- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes FluidRain, a compact video deraining model that converts an estimated divergence-free rain-flow field into an anisotropic attention bias. A Loop-in-Loop architecture shares parameters across neighbouring frames and multiple scales. The model uses 0.80M parameters and is validated through four benchmarks, controlled architectural ablations, changing rain directions, and real-rain transfer.
Critical strengths
1.The model achieves competitive restoration with only 0.80M parameters, including useful transfer to WeatherBench.
2.Controlled studies on complementary observations, weight sharing, projection, and directional interventions provide substantial evidence for the design.
Critical weaknesses
1.All baselines are retrained using a common 20k-iteration schedule and small crops, without convergence curves or comparisons against adequately trained checkpoints. Different architectures may require different optimization recipes, so the reported rankings primarily establish performance under this particular training budget.
2.The divergence-free derivation assumes restricted camera motion and depth conditions. Although these limitations are acknowledged, direct rain-flow accuracy measurements and tests under assumption violations are missing. Projection removal alone cannot distinguish physically meaningful modeling from generic regularization.
3.DeLiVR already explores geometric motion cues in attention. Comparing complete networks does not reveal how much improvement comes specifically from the proposed bias rather than the backbone and parameter-sharing strategy. A matched-backbone comparison would clarify the methodological advance.
4.Table 1 reports 271 ms for FluidRain, compared with 75 ms for RainMamba and 20 ms for NAFNet. These results warrant a clearer accuracy–latency analysis, together with computational cost and peak memory measurements.
Questions for authors
1.Do the main rankings persist with longer training or official checkpoints evaluated under a verified common protocol? Please provide convergence evidence for the strongest video baselines.
2.Within the same backbone, how does the proposed pathway compare with a generic smoothness-regularized directional field and a DeLiVR-style attention bias?
3.Can you quantify rain-flow direction accuracy before and after projection, and identify whether projection helps or hurts under camera motion that violates the stated assumptions?
2 comments
Manuscript revisions
Thank you again for your constructive suggestions. We have incorporated the additional analyses discussed in our response into the revised manuscript:
- Training diagnostics: Appendix C.5 and Figure 11 now include the training curves and the monitoring setup.
- Rain-flow evaluation: Section 4.4 (Tables 5–7) now includes the projection and attention-bias controls, direction-accuracy measurements, and controlled camera-motion tests. Appendix D.7 provides the evaluation protocols.
- Matched-backbone comparison: Appendix D.6 (Table 13) now includes the DeLiVR-style spatiotemporal-bias comparison within the same Loop-in-Loop backbone.
We appreciate the time you have devoted to reviewing our work and would be grateful for your feedback on these revisions and any remaining concerns.
Response to Reviewer voeP
We thank the reviewer for the constructive assessment and for recognizing FluidRain’s competitive restoration with only 0.80M parameters, its transfer to WeatherBench, and the controlled studies supporting our design. Your suggestions help us clarify the role and limitations of the rain-flow prior.
1. W1 & Q1: Training duration and convergence evidence
We examined the NTURain training curves for FluidRain, S2VD, and RainMamba. During the final 2k updates, FluidRain and RainMamba show little change in monitored PSNR, while S2VD shows no further improvement. Their losses also decrease only slightly. For FluidRain, the monitored PSNR gain over the entire final 4k updates is approximately 0.05 dB.
These observations provide evidence that performance stabilizes toward the end of the 20k-update schedule. They address the concern about missing training diagnostics, although they do not establish whether the rankings persist under longer training or official checkpoints. We will include the training-loss, learning-rate, and monitored-PSNR curves, together with the monitoring settings, in the supplementary material.
2. W2 & Q3: Direction accuracy and camera-motion violations
We added direct measurements of direction accuracy before and after projection, together with controlled camera-motion tests.
Direction accuracy. We compare raw and projected directions from the same forward pass after separately averaging flow vectors within each s=1 attention window. Angular errors are measured against structure-tensor targets recomputed per window, using 180∘ equivalence, identical valid windows, and equal weighting across videos. We use the same model weights as in the pointwise evaluation.
Table R3. Direction error before and after projection (° ↓).
Projection improves direction accuracy on both evaluated benchmarks.
Camera-motion tests. We rendered eight scenes under static, forward-motion, and yaw conditions, with 40 evaluated centre frames per condition. Rainy and clean pairs use identical camera trajectories and exposure, with raindrops included only in the rainy version. Checks using the known trajectories confirm nonzero divergence in the forward-motion and yaw conditions.
Table R4. Controlled camera-motion results.
Table R3 shows improved direction accuracy after projection on both benchmarks. Under the camera motions that violate the assumptions in Table R4, projection slightly worsens direction accuracy for forward motion (+0.057°) and slightly improves it for yaw (−0.063°). Nevertheless, Full achieves higher regional PSNR than No-Π in both conditions, by 0.429 and 0.438 dB, respectively.
3. W3 & Q2: Matched-backbone comparison with DeLiVR-style bias
We evaluate a DeLiVR-style SO(2) spatiotemporal-bias adapter within the same Loop-in-Loop backbone.
Table R5. Matched-backbone comparison on RainSynComplex.
FluidRain improves PSNR by 1.52 dB and SSIM by 0.0311. The adapter uses framewise SO(2) rotations to construct the spatial attention bias and incorporates angular displacement into the existing frame-fusion logits, retaining the other flow-dependent components. FluidRain instead parameterizes local anisotropic attention through the direction and extent of the projected rain-flow field. These results support the advantage of the proposed geometric guidance over the tested DeLiVR-style alternative when the backbone and parameter-sharing strategy are held fixed.