- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2(−1)
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
onsiders sliding-mode control of uncertain reaction–diffusion systems with semi-Markov switching. An FNO is used to estimate matched uncertainties and is combined with a dynamic event-triggered controller. The authors establish stability results under a bounded prediction residual assumption and use numerical simulations to evaluate prediction accuracy and control effort.
Critical strengths
The idea of using an FNO to estimate matched uncertainties, rather than directly learning controller gains, is reasonable. It provides a useful way to combine learned compensation with robust PDE control. The stability analysis is also fairly detailed, and the reported reductions in control effort and input fluctuations are encouraging.
Critical weaknesses
-
My main concern is the novelty. Learning unknown disturbances and compensating for them is a well-established idea in robust control. The paper applies this idea to PDE systems using a largely standard FNO, together with existing sliding-mode control and event-triggered techniques. While the combination is useful, I am not fully convinced that it offers a sufficiently new methodological contribution. In particular, the connection between prediction accuracy and closed-loop performance could be better established.
-
I also have concerns about the theoretical assumption and experimental comparisons. Assumption 2 requires a uniform bound on the prediction residual for all time, whereas the bound used in the simulations is obtained from validation data with an empirical factor of 1.25. The authors acknowledge that this does not certify the assumption. In addition, the FNO performs only slightly better than U-Net in Table 1 (0.003245 vs. 0.003351). Although Table 2 reports substantial improvements, the controller without NO uses an analytical bound on the full uncertainty, while the proposed controller uses an empirically calibrated residual bound. It is unclear whether the reported improvements would remain as substantial under comparable robustness guarantees.
Questions for authors
-
Since the residual bound is calibrated from validation data, how can Assumption 2 be verified or enforced during deployment? What happens to the stability guarantees when the actual prediction residual exceeds this bound?
-
Why does the controller without NO use an analytical bound on the full uncertainty, while the proposed method uses an empirically calibrated residual bound? Would the improvements in control energy and total variation remain under comparable calibration procedures or robustness guarantees?
-
Could the authors clarify the main methodological contribution relative to existing neural-operator-based PDE control and learning-assisted sliding-mode control? Beyond using an FNO for uncertainty estimation, what aspects of the approach can be generalized to other learning-based control problems?
4 comments
Response to Reviewer QWH3
3. Comparable calibration, analytic protection, and estimator comparisons
We added matched-calibration and analytic-bound comparisons to test whether the benefits depend on how the margin is chosen.
-
Same calibration rule. Both controllers use 1.25 times their mode-wise maximum validation residual: for FNO and for Zero (no compensation). Margins are fixed before testing on 50 paired trajectories per condition.
Test condition FNO control energy Zero control energy FNO sampled TV Zero sampled TV Original setup 295.29 350.18 171.97 13,485.81 Combined changes 575.91 634.41 270.49 12,748.28 Combined changes comprise a 1.5× multi-frequency initial field, doubled switching rates, and rotating uncertainty directions. With the same calibration rule, FNO retains 15.7% and 9.2% energy savings, respectively, and over 97% lower TV. These comparisons are reported in Section 5.5 (Table 4); see Appendix D.5 for complete protocols and results.
-
Analytic uncertainty protection. We also retain FNO compensation while covering its residual by . Full-bound No-NO disables compensation and uses .
Test condition FNO control energy Full-bound No-NO energy FNO sampled TV Full-bound No-NO TV Original setup 382.96 369.13 16,217.76 16,044.30 Combined changes 671.92 653.50 15,398.60 15,207.59 The matched-calibration results demonstrate the value of FNO: compensating uncertainty enables a smaller residual margin and lower control costs. The full analytic bound does not exploit this smaller residual, so the same energy and TV savings are not retained. See Appendix D.5 for the analytic-bound comparison details.
-
Broader estimator comparison. We compare six methods on the same 50 in-distribution and 50 rotating-direction OOD trajectories under the same information constraints. All 600 runs meet the terminal criterion; the table reports OOD results.
Method Mean residual Control energy Sampled TV Transmissions Estimator time (ms) FNO 0.020826 293.22 171.98 46.84 5.089 U-Net 0.021775 292.73 173.41 50.76 4.081 SD-DOB 0.021934 401.82 19,567.03 4,062.72 0.0868 Adaptive RLS 0.030270 349.54 13,520.68 3,906.88 0.1196 Zero predictor 0.028934 348.40 13,480.85 3,886.88 0.0129 Full-bound No-NO — 367.39 16,022.94 3,978.18 — FNO and U-Net have comparable in-distribution residuals; on rotating-direction OOD paths, FNO achieves 4.4% lower mean residuals and 7.7% fewer transmissions. Relative to SD-DOB and RLS, FNO reduces control energy by 27.0% and 16.1%, respectively. We select FNO for its balance of prediction accuracy, control smoothness, and communication efficiency under intermittent state transmission. See Section 5.3 (Table 2) and Appendix D.4 for the comparison and implementation details.
In summary, we added matched-calibration and analytic-bound comparisons and causal-design ablations, and clarified deployment calibration and fallback. These revisions address comparison fairness, identify the source of the control-cost reductions, and show what the causal design contributes.
References
[1] Bhan, Shi, and Krstic. Neural Operators for Bypassing Gain and Control Computations in PDE Backstepping. IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, 2024.
[2] Li et al. A novel learning-based asynchronous sliding mode control for discrete-time semi-Markov jump systems. Automatica, 2022.
[3] Cheng et al. Neural Network-Based Sliding Mode Control for Semi-Markov Jumping Systems With Singular Perturbation. IEEE Transactions on Cybernetics, 2025.
[4] Holl et al. Learning to Control PDEs with Differentiable Physics. ICLR, 2020.
I apologize for the confusion. Due to an error in my visibility settings, you were unable to see my previous comment. Thank you for your efforts in preparing the rebuttal. You have addressed most of my concerns. After reading the responses to the other reviewers, I am inclined to raise my score from 2 to 3 based on the quality of your rebuttal. However, the major remaining issue is that the presentation style and clarity of the figures, tables, and visualizations still leave considerable room for improvement. Therefore, I will maintain my current score for now.
The overall quality of the manuscript has improved substantially. I encourage you to consider submitting it to another journal or conference.
Thank you very much for your time and thoughtful feedback. If you feel that our responses and revisions have addressed your concerns, we would be sincerely grateful if you could consider updating your assessment and rating accordingly. We would be happy to clarify any remaining questions and greatly appreciate your consideration.
Response to Reviewer QWH3
Thank you for your careful assessment. We have clarified the guarantees and added the following comparisons.
1. Assumption 2 and exceedance
Each mode's margin is 1.25 times its maximum validation residual ∥ri−si∥L2, fixed before testing.
In simulation, calibration uses the simulator's known uncertainty. For physical deployment, commissioning data would be needed to measure the unknown input independently or reconstruct it from measured state evolution, the nominal dynamics, and applied control. We would compare this with the applied FNO compensation, add any known reconstruction-error bound to the margin, and reassess it using new measurements when conditions change. See Appendix D.1 for calibration details.
If the margin is exceeded, its stability guarantee no longer applies; this does not itself imply instability: all 200 runs meet the terminal regulation criterion. The threefold margin retains 17.4% lower energy and 85.2% lower control total variation (TV) than full-bound No-NO. See Appendix D.5 for the complete margin-sweep results.
On 50 rotating-direction out-of-distribution (OOD) paths, a causal monitor checks completed-interval residual anchors. An alert disables compensation and selects full-bound No-NO using rˉi. Mean exceedance time with compensation active falls 0.2603→0.0282 s (89.2%), with 17.0% less energy than always-full-bound operation. This mitigates violations but does not enforce Assumption 2. FNO uses smaller residual margins to reduce control costs; full-bound No-NO remains the conservative alternative. See Section 5.5 and Appendix D.3 for monitoring and fallback details.
2. Methodological contribution and transferability
Relative to gain learning [1], learned PDE control [4], and finite-dimensional SMC [2,3], we estimate spatial uncertainty in switching PDEs from intermittent states. See Appendix E for the comparison with related work.
Between transmissions, the predictor uses model-propagated states, past interval residual estimates, and mode/sojourn-time information. Deployment gates regulate when compensation is applied. The gain hi(t)=ϵˉi+χi(t)+δi separately covers the remaining prediction residual, state-holding error, and reaching margin.
To quantify these design choices, all variants use the same 287,362-parameter FNO and three training seeds. Validation-selected checkpoints are evaluated on 50 paired rotating-direction OOD trajectories. The main ablations are reported in Section 5.5 (Table 5); see Appendix D.7 for the complete results.
Removing switching inputs raises the calibrated margin to 7.46 times its original value and control energy by 35.7%; replacing propagation with held states raises residuals by 71.4%; removing gates raises transmissions by 37.7%. The margin sweep in Question 1 keeps the trained FNO unchanged and shows that larger margins increase control and communication costs.
The generalizable idea is to predict and compensate the unknown term using only available information, then design the robust term to cover the remaining prediction error and state-holding error. Other estimators can replace FNO if they satisfy the same information and residual-bound conditions, with an appropriate stability analysis for the target system.