- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes using learnable quadrilateral planes for non-volumetric primitive based 3D reconstruction improve the fine geometry and appearance reconstruction capabilities while also inheriting the efficient rasterization property of non-volumetric primitive based 3D reconstruction models. The claimed contributions are the (1) quadrilateral primitive and its respective appearance modeling, (2) training framework including planar-convex retraction, (3) and improvement of reconstruction metrics PSNR SSIM LPIPS on indoor Mip-Nerf 360 and NeRF Synthetic when comparing with Triangle Splatting and 2DGS. The authors also include remarks on rendering speed and geometric quality, but rendering speed is slower than its non-volumetric competitors and no comparison with volumetric representations and no quantitative comparison for geometric accuracy is available to back the claims. Especially, the paper repeatedly highlights the lack of flexibility of Triangle Splatting in reconstructing fine detail geometry and appearance and claims that the proposed quadrilateral primitives are more flexible in doing so, but there is no logical or empirical evidence to support this, apart from the qualitative comparisons in Figures 6,7,8 which is insufficient. Moreover, the paper fails in showing that non-volumetric representation is important at all.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
-
Unclear advantage of proposed method. It seems that the only advantage of this method is reconstruction quality for indoor scenes. If so, the paper should be written with the focus on indoor scenes, which it currently isn’t. If there is a tradeoff that would make the proposed method better applicable in particular situations it should be mentioned. Otherwise the quantitative comparisons show - with comparison to quite outdated methods - no improvement in overall reconstruction quality while also being large in model size and slower in rendering speed.
-
Lack of related work and comparisons. More comparison should be made with both volumetric and non-volumetric representations to show the advantage of non-volumetric representations when compared to volumetric methods, and the superiority - in any aspect - when compared with other recent non-volumetric representations. Related Works section and Experiments section should include recent works like Radiant Triangle Soup (Burgdorfer and Mordohai, 2025), Deformable Beta Splatting (Liu et al., 2025), Nexels (Rong et al., 2025), or explain why the comparison is limited to Triangle Splatting and 2DGS. Currently the paper seems to lack study in relevant literature, and need clear demonstration of the advantage of the proposed method in relation to recent literature.
Questions for authors
-
Inconsistent terminology or unclear expressions in the paper should be made consistent, clearly defined or revised. What does the following mean: “local point spacing” “primitive adaptation process” “auxiliary shell points” “bilinear spatial residuals” “local child domains” “in-plane displacement” “insufficiently observed” “boundary/edge falloff”
-
What triggers the split, clone and pruning of the quadrilateral primitives? Why are these methods adequate for quadrilateral primitives?
-
What is the model size and number of primitives for NeRF Synthetic comparison? (Table 2) Does the improvement in PSNR SSIM LPIPS accompany larger model size and slower rendering speed? What is the model size, number of primitives for Outdoor/Indoor Mip-NeRF 360? The improvement in PSNR SSIM LPIPS for Indoor Mip-NeRF 360 in Table 1 could be due to larger model size.
Minor questions / suggestions for future work:
-
The paper could be restructured to put less important details like dataset or evaluation metrics details in the appendix to have more important details like “primitive adaptation” or ablation tables included in the main paper.
-
The meanings of equation 2 and equation 3 should be explained. Currently it only defines the variables and there is insufficient explanation of why equation 2 is derived (equation 2). Define gamma_u and gamma_v. Elaborate on what the update to d does to the quadrilateral (equation 3).