- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Setting the eyes on the efficiency, this paper addresses the tasks on unifying 4K video dehazing, deraining, denoising, and LLE. Named as LoopMoEVR, the proposed method reuses a video-processing backbone across iterations, combines degradation information with iteration embeddings through a low-rank interaction, and uses local features, pooled video states, and cross-iteration momentum to condition normalization and updates. The paper also designs a separately trained predictor to select the number of iterations for better dynamic efficiency. Experiments cover different datasets and degradation types. Component ablations and qualitative experiments on real-world images are also included within the paper.
Critical strengths
- Clear motivation and a useful idea on the tradeoff of quality and parameter. The conditioning settings are tested and confirmed.
- Extensive ablations on adaptive depth and temporal visuals. The results also support input-dependent iteration allocation while keeping stability.
- Qualitative comparison is included within the paper.
Critical weaknesses
- While promoting the efficiency of this domain is applaudable, the problem is, from Tab. 1, also from the design of the proposed method, the reduced params are from the trade-off of computation speed, i.e., by iterations. Compared to others, the problem is more explicit, e.g., 0.51 s v.s. 0.48 s. This renders the Fig. 1 misleading. As less params will not contribute to faster processing speed and not suitable for certain mobile phone uses/implementations. Justifications are needed regarding this claims.
- The generalization claim is too broad in reviewer's minds. Real-world evidence only consists of two sets of still images, while non-UHD PSNR falls below on both tested datasets. These results do not support the generalization.
- While Tab. 6 compares dense and expert branches, the current presentation is without reporting their params or computation needs. Adding shared experts improves PSNR by 1.03 dB, but also adds capacity. Are the gains from a comparable parameter or computation budget?
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses. The reviewer's rating of 2 is mainly based on these. When with satisfactory rebuttal, the reviewer is happy to adjust the score.
A point regarding methodology part shall also be noted, as that, the current equations and notations are rambling, forcing the readers to read the paper with extreme attention. The notations are also less connected to the presented figures.