- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes PIVOT a physics guided neural surrogate adaptation method that learns a probe controller and a local spatial response model to correct the outputs of the surrogate to have lower error and lower PDE residuals. By incorporating physics information, PIVOT outperforms the baseline adaptation methods when doing extrapolation on a variety of benchmarks.
Critical strengths
- The PIVOT experimental results indicate that is it robust to cross-domain extrapolation and the ablation shows that each component of the method leads to real improvement in the final performance.
Critical weaknesses
-
PIVOT is compared to baselines that mostly do not have access to physics information. Besides POTT and F-Adapter, the other baselines are generic methods that don't receive the physics residual information as input. I think a comparison with a method that directly does physics informed output correction would highlight the advantages of probing based correction vs physics informed output correction.
-
The method is difficult to follow from the manuscript text and took a significant amount of effort to understand. There are many components to the correction process that are explained at a high level, but the details are missing or unclear. For example, the training and inference process differ but it's hard to parse which components are part of training and inference. A potential way to make this clearer would be to add a training algorithm and an inference algorithm to the appendix detailing how each component works and fits together.
Questions for authors
Does virtual probing outperform alternative ways of exploiting the same target physics, given the same frozen operator and target observations? Comparing PIVOT to a physics-informed LoRA or another physics-guided adapter that uses the same frozen surrogate will answer this question. For example the paper A Benchmark and Physics-Informed Optimization of LoRA for SAR Target Recognition proposes a physics informed adaptation method called Pi-ConvDoRA.