- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes MAPO-Net, an MLLM-guided framework for multi-exposure HDR reconstruction in dynamic scenes. By leveraging a frozen multi-modal large language model to generate artifact descriptions, the method introduces a cross-modal detector that combines textual and visual features to localize reconstruction artifacts. The predicted masks are converted into spatial weight maps to guide an artifact-aware reconstruction loss, complemented by an MLLM-based perceptual loss. These auxiliary modules are used only during training. At inference, only the HDR reconstruction backbone is retained. Furthermore, the authors introduce Hard-HDR, a dataset containing 2,300 real-captured scenes with HDR references and artifact annotations. The reported experiments on three datasets and multiple reconstruction backbones show improvements in reconstruction quality and ghosting suppression.
Critical strengths
The proposed Hard-HDR dataset could be a useful resource for the community if publicly released, providing additional real-captured scenes and artifact annotations for training and evaluation.
Critical weaknesses
-
The manuscript contains numerous substantive citation errors, including references to its central backbone and competing methods. For instance, AFUNet is attributed to Yan et al., TPAMI 2024, whereas the actual work is by Li et al., ICCV 2025. The DiffHDR reference pairs the paper title with an entirely incorrect author list, and Table 6 identifies HDR-Transformer as TPAMI 2024 despite citing its ECCV 2022 paper. Additional author and title mismatches occur in the SUPIR and GPT-4V references. The extent of these errors raises serious concerns about the accuracy of the literature review and the identification of the methods used in the experiments.
-
The experimental setup is insufficiently specified, making it difficult to assess how the reported comparisons were obtained. The tables also contain unexplained inconsistencies: Table 4 describes an ablation on Hard-HDR, yet its baseline exactly matches all five Kalantari17 baseline values in Tables 1 and Table 5 rather than the Hard-HDR results. Its full-model results also differ from those reported for Hard-HDR in Tables 1 and Table 7. These discrepancies undermine confidence in the reported improvements and ablation conclusions.
Questions for authors
• How do the authors explain the numerous incorrect author–title associations and publication details in the references? Were these entries generated or modified using AI tools, and how were they verified?
• How do the authors explain the discrepancies between Table 4 and Tables 1 and Table 7? In particular, why does the Hard-HDR ablation baseline exactly match the Kalantari17 baseline in Tables 1 and Table 5, and why do the full-model results differ across tables? Please clarify the experimental settings and identify the correct results.