- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces riemannian flow matching for the evolution of molecular orbital for the Grassmannian manifold . The authors provide the infinitesimal derivative of the quotient manifold (i.e., horizontal derivative) and the corresponding flow matching training loss. The results show the effectiveness of the method.
Critical strengths
- Modeling the orbital iteration as a quotient-space flow matching is clearly novel.
- The results for MD17 and MD22 show the effectiveness of this method.
Critical weaknesses
- Stiefel manifold is usually denoted as instead of .
- Equation (2) is not density matrix. The density matrix is generally defined by . I also did not find the exact equation in [1] that you referred to. This is also used in your loss definition
- Flow matching itself is defined in the Euclidean space. Please cite Riemannian flow matching [2], quotient space diffusion [3] and related works to make equation (8) and your Appendix more meaningful.
- For your inference geodesic walk, I cannot understand from your writing line 270-305 that you are walking from the initial point t=0 directly to all other time points like what QHFlow did, or you are walking under successive time frames. Your line 296 shows you walk successively, while your line 300 and Figure 2 suggest the other. I also do not recommend introducing jargon like "quantum prefix-scan" as the word "quantum" does not make sense here.
- In Figure 1, what are the black curves and red curves crossing the horizontal space? Similarly, the black curve in Figure 2.
- Please cite QHNetv2 [4] and its results.
[1] Eric Cancès and Gero Friesecke. Density Functional Theory. Springer, 2023.
[2] Chen, Ricky TQ, and Yaron Lipman. "Flow matching on general geometries." International Conference on Learning Representations. Vol. 2024. 2024.
[3] Xu, Yixian, et al. "Quotient-space diffusion models." arXiv preprint arXiv:2604.21809 (2026).
[4] Yu, Haiyang, et al. "Efficient prediction of so (3)-equivariant hamiltonian matrices via so (2) local frames." arXiv preprint arXiv:2506.09398 (2025).
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.
We appreciate your careful reading of our work and the constructive suggestions you have offered. We address the points raised in the following response and invite you to share any additional questions or comments as the discussion proceeds.
W1. Stiefel manifold is usually denoted as V_k instead of St.
The notation St is widely adopted in the Kohn–Sham DFT literature[1], and we therefore consider its use appropriate in our formulation.
W2. Equation (2) P=CC†S is not density matrix...
We thank the reviewer for the comment. The conventional AO density matrix is expressed as CC†, while CC†S is also a representation of the density projector in a nonorthogonal basis. Our formulation adopts the latter representation to describe electronic states on the Grassmann manifold, and we will clarify this distanction.
W3. Flow matching itself is defined in the Euclidean space...
Our formulation of Eq. (8) follows directly from the standard Riemannian geometric construction of a pullback metric, as explicitly derived in Appendix B.1. The suggested works are likewise built upon these established geometric foundations, but pursue fundamentally different objectives. Their connection to our approach is therefore limited to sharing certain mathematical concepts, rather than directly enriching the formulation of Eq. (8) or its derivation in the Appendix.
W4. For your inference geodesic walk...
Our method performs successive propagation mathematically, but not sequentially in computation. Specifically, the model predicts the sequence of local propagation operators independently of the intermediate states reconstructed by the scan. Their cumulative compositions are then evaluated in parallel via an associative prefix-scan, yielding all intermediate electronic states from the initial state. Thus, Equation in line 296 describes the mathematical composition of successive updates, whereas Figure 2 illustrates their parallel evaluation.
We understand that the term "quantum prefix-scan" may be ambiguous in this context. To avoid potential confusion and better reflect the underlying geometric structure, We will revise the terminology accordingly.
W5. In Figure 1, what are the black curves...
In Figure 1, the black curves represent gauge fibers corresponding to redundant orbital representations that are identified under the quotient projection onto the Grassmann manifold. The red curves illustrate horizontal directions representing physically meaningful subspace evolution. In Figure 2, the black curve depicts the propagation trajectory of the orbital coefficient matrices predicted by our model. We will clarify these visual elements in the figure captions.
W6. Please cite QHNetv2 and its results...
We intended to include QHNetv2 as an additional baseline. However, upon examining the repository provided in the QHNetv2 paper, we found that its implementation code is still not publicly available, making it difficult to reliably reproduce and evaluate the method. Nevertheless, we will cite QHNetv2 in the related work.
Reference
[1] Altmann, R., Peterseim, D., & Stykel, T. (2024). Riemannian Newton methods for energy minimization problems of Kohn–Sham type. Journal of Scientific Computing, 101(1), 6.