W1. The benefit over existing sensitivity-supervised methods is not clear.
SC-FNO (Behroozi et al., ICLR 2025) already uses sensitivity supervision for PDE surrogates and discusses obtaining sensitivity targets by finite differences. This paper explains the difference between parameter sensitivities and finite-response matching, but does not compare the resulting training methods directly. Given how closely related their objectives are, a matched SC-FNO comparison is needed to establish what the proposed training losses add in practice.
W2. A simple ablation of PhySA's response normalization is missing.
Let the prediction errors at the nominal and perturbed specifications be
e0=A(z)−S(z),eδ=A(zδ)−S(zδ),
and let ΔS=S(zδ)−S(z). The response-matching term in PhySA, for a nominal–perturbed pair, can be written as
=\frac{\|e_{\delta}-e_0\|^2}
{\max\left(\|\Delta S\|^2,\epsilon_{\mathrm{SA}}^2\right)}.$$
A natural baseline is the same difference loss without response normalization:
$$\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{diff}}=\|e_{\delta}-e_0\|^2.$$
This would show whether the normalization itself helps, rather than just adding supervision on response differences. The existing weighted-parametric baseline matches the sampling proportions of nominal and perturbed examples; it does not test this normalization. The comparison should keep the other loss terms and sampling procedure fixed, with reasonably tuned weights for both objectives.
**W3. The downstream value of response fidelity remains untested.**
Parameter inversion, design, and control motivate the proposed diagnostics, but none of these tasks is evaluated. Table 18 reports physical-quantity errors, which is useful, but it does not show whether a lower SAE leads to a better inverse estimate or design decision. This matters because PhySA directly optimizes a loss closely related to SAE, and field accuracy sometimes gets worse. A representative downstream task would help establish when this trade-off is worthwhile.
**W4. The trade-off between field accuracy and response fidelity needs a clearer analysis.**
On the Burgers viscosity task with FNO, PhySA lowers SAE from 0.5006 to 0.1860, but held-out relative $L^2$ error rises from 0.0181 to 0.0292, and SNRE also worsens (Table 11). On Public Burgers, the field-error gains do not pass the paper's multiple-comparison threshold ($q=0.0814$). Results are mainly reported for fixed loss weights. A weight sweep and a field-error-versus-SAE Pareto plot would clarify whether the method offers a better trade-off or simply places more emphasis on response accuracy.
Thank you for your assessment. We have restructured the introduction and main exposition so that readers without prior familiarity with neural PDEs can understand the motivation, core idea, and practical value before encountering the mathematical framework. We begin with a concrete viscosity example, introduce the necessary terminology as it arises, and use that example to guide the explanation of the problem and our training method.
Let us briefly introduce our work in plain terms. A PDE surrogate is a neural network used to approximate a physical simulation. Changing a condition such as fluid viscosity changes the correct solution. Our goal is to teach the model how that solution changes. PhySA therefore trains the predicted difference between two conditions to match the true difference, alongside the usual training on the solutions themselves. It measures the mismatch relative to the size of the true change, so that small physical responses receive appropriate attention.
The theory identifies conditions under which learning these changes, together with an accurate prediction at the reference condition, also limits prediction error between the physical settings used in training. The practical motivation is to support tasks that compare physical settings or infer an unknown parameter from observations.