- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies the choice of learning targets for ML period DFT initialization. It empirically demonstrates that is advantageous over other learning targets.
Critical strengths
This paper shows that can be a better learning target for the dataset and ML models the author tested.
Critical weaknesses
-
This paper doesn't demonstrate enough contribution to the field or meet the conference's standards. It cites "Chen et al., 2026" (https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.15151) multiple times and acknowledges that this paper is a follow-up work to "Chen et al., 2026". However, the overlap between "Chen et al., 2026" and this work is very large: their dataset is the same, and the SCF benchmark methods are the same. This paper also reuses , , and evaluation from "Chen et al., 2026", without making new progress in these three targets. For the ML model architecture part, this paper uses an existing framework, ChargE3Net. This work added to the existing dataset, but calculating is easy given that and already existed in "Chen et al., 2026". Another new thing (compared to "Chen et al., 2026") in this work is the downstream properties evaluation. However, downstream properties evaluation is not a new task and is widely benchmarked.
-
The experiments in this paper are not able to prove that is broadly more advantageous than other prediction targets. Thus, the conclusion in the paper has a narrow scope. Specifically:
- The most important conclusion in this paper, that can be advantageous for SCF initialization, is known in the field. And the related work includes (https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.25724, https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.21657)
- Even in the period system this paper focused on, it fails to establish that is generally/broadly more advantageous. Only one dataset has been evaluated, and changing the dataset can potentially reverse the conclusion, given that the current gap between and the competing method is very close. To show a general advantage, the author needs justifications from physical intuition, evidence across datasets and calculation settings. One thing the author can do is to show a metrics v.s. dataset size curve/table. This can help us understand if their ranking flips with different data volume.
- Taking one step back, this paper also doesn't provide strong enough evidence for the provided dataset. The biggest problem is that the baseline is too weak. As shown in Table 3, the SAD default takes 16 cycles to converge. However, as a residual learning approach based on SAD, HamGNN-Matrix-∆D still needs 16 cycles to converge. Without the residual, ML-based initialization even needs more SCF cycles to converge. So either the dataset chosen is very hard for this task, or the baseline method is not well optimized/suitable for this dataset. Showing beating a poor baseline is not unexpected. Please clearify if the advantage of comes from a better learning target, or better/suitable model architecture.
Questions for authors
See weakness