For comparison, we use average trajectories and control frequencies from that benchmark. For example, trajectories contain 276 steps for LIBERO-Long [1] (14 s at 20 Hz), 372 for RoboCasa [2] (19 s at 20 Hz), 502 for VLABench [3] (approximately 50 s using its nominal 10 Hz), and 2,972 for RoboCerebra [4] (149 s at 20 Hz). RoboDojo’s long-horizon demonstrations average 630 steps [5] (25 s at 25 Hz). These conversions account for different control frequencies of different benchmarks. We note the closest is the RoboCerebra benchmark [4], however, it primarily tests the single Franka Panda embodiment. Our tasks test the single Franka Panda, bimanual Panda and bimanual YAM embodiments.
Furthermore, T2 uses multiple rounds of graded rollout feedback, while the reported costs mainly reflect individual evaluation trials rather than the cumulative cost of obtaining demonstrations and optimizing prompts.
We now provide the per-episode individual evaluation cost and the optimization cost for T1 and T2. As expected, the optimization cost for T2 is high but it is a one-time cost.
The lack of cross-task generalization experiments also makes it difficult to establish the broader effectiveness of the proposed autonomous improvement setting.
We agree with the reviewer and made changes to the manuscript to limit the scope of the autonomous improvement section to task-specific autonomous improvement.
[1] Liu et al. LIBERO: Benchmarking Knowledge Transfer for Lifelong Robot Learning. 2023.
[2] Nasiriany et al. RoboCasa: Large-Scale Simulation of Household Tasks for Generalist Robots. 2024.
[3] Zhang et al. VLABench: A Large-Scale Benchmark for Language-Conditioned Robotics Manipulation with Long-Horizon Reasoning Tasks. 2025.
[4] Han et al. RoboCerebra: A Large-scale Benchmark for Long-horizon Robotic Manipulation Evaluation. 2025.
[5] Chen et al. RoboDojo: A Unified Sim-and-Real Benchmark for Comprehensive Evaluation of Generalist Robot Manipulation Policies. 2026.
[1/n] Reviewer Er47
Thank you so much for your feedback and thorough questions. We address all four questions and additional points below.
Q1: Limited Model Coverage. The evaluation only includes proprietary models from two model families. Could the authors extend the experiments to additional open-source and closed-source models to demonstrate that RoboARCade can reliably differentiate the capabilities of diverse agentic robot control systems?
Absolutely. We expand our models in Table 1 to include another frontier closed-source model, Gemini 4 Argon, and a frontier open-source model, Deepseek V4.1 Flash 1017. We also evaluate Gemini 4 Argon at high and medium reasoning levels (Appendix Table 12 and Table 13). High reasoning achieves 46.6% subtask success and a 34.5% full-episode solve rate, compared with 37.9% and 27.3% for medium reasoning. These differences show that the benchmark distinguishes performance across reasoning levels within the same model. Note that the numbers from the original manuscript are very slightly different as we discovered some errors in a few rollouts and reran them.
Main Paper Table 1: